Tech/maintenance Thumb Hook - Vintage to Modern... How?

DavidUK

Well-Known Member
Messages
8,133
Location
Near Evesham, Worcestershire
I just finished re-padding a previously unplayable 50's Beaugnier tenor.

Plays fine, although unsurprisingly not as well as its Yani or Yamaha room-mates.

Part of this could be due to distraction as it gives me noticable discomfort via its original thumb hook compared to the more modern adjustable thumb hooks of the others, PLUS the positioning of the Beaugnier's hook (centre below) is slightly further to the left, smaller, and lower down...

20241028_124911.webp

20241028_112338.webp


My immediate thoughts are to have a more modern adjustable hook fitted in a similar position. Something like this?...

Screenshot 2024-10-28 at 21.55.06.webp
Screenshot 2024-10-28 at 21.55.17.webp


If I go this route I'd need to get a tech to solder it on. I'm not bothered by the scar or lacquer loss as the horn has patina already. As an aside I'm currently using a strong 2 part metal to metal structural adhesive with 15.0 N/mm² shear strength but feel a little nervous doing a DIY bond on such an important fixture.

Any other suggestions aside from this route? One of these perhaps...

Screenshot 2024-10-28 at 22.05.43.webp


Thanks for any input.

🙂
 
You say that the Beaugnier hook is lower down and it does seem further away from the F# (trill) tone hole above it. But that tone hole looks to be unusually high compared with other saxes, so maybe isn't the best point of comparison.

I guess that a better way of judging its position is relative to all the RH pearls, side keys and other touch points.

Rhys
 
Not much weight on a thumb hook and not the end of the world if it works loose. It's a convenience not a necessity.

Some of those eBay replacements aren't as comfortable as they look. I found them very small, although I do have chunky thumbs. I had to reshape one for the Jupiter straight sop. I played it without a thumb hook for a while.

I find the unadjustable Yam thumb hooks very comfortable. If the original can't be relocated I'd consider having it replaced with a Yam.
 
I have this Yamaha Vito tenor, with unadjustable thumb hook, to re-pad also...

Screenshot 2024-10-29 at 12.03.12.webp


I'll try it when completed to see how it feels. Note rods and screws were left in for soda blasting. I took them out for the 21 alto and soda got into all the threads. Removeable with a damp pipe cleaner but a pain to go over it.
 
Music Medic sell a nice one that's adjustable vertically, at least a bit. That's the one I'd pick. Then use duct tape or double sided tape to temporarily fix it to get your desired location, then mark around the base plate with a pencil and off to the tech.

I wish someone would reproduce the Martin adjustable hook. That one has enough adjustment range to be worthwhile.
 
Thomann sels the Ton Kooiman thumb rest Forza as an ergomical based design. Never tried it but a teacher at the Rotterdam conservatorium said it to be ok. Afterwards he added that the original design was without a recognisable hook based on the idea that the left thumb only has to press forward. It didn't sell until he added a recognisable hook.
I think its overprized.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,064
Messages
578,438
Members
8,130
Latest member
tommyliehe
Back
Top Bottom