Saxophones The Alphabet of Tone

Pete - I ain't an ignorant fool. I know capitals are deemed by some as Shouting and by others as Emphasis. I assume you've noticed my capitals are emphasis and if not I deem you a fool or an argumentative annoyance. We're discussing (ideally) tone.
We're not discussing Desond - we are we - we're trying to find common ground and what WE relate to as teminolgy regarding saxophonic tonal character. If you don't wish to contribute in a constructive manner OR if you find yourself inclined to be argumentative please comment elsewhere.
 
Those whom differ in education or cultural exposure….the way they were taught ?
But this was my point, but in relation to compiling some sort of list - an Alphabet of Sound - (the "scientific" part) or are we just sharing descriptive words?

My wish to prune comes from having too much flowery language attached to music that can obscure or hamper understanding (music is difficult enough, right). I once had a harmony lecturer who loved the use of language. He frequently baffled virtually the whole class. This is where I'm coming from and is the root of my non - understanding of all the similar words being thrown around without attachment.
 
But it needs to be reined in, or it’s not useful.

reined in? what precisely 'needs" reining in?

But at the end of it all, there will be so many similar words that any Alphabet of Tone - a glossary - becomes unuseable.
Perhaps it needs to be taken less seriously. It could be useful in some aspects, less useful in others but may nonetheless a fun exercise.
If hairs are being split being "sweet" and "warm", and we can easily add ten more words for each; where does it stop? And what is the purpose
I think there are really only a couple or very few words that will be unanimously accepted. I remember being a bit miffed at people using the word dark to describe what I considered warm. I used dark to mean something else, not necessarily to mean fewer higher overtones or more fundamental which is how I explain warm.
 
I think there are really only a couple or very few words that will be unanimously accepted. I remember being a bit miffed at people using the word dark to describe what I considered warm. I used dark to mean something else, not necessarily to mean fewer higher overtones or more fundamental which is how I explain warm.
Which is my argument. Though I'm obviously a fool for thinking as much. Two P's (ete's) in a pod then 😎
 
Warm
Dull
Dark
Mellow
All basically mean somewhat lacking overtones/harmonics.
Agreed (possibly with the exception of dark but that is my own subjective view)
Bright
Nasal
Shrill
Plenty of overtones/harmonics
I wonder though if nasal could rather be plenty of mid frequencies and so lacking in more extreme high and low. Possibly what sound engineers might refer to as boxy?
 
We're discussing (ideally) tone.
We're not discussing Desond - we are we - we're trying to find common ground and what WE relate to as teminolgy regarding saxophonic tonal character.
Ya see... throwing words around with no examples isn't useful. If someone talks about a dark sound then it would be helpful to give an example.
 
Pete - it can take ages for an emerging sax player to comprehend terminology such as warm or dark, focused or spread. They will need enough experience with various instruments to realise how different one sax can be when compared to another. Consciously or sub-conscioulously they're aware of tone and to what extent that tone truly expresses themselves. They'll explore mouthpieces and eventually realise the mouthpiece is just a piece of the puzzle not unlike a carburetor to an engine.
It doesn't matter how wonderful the carbureter is if the engine doesn't have substance


​

 
@Pete Effamy
Honestly dude you need to take a time out ! Time offline or a few days away with family or friends.
Your recent replies everywhere seem like you’re personally stressed.
Chill some, relax and think about the subject.
What can you add to the betterment of global understanding on this thread ?

The needs of definition.

This isn’t a debate about old subjects.
 
@Pete Effamy
Honestly dude you need to take a time out ! Time offline or a few days away with family or friends.
Your recent replies everywhere seem like you’re personally stressed.
Chill some, relax and think about the subject.
What can you add to the betterment of global understanding on this thread ?

The needs of definition.

This isn’t a debate about old subjects.
Interesting how Pete Thomas skirted what I said and yet you don't include him in this. Two pretty personal attacks now.
 
Words that I might have a reasonable stab at deciphering with regard to the sound of a saxphone:

Warm
Dull
Dark
Mellow
All basically mean somewhat lacking overtones/harmonics.

