Intonation Theatres, Clubs and Tuning

Veggie Dave

Sax Worker
Messages
3,466
Location
Citizen of Nowhere
I'm wondering how those of you who play theatres, clubs etc. make sure you're always in tune?

My experience up to now is that you just have to lip up, or more usually down, if you're able to hear a problem, which isn't really a solution. It's not like we can retune between songs like guitarists can. I've found backstage and in the wings can have dramatically different temperatures to what's on stage. Yes, you'd expect the stage to be warmer but I've had times where the temp has been much, much colder than the stage just a few feet away; if you've got your horns there, the tuning is going to be painfully sharp within a couple of minutes of hitting the stage.

I've thought about leaving the horns on stage but that makes warming up before the show impossible unless you take the horns backstage, where the temperature could be massively different, so by the time you go on stage you'll still have the same tuning issues anyway.

Thankfully my Keilwerth doesn't suffer from this temperature tuning issue anywhere near as badly as my old Trevor James did but two years of on-stage tuning issues with the TJ has made me (possibly over) paranoid.
 
My experience up to now is that you just have to lip up, or more usually down, if you're able to hear a problem, which isn't really a solution. It's not like we can retune between songs like guitarists can.
Do you have a clip-on tuner ? In between songs would it be possible to step back from the mic, even move away from the band and bell away from audience, quickly clip and turn it on for a quick test ? Just a thought.....
 
Lol. Ever tried playing outdoors at sundrenched beach, "Horn getting almost burny hot in your mitts ,"

You tune on the fly in both directions during whatever number you are playing but great fun non the less. Aaah.
It's dealing with a horn killed by cold damp UK summer ,winter weather that often beats me trying to breathe life and intonation back into the situation. L Ol.
 
Lol. Ever tried playing outdoors at sundrenched beach, "Horn getting almost burny hot in your mitts ,"
Had that once when playing in France... had to walk off stage as the sax had become completely untunable (being a 1930s Conn it wasn't great tuning to start with but the direct, mid afternoon French sun put it way out)
 
If you watch professionals and experienced players in a live performance, they often move the mouthpiece slightly on or off the cork during rests to make pitch adjustments. To do so easily requires that the cork to be properly fit to the mouthpiece shank and have a bit of cork grease. I will often "lip" notes up or down to match pitch and then as soon as possible move the mouthpiece so that is no longer necessary or doesn't need to be done as much.
 
If you watch professionals and experienced players in a live performance, they often move the mouthpiece slightly on or off the cork during rests to make pitch adjustments. To do so easily requires that the cork to be properly fit to the mouthpiece shank and have a bit of cork grease. I will often "lip" notes up or down to match pitch and then as soon as possible move the mouthpiece so that is no longer necessary or doesn't need to be done as much.

You do see that very often if you watch decent sax players playing live. It emphasises the importance of being able to hear whether you are in tune with other instruments, rather than relying on a tuner showing you. It is also important to know the intonation characteristics of your own instrument.

Here's Sonny Rollins quickly adjusting his mouthpiece position about 13 seconds into a song.


With experience, you develop a feeling for how far to move the mouthpiece in/out to correct being flat/sharp by roughly how many cents (or how much lipping down/up).

Rhys
 
Do you have a clip-on tuner ? In between songs would it be possible to step back from the mic

If you absolutely have to then you could do this but there would have to be very little noise so as not to confuse the tuner. But I'm looking more for how you can make sure you walk on stage in tune.

Lol. Ever tried playing outdoors at sundrenched beach, "Horn getting almost burny hot in your mitts ,"

I used to go on cross-country walks during summer, playing to backing tracks on my phone. A great way to get a tan and some exercise while practising.

It's dealing with a horn killed by cold damp UK summer ,winter weather that often beats me trying to breathe life and intonation back into the situation. L Ol.

I was asked to play with a friend's sax learner group a couple of years ago (to add some omph to the proceedings, apparently). It was about 3C.

They were on stage and mic'd, while I got to stand at the side and play flat out to be heard.

brentwood.webp


If you watch professionals and experienced players in a live performance, they often move the mouthpiece slightly on or off the cork during rests to make pitch adjustments.

