Playing the saxophone Tonguing and vibrato

So when you lightly tongue are you saying du du and still hitting the reed but not enough to actually block the air? I'm so confused now having to think about when and when not to tongue! Because I play by ear and don't usually think about tonguing.

You have explained really well though, thanks for your help. I also loved your interpretation.

@Pete Thomas thanks Pete that's very helpful. I guess it's just a matter of getting used to tonguing and feeling when and when not to use it. I'm so aware of my tongue now when I play lol, it's putting me off a bit but I suppose it's just practice. I actually feel like I'm supposed to tongue every note now as a default which is probably wrong too, but overthinking it I guess...
I would try to think of it more in terms of stopping the reed from vibrating than blocking air, even though it may be the same thing. In ghost tonguing, for example the tongue is resting on the reed, yet still allowing it to vibrate. Light tonguing is a degree more than that, where the reed stops, even if just for a couple of milliseconds. As you move toward stacatto, the tongue simply stays on the reed longer. The pressurized air needs to be ready to go when you release your tongue, but not so much as to get a blatty sound.

I'm a big believer in experimenting while thinking ONLY about the result, not the means. In other words don't think about what your tongue is doing, rather concentrate on the sound you're making. Your body will do what it needs to do to make that sound. When you're happy with it, repeat over and over until it's automatic. I have to admit that I have never once thought about what my tongue, lips, mouth, throat and embouchure are doing. Only when someone asks, do I try to analyze it and explain. I focus only on the resulting sound.
 
Last edited:
Knowing the piece would help but two different people can read that same piece and still tongue it at different times
I posted a page of "He Ain't Heavy He's My brother" by the Hollies which is one of the songs I'm working on. I have many songs, I just pick one out of my library and try and play it by ear. "Somewhere Over the Rainbow" is another one. "How Deep Is Your Love", "Yellow" by Coldplay. That sort of thing.
 
Well, start by tonguing the beginning of each phrase. Am I correct to posit that you typically don’t tongue at all, but instead rely on a breath attack? Have some Fun with Phrasing. Practice a phrase you know. Now articulate it randomly but mindfully. Break it into subgroups of notes, and lightly tongue the first note of each subgroup. It’ll make more sense when you try it.

If you practice scales, you can just make up rules for each time you play them. Tongue every group of four, or the first and second of each group of four, etc.



And hopefully each would hear the difference. One will certainly sound more musical than the other.

The path to change starts with awareness.
I didn't tongue at all before no, it was always a breath attack (unless I kinda did it a bit without noticing). I had another little practice earlier and it's getting a bit easier. I sounded better before though, much smoother. But I realise tonguing is the proper way and in the long run is going to sound much better.
 
@Colin the Bear yeh good point, there is too much overthinking going on with it. But it's a new skill so I'm hoping it'll be natural enough soon, just a weird way of playing for me (but the right way!) I found some old recordings of Somewhere Over the Rainbow on here so I've been giving them a listen for ideas.
 
I'm also attempting to learn vibrato and note bending, I can bend down about a tone from the high notes-is this enough for vibrato and/or note bending or should I be bending more than a tone?
Absolutely enough for vibrato. Actual vibrato will be a lot less than a whole tone.The important thing is to have control over both pitch and timing. Gradually do the exercise faster until it's vibrato type speed (which can vary to taste) and by the time it's a vibrato rather than a bend it tis much shallower in pitch change (again the actual depth of the vibrato bend is down to your taste.

For practising bending per se then as far as you can go is a good exercise.
 
As you move toward stacatto, the tongue simply stays on the reed longer. The pressurized air needs to be ready to go when you release your tongue, but not so much as to get a blatty sound.
I agree and would add that the tongue, whether used to stop the air by touching the reed tip or starting the air be removing should be as unobtrusive as possible, ie you just hear a note stop of start cleanly so there is no attack sound, unless that is what you or the composer wants , e.g. if it is an accent.
 
More thoughts on vibrato and bending. On sax, we typically use jaw vibrato which is a chewing motion. It is used very sparingly these days. But it depends on the style of music. For pop/standards, I'd play those straight with maybe a little terminal vibrato. Only ballads would have sustained vibrato, and not very wide, if you're playing with a modern sensibility.

But if you're playing music from the 20s and 30s, there is a lot of wide, fast vibrato on just about everything except unison lines. However, do follow what your section leader is doing. I understand that this does not apply to your situation right now, but it would if you ever joined a band.

Bending is also out of style these days. Old music had a lot of bending. But these days (since the 60s), grace notes are used where you would have done bending in the old days. Regardless of the style, over using bends sounds bad and amateurish.

While you do usually move the jaw when bending, most of the effect comes from inside the mouth by changing the angle and speed of the airstream with the shape of the tongue and throat, similar to how a harmonica player does bends. And some notes on sax bend much more widely and easily than others. Many notes can't really be bent at all. You're not going to be able to bend a low Bb, for example.