Bright
Nasal
Shrill
Plenty of overtones/harmonics

Words that mean precisely nothing to me:

Focused
Spread
Centred
Core
I read this and think Simon & Garfunkel concerts in the park live. I can’t remember the year ? β€˜68 or β€˜72 ?
I regress as this has nothing to do with sax voice, just vocals. πŸ€”πŸ€”πŸ€”
 
Interesting how Pete Thomas skirted what I said and yet you don't include him in this. Two pretty personal attacks now.
Pete explained and expressed the difficulty of task at hand clearly in the other post. Including the fact that he took time to think about and reflect on past research, posts and experiences. My take from his post…..
1) difficult subject.
2) Globally; feelings to emotions of current or past music is long lasting.
My take on this.
Define mood as a color or tone of sound !

.
 
English/American is the #1 language when it comes to saxes. As a Swede it's important to understand english/american saxophone words.

 
Ya see... throwing words around with no examples isn't useful. If someone talks about a dark sound then it would be helpful to give an example.
This is all discovery. Words to define sounds for all to be understan.
I offered words. A YouTube video to my understanding of those words.
Have you offered the same ???

Loose the attitude. Quit your complaining and pointing fingers at the guy with a goal that needs help.
The goal ?? To have standard words that define sounds of what we do…play saxophone and the sound categories associated.
Try harder to help rather then try to prove wrong or faults.
The thread needs your positive help, not your complaining


Focus on the task at hand.
There’s no Axe to grind,
No wall to climb.
Just globally honest humble people interested in communicating their experiences. What they hear in sound(s. Potentially to make changes for the audience enjoyment.
 
I don’t suppose anyone would care to venture definitions of, say, focused and spread that don’t involve more undefined words like β€˜core’.

A prolonged consideration of such definations will bring clarity.
Focused - Centered -
Spread - Broad

Core IMHO = refers to the inherrent "overall" sound (as opposed to tone) of an instrument

The Core sound of an instrument can be Focused and Dark - OR - Warm and Spread - OR - Bright and Centered
The Core sound is the inherrent characteristic of the instrument plus (usually) the influence of the mouthpiece & reed.
The Core sound "may" be that of the instrument itself - some are warmer - some are darker - some are brighter


​

 
This is all discovery. Words to define sounds for all to be understan.
I offered words. A YouTube video to my understanding of those words.
Have you offered the same ???

Loose the attitude. Quit your complaining and pointing fingers at the guy with a goal that needs help.
The goal ?? To have standard words that define sounds of what we do…play saxophone and the sound categories associated.
Try harder to help rather then try to prove wrong or faults.
The thread needs your positive help, not your complaining


Focus on the task at hand.
There’s no Axe to grind,
No wall to climb.
Just globally honest humble people interested in communicating their experiences. What they hear in sound(s. Potentially to make changes for the audience enjoyment.
Attitude? I'm getting plenty from you, sir. Offer examples myself? Yes - try post number 4.

Loose the attitude. Quit your complaining and pointing fingers at the guy with a goal that needs help.
The goal ?? To have standard words that define sounds of what we do

How can you have standard words when extremely similar words are being proffered regularly, and without any examples in order that anyone might understand any sort of definition? (and therefore choose a particular word).

Pete T said this:

I think there are really only a couple or very few words that will be unanimously accepted.

Thom said this:

English/American is the #1 language when it comes to saxes. As a Swede it's important to understand english/american saxophone words.

So that's quite an insight from a non - native speaker.

Is it not more informative to compile a list of players and then place words descriptive of tone next to them? At least we all know what is being described then.
 
How can you have standard words when extremely similar words are being proffered regularly, and without any examples in order that anyone might understand any sort of definition? (and therefore choose a particular word).

Is it not more informative to compile a list of players and then place words descriptive of tone next to them? At least we all know what is being described then.
This would be ideal. But would also need to demonstrate that in many cases there isn't one definitive word for a specific tone or sound that may be given as an example.

Perhaps what we need is a poll
 
A prolonged consideration of such definations will bring clarity.
Focused - Centered -
Spread - Broad

Core IMHO = refers to the inherrent "overall" sound (as opposed to tone) of an instrument

The Core sound of an instrument can be Focused and Dark - OR - Warm and Spread - OR - Bright and Centered
The Core sound is the inherrent characteristic of the instrument plus (usually) the influence of the mouthpiece & reed.
The Core sound "may" be that of the instrument itself - some are warmer - some are darker - some are brighter



​

Can you now define β€˜centred’ and β€˜broad’?
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,058
Messages
578,303
Members
8,127
Latest member
PJ2116
Back
Top Bottom