This is fine if you have an on-stage mix that allows you to hear yourself well enough to make finite adjustments. Up to now I've rarely had this luxury. πŸ˜‰

But what I'm looking for is how players make sure they walk on stage knowing that at least the first song will be spot on.
 
This is fine if you have an on-stage mix that allows you to hear yourself well enough to make finite adjustments. Up to now I've rarely had this luxury. πŸ˜‰

But what I'm looking for is how players make sure they walk on stage knowing that at least the first song will be spot on.
I have never experienced playing in a setting where I could not hear my own pitch. Occasionally when everyone in a large ensemble are all tuning (loudly) at the same time [trumpets 😱] I insert my finger into one ear to cut the sound waves in the air so I can hear the sound through "bone conduction"
 
I have never experienced playing in a setting where I could not hear my own pitch.

I wish I could say the same. I posted about one particular gig on here a few years back, where I was stood at the side of the stage trying to play along to a song the band was playing to make sure I was in tune before walking onto the stage. It was so loud I couldn't even tell if the sax was making a noise, never mind what note it was.

It was the last time I went on stage without ear protection and also the last time I worked with that sound engineer.
 
I think you're on a bit of a hiding to nothing, Dave. I understand to a degree the world of amplified stage music and the difficulties of personal monitoring and it's limitations without a dedicated monitor engineer (probably even with, I've never had the luxury)


I wonder though if the hectic mix of on stage noises and reverberations might actually play into your favour and make it much more difficult for the audience to even notice if you're a bit flat or sharp (would most notice anyway?)

You could always adopt the habit of regularly putting your hand on your mouthpiece and making as though you're moving the piece in small increments and looking a bit unhappy with things. In the unlikely event anyone in the audience is able to pick up you're a bit out of tune, that might convince them you're trying to do something about it..πŸ˜‰
 
You could always adopt the habit of regularly putting your hand on your mouthpiece and making as though you're moving the piece in small increments and looking a bit unhappy with things. In the unlikely event anyone in the audience is able to pick up you're a bit out of tune, that might convince them you're trying to do something about it..πŸ˜‰

Ah, the guitarist approach - always glare at your amp every time you make a mistake. πŸ˜€
 
I wish I could say the same. I posted about one particular gig on here a few years back, where I was stood at the side of the stage trying to play along to a song the band was playing to make sure I was in tune before walking onto the stage. It was so loud I couldn't even tell if the sax was making a noise, never mind what note it was.

If you have difficulty hearing the sax how do you know it's out of tune enough to worry about ?

I don't think I've ever played in a situation that loud, but an acoustic Soundback plexiglass reflector on the microphone was very useful for hearing enough of my sax and not to be dependent on any sound engineer for tuning (but you still depend on them for your sound out front). You can also get a similar reflector that clips to the bell of a sax, but they look a little weird to the audience.

Rhys
 
Last edited:
If you have difficulty hearing the sax how do you know it's out of tune enough to worry about ?

I don't think I've ever played in a situation that loud, but an acoustic Soundback plexiglass reflector on the microphone was very useful for hearing enough of my sax and not to be dependent on any sound engineer. You can also get a similar reflector that clips to the bell of a sax, but they look a little weird to the audience.

Rhys

Good point, what about something like this..

 
Bleeding expensive (like other stuff from RAT). Also a bit more obtrusive than one that fits around the microphone on its stand. But just the same idea.

Rhys

If the monitor mix ain't up to much, I'm not sure if a screen around the mic would do much. Only Dave could confirm that I guess.

Yes that product is expensive for what it is, but could be used as a template for a bit of DIY.
 
The Soundback on the mic stand reflects sound and is completely independent of the monitor mix. As I said, I used it on many gigs and it worked well for me, but the stage was never quite as noisy as he described.

Rhys

Ahh, so it's a reflector thing you were referring to. Thought it was to direct more sound into the mic. My bad!
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway πŸ˜€

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,057
Messages
578,243
Members
8,127
Latest member
PJ2116
Back
Top Bottom