Back to tonguing, since you have always used a breath attack, I can see how this will be a challenge for you. Old habits are hard to break. You may want to explore the doodle tonguing technique which may help ease you into a more natural way of tonguing, as if you were speaking. As a jazz player, this is the way I tongue fast passages, and it's an easy transition into normal tonguing.
 
A very small remark from a late beginner. Sometimes i found I was tonging to get a note to sound properly, maybe for some long jumps and such. Practicing clean sounding transitions without tonging, at least, gives you the option of tongue for musical rather than technical reasons.
 
While you do usually move the jaw when bending, most of the effect comes from inside the mouth by changing the angle and speed of the airstream with the shape of the tongue and throat,
I would say I use both. The throat one is only viable for me on high notes.

Sometimes i found I was tonging to get a note to sound properly, maybe for some long jumps and such.
Yes, in cases like this tonguing (or too hard a tonguing) is employed when the note is difficult because of a leak. In an ideal world tonguing is used purely for expression, nut to be a bandaid for am instrument not working well.
 
Absolutely enough for vibrato. Actual vibrato will be a lot less than a whole tone.The important thing is to have control over both pitch and timing. Gradually do the exercise faster until it's vibrato type speed (which can vary to taste) and by the time it's a vibrato rather than a bend it tis much shallower in pitch change (again the actual depth of the vibrato bend is down to your taste.

For practising bending per se then as far as you can go is a good exercise.
Thank you, this clears things up for me re vibrato and bends, much appreciated!

Bending is also out of style these days. Old music had a lot of bending. But these days (since the 60s), grace notes are used where you would have done bending in the old days. Regardless of the style, over using bends sounds bad and amateurish.
Yeh I have seen discussion about how new players are overusing bending and it's not good. I can't really do it that well so no problem there for me!

Back to tonguing, since you have always used a breath attack, I can see how this will be a challenge for you. Old habits are hard to break. You may want to explore the doodle tonguing technique which may help ease you into a more natural way of tonguing, as if you were speaking. As a jazz player, this is the way I tongue fast passages, and it's an easy transition into normal tonguing.
I'll check that out, thanks!

So if I'm not using much vibrato or bending what sort of effects should I be using? I can only really think of growling (that's still in fashion right?), I know there's loads of different effects one can use but I mean just for an intermediate player (I hope I can call myself that one day) maybe I'll put a song up and that might help. I need to figure out soundcloud-seems to be what everyone uses on here.

I seem to be tonging quite quickly, on and off the reed quick as I can, I hope this is correct technique.
 
I usually play by ear
(Learn to) sing in the way you want to play it on your sax.

Vibrato? To play the saxophone is just one big vibrato. The growl, flutter tone, vibrato, heavy vibrato, slightly skake your horn with your hands/fingers, just go down a little bit in your knees .... . You just want to reenforce the vibrato of the reed.

Not bending can be done with the lips or with the jaw. Even the keys can be used.

My basic embouchure exercises are:
- Note bending with lips or jaw. I also combine it with long tones.
- Legato without tongue. Start on C2 and the play C3 and back to C2. Then B2, Bb2 ..... in the same way. If you can, don't use the octave key.
- "Bricks".
- Staccato. You are into pop, blues, R&B, rock? Think the tongue is the drumstick and the reed is the snaredrum.
- Overtones.

I try to do two of these exercises before I play/practice.

Here is the video "When the other horn placer doesn't show up" by Andrew Clark. Maybe some ideas you can pick up?
View: https://youtu.be/77ItPk6Oed8
 
I just changed reed and it's sooo much easier to tongue! I had no idea my reed was so bad or old (about 3 weeks?) anyway it sucked and this new one is so much easier to tongue with and play!
Making progress. With experience you'll get better at determining when a reed is worn out.

Make sure you put the reed on properly as well. You should see just a sliver of mouthpiece at the tip, Reed should not be flush with the end, overhanging the end or showing more than a sliver of mouthpiece except under special circumstances.
 
@lydian yeh, I was wondering why I was progressively sounding worse than when I first got my new sax a few weeks ago :headscratch: but what with practicing tonguing I thought it was due to that. What a difference a new reed makes! I sound so much more in tune as well. Ugh sax is not like the piano you just sit down and play and don't have to think about this, get it tuned once or maybe twice a year that's it!

Gotta admit I'm bad with technical stuff and details, maybe sax isn't for me even as a hobby 😛 everything was a struggle to play earlier, and my first thought was "I've wrecked my new sax already, it's got a leak or something" then I changed the reed and voila! Haha I'm so dense, oh well I'll know now.

Thanks for the mouthpiece tips as well :thumb:
 
Saxophone is different every day.
It takes preparation and skill and dedication.
60 years in and I'm still an improver.

If you're struggling with the whole concept of making music with a slice of grass, that changes by the second, perhaps synthetic is the way to go.
Many prefer the consistency.
Me, I don't like the taste. :confused:
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,062
Messages
578,402
Members
8,129
Latest member
Bartman
Back
Top Bottom