Tech/maintenance Talking of tone hole files...

it's pretty obvious that the makers of the instruments (King, Beauginer, US Selmer, Buescher, so far)
didn't get the tone holes very flat, by modern standards. A few tenths of a mm was pretty good, put
soft pads on it, and send it.
So just like over- restoring a 60's automobile that left the factory with
pretty mediocre bodywork, slapdash assembly and parts already failing-
how good SHOULD the toneholes be?
They should be fit for function, which is different for everybody according to: (wo)man is the measure of all things, including tone holes (Protagoras).

I work with the idea that happiness is a good closing saxophone, but I am not into what you call over-, restoring. Small corrections to the tone hole are fine with me.
 
If you took the wavy pad/tone hole theory to extremes you'd find as the angles increased there would be friction lifting the pad away due to the convex pad edge getting "stuck" in the convex tone hole "V" shaped edge, or vice versa.

My experiment with silicone sheet, both solid and foam, quickly ruled it out as a pad material as it tended to want to stick to the tone hole, especially when wet. This may be due to its skin which was very slick.

I've not tried silicone sealant (wouldn't work for my pads) which must behave differently for @Woodpad to continue to use it.
I didn't feel any friction, probably because the contact area of the pad is elevated.

When I started my experiment I made the gamble that I could always find a good sealing material among all different types of plastics. The fourth type of silicone worked. It is possible that there are better types available.

The nice thing about this type of silicone is that it becomes slippery when wet, measured with a piece of brass on a flat silicone surface. .
 
Slippery when wet... have you ever noticed that a suction pad works better when wet and slippery?

The trial silicone pad's tendency to stick to a tone hole is also due to this effect. When I encountered it I used a piece of flat brass, wet, on a disc of flat silicone sheet and noticed how the brass would stick to the silicone.

Take a glossy floor tile and walk on it dry, it's fine, no slipping. Make it slippery and over you go. Now take two wet floor tiles and place them face to face. They want to stick to each other.

I solved the problem by avoiding materials with a flat skin to them.
 
how good SHOULD the toneholes be?
How do you 'fix' something that was never really exact to start with?
Was that 'perfect vintage sound' a result of the way the horn was made, or despite it?
Ideally the toneholes should be perfectly flat.
Will they work if they're not? Yeah, up to a point. You can manipulate pads to follow the curvature of the toneholes and that'll give you a good seal. For a while.
Pads expand and contract over time - and not necessarily evenly - so it really pays to minimize any variables if you're at all interested in long-term reliability.

And sure, you'll get an improvement in the sound with well-set pads - but it tends to be more in terms of volume, evenness and stability rather than a shift in the frequency spectrum (though you might well notice a bit more 'glitter' around the notes).
But what you really get is a noticeable improvement in response. The notes 'pop', you get more of a percussive start to the note, there's less blurring between one note and the next. And the feel of the action improves.

It's most noticeable on baritones. I always advise owners of brand new baritones to have the bell toneholes precision levelled because it really peps up the response on the low notes simply by removing one of the many variables that comes free with every baritone...of which key flex is the most prominent.
 
Slippery when wet... have you ever noticed that a suction pad works better when wet and slippery?

Small experiment
I took a Conn bari and attached a cup to the low C# mechanism with a cord hanging between two levers of the mechanism. Opened and closed the pad several times. Then I put playing cards in the cup. The mechanism opened with a snap at 27 or 26 cards.

Made the pad wet with tap water. Now the mechanism opened with 13 or 14 cards. No suction effect noticed.
 
Ideally the toneholes should be perfectly flat.
Will they work if they're not? Yeah, up to a point. You can manipulate pads to follow the curvature of the toneholes and that'll give you a good seal. For a while.
Pads expand and contract over time - and not necessarily evenly - so it really pays to minimize any variables if you're at all interested in long-term reliability.

And sure, you'll get an improvement in the sound with well-set pads - but it tends to be more in terms of volume, evenness and stability rather than a shift in the frequency spectrum (though you might well notice a bit more 'glitter' around the notes).
But what you really get is a noticeable improvement in response. The notes 'pop', you get more of a percussive start to the note, there's less blurring between one note and the next. And the feel of the action improves.

It's most noticeable on baritones. I always advise owners of brand new baritones to have the bell toneholes precision levelled because it really peps up the response on the low notes simply by removing one of the many variables that comes free with every baritone...of which key flex is the most prominent.
I made a rough estimate of how big the difference in gap size due to the position of the instrument is, for alto and bari, as a short appendix to this answer, just to get a grasp on dimensions.

  1. The gap size is proportional to the diameter of the tone hole.
  2. The deformation is proportional to the weight of the instrument when the instruments are made of the same sheet metal and same thickness.
For such conditions the gaps are 3 times bigger on a bari. When the bari is made of thinner material (0.8 to 0.7 mm) this becomes 4 times (roughly).

It looks like its a good choice to do this for bari's.
 
Each unit is completely different. It’s a judgment call. Often it’s hard to knock something down. given the location it’s easy to raise a little. I try to pick the route that’s the least intrusive. Same as Steve. Always thinking about long-term life of the instrument. It’s a shame to trash one that’s already lived 100 years with good care.
None of this is extremely difficult. Yes a bit of a learning curve. Mostly finesse in tool choice / use. I don’t think you would trim the roses with a chainsaw. Could get ugly.
this is a very interesting discussion/argument. in connection with this aside about roses i can inform you the the royal horticultural society conducted an experiment wherein they pruned roses with a) secateurs and b) a chain flail, like they use on tractors to cut hedges at roadsides. they concluded that each method produced similar results.
 
this is a very interesting discussion/argument. in connection with this aside about roses i can inform you the the royal horticultural society conducted an experiment wherein they pruned roses with a) secateurs and b) a chain flail, like they use on tractors to cut hedges at roadsides. they concluded that each method produced similar results.
No surprise there, the chain saw was originally developed as a medical precision tool.
 
Another thing to watch out for with the bell keys is flex in the keys. Even with the flattest tonehole and the most perfectly seated pad, it sometimes goes that a small leak pops up at the 2 o'clock position (where the outside centre of the pad is 12 o'clock) . When this happens you have to add a bit of 'bias' to the pad to account for the flex - just as is sometimes necessary on the left side of the Aux.F pad to accommodate the tension introduced by the Bis Bb/G# adjusters.
I just noticed another type of flex in the two last bell keys of a tenor saxophone. When my diy silicone pads solidified with the sax in an upright position I could see a difference due to flex all around the tone hole.

In a horizontal position the mark made in the pads where around 0.2 mm too far in the direction of the bell opening. This changed to zero when the saxophone was upright. I think it is the weight of the keys plus some spiel in the mechanism.
 
I just noticed another type of flex in the two last bell keys of a tenor saxophone. When my diy silicone pads solidified with the sax in an upright position I could see a difference due to flex all around the tone hole.

In a horizontal position the mark made in the pads where around 0.2 mm too far in the direction of the bell opening. This changed to zero when the saxophone was upright. I think it is the weight of the keys plus some spiel in the mechanism.
Doesn't surprise me at all.
In an ideal world you'd level the toneholes with all the keys fitted and sprung - because it all has an impact (though minute) on the body. It's largely a moot point though because there are other factors that cannot be controlled (such as temperature, finger pressure etc.) - and you quickly run into the wall of diminishing returns as you face up to the realisation that there's a mechanical limit on how much precision a horn can support. It's at this point where a degree of flex in the pad really earns its keep.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,071
Messages
578,539
Members
8,132
Latest member
LouisJR
Back
Top Bottom