Playing the saxophone Taking a break from lessons?

To play devil's advocate here:

It can take several lessons for a teacher to get to know you. If you're given things to work on outside of a lesson how well do you do that.

Identifying what areas need work, and prioritising those.

Playing tunes you have no interest in? Most etudes and exercises have a purpose, whether it's rhythm, timing, syncopation, patterns & intervals.

It's one thing being able to play a tune you've rehearsed repeatedly (there can probably be improvement somewhere), the real test is sight reading a completely new, unknown tune.

When I started lessons, I could already read music and play to some level.

My teacher and I worked through an exercise book (could have been abracadabra) at the end of it, he congratulated me that I now knew what all the buttons did, and it was now time to learn to play a saxophone - he was correct 🀣
 
To play devil's advocate here:

It can take several lessons for a teacher to get to know you. If you're given things to work on outside of a lesson how well do you do that.

Identifying what areas need work, and prioritising those.

Playing tunes you have no interest in? Most etudes and exercises have a purpose, whether it's rhythm, timing, syncopation, patterns & intervals.

It's one thing being able to play a tune you've rehearsed repeatedly (there can probably be improvement somewhere), the real test is sight reading a completely new, unknown tune.

When I started lessons, I could already read music and play to some level.

My teacher and I worked through an exercise book (could have been abracadabra) at the end of it, he congratulated me that I now knew what all the buttons did, and it was now time to learn to play a saxophone - he was correct 🀣
There’s also the journey that your ears go on with sound, and really hearing stuff.
 
There’s also the journey that your ears go on with sound, and really hearing stuff.
Yes, I've been doing some ear training and trying to play simple tunes by ear. Something else I need to work on. 😳
Well that’s really only a test of how accomplished you are at sight reading of course there’s plenty more to learn.
Agreed, the longer you play practice, it seems there's more to learn, and you become ever more critical of your own playing.

Whilst some exercises & etudes seem simple, there is usually a purpose & benefit to them.
 
There is a big difference between "tunes", pop, rock, jazz, show songs, stuff for kids on Disney, etc etc, and classical etudes with a bit of melodic sense.

The teachers I knew, and myself, only taught the "tunes" that the students wanted to learn. Since they knew those tunes, they just needed to find them on their instrument of choice, with the teachers help. It's nice if the tunes are not in keys with numerous sharps and flats, so they can play along with recorded music, otherwise they have to be transposed, to a key they can play.

For those who want to become more accomplished, scale work, etude studies and a metronome are part of that learning.
Lots of people play nice jazz, with an occasional flurry of notes, but they are limited, compared to the better players, both in Jazz and Classical literature.
Set your goals.

Fun stuff:

IMG_4939.webp

IMG_4940.webp
 
I had a look at a Shostakovitch last night as it happens, this was one of the youtub payalongs with the sheet music on screen, handy that you can slow the track right down if needed ( it was ! )
I've found these playalong things very useful in practice, plus it keeps to on your toes with the tempo, unlike stuff in a book, nice to have a backing to give a piece some context too.
I tried something a bit simpler than your 'fantasic dances' though πŸ˜‰

View: https://youtu.be/_ftEexk9gis?si=uGYHqDE7y68Aogqf
 
Last edited:
The kids that practiced, would play music like this, a tempo, for high school music conservatory auditions.
Everyone practiced daily with a Franz electric. :thumb:
Sight reading and a classical sound, as well.


View attachment 30215

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KYax7YmWC5c
I wouldn’t be able to sight read that. I probably would have done when sight reading was something I had to do as part of earning my living though. Probably got a bit rusty since most of my work had been for myself and just write the difficult stuff for other people.
 
Thread resuscitation........I'm also having this dilemma at the moment.

Got my sax in December 24 and started lesson in January 25. Weekly for about the first 3 months then fortnightly for three months and now monthly.

My teacher is very good and we get on well and he has really helped me progress but I'm getting frustrated now. Since joining an amateur jazz band in June I have weekly two hour rehearsals plus daily 1-2 hour home practice and really feel that I am developing. The band leader plays also plays sax and gives me help and advice as does the other experienced tenor player. The B/L has offered me coaching too. My reading, timing and musicality has really progressed and I have played five gigs now, soloing in two of them.

Even though I am practicing and learning standards my teacher still wants to work through the 'Abracadabra' book, learning simple songs in a step-by-step approach. We are near the end of it but I don't see the point in learning to play tunes I don't care for; I 'd rather spend the time practicing songs that are in the band's repertoire, and receive general tips and guidance.

Tone work, scales, arpeggios, chords etc I can do myself, and I study music theory every day, being retired gives me plenty of time to indulge in my passion. I am still a novice but I feel more confident and more of a 'player' than a 'learner' now. I turn up to rehearsals and gigs, pick up the horn and play, maybe not that well but I can keep up and feel part of it rather than an outsider trying to play along. I seem to learn best when under pressure and being somewhat of an autodidact and obsessive find just getting on with it works best for me, sink or swim!

I guess its similar to that the stage in learning to drive when you realise that you just driven without thinking, changing gear, speed management, observation, driving smoothness have become natural. Not a Formula One driver but competent enough to be let on the roads with minimal supervision.

I see my teacher in a fortnight, the first time since July so he can asses my 'progress' to date. However I am thinking of suggesting we go to check up lessons, maybe every couple of months just to ensure I'm not developing bad habits and to iron out any issues.

I hope this doesn't sound arrogant after less than a year of learning but I don't feel any benefit from regular lessons anymore and think it's time to fly solo.

Any thoughts most appreciated.
Hi @cappers, first off many thanks for reviving this very relevant thread!

I can't add much to this discussion. Because - although I've played sax in amateur bands for 30 years (since the age of 40) - I had tuition for only 1 1/2 years. The first 1/2 year, I had a great (amateur) tutor. He left so - while playing in a local 'Wind Orchestra', I also had a year's tuition at a local musical school. Which I hated but in retrospect learned a lot from. Any other 'sax abilities' I've gradually picked up from - or via - this cafΓ©.

As an aside, my eldest daughter (now 38) in her teenage years wanted to learn to drum. We bought her a drumkit but the lessons from her first 'tutor' were perhaps 'solid' but not 'fun' or 'inspirational'. So she found a 2nd tutor and her 'drumming world' changed. Her 2nd tutor made 'practicing' fun and and inspired her to continue practicing.

So, IMHO, it essentially boils down to:
- 'trust in and inspiration by' your teacher
- trust in your own learning abilities, with support from you band leader and members

Your approach sounds fine to me. Consider gradually winding down with your tutor from 1x per 2 weeks to 1x per 4 weeks to 1x per 8 weeks.

But the bottom line is that:
a) if you don't feel sufficiently inspired by your current 'tutoring schedule
b) if you don't feel that you're not learning enough through your current 'tutoring schedule

then it would seem wise (to me) to first discuss your proposed changes to the schedule with your tutor. Any tutor worth her/his salt would IMHO accommodate your wishes.
 
Pete, that piece was one of two, that was practiced for the auditions.
The sight reading was just a page they put on the stand, gave you a minute to look at it, and said, play.
You auditioned in the middle of your senior year in Junior High School, age 14.5.
My other piece was a Hungarian Rhapsody, which was also memorized, but the music was on the stand.
Even though I was familiar with performing, nervous, was an understatement. πŸ˜΅β€πŸ’«
Back around 2010, while waiting for one of my workers, who was running late, I picked up my traveling Piccolo.
I heard the voices of Eastern European women, at the pool, and started an improv on the Hungarian piece.
Moments later I was surrounded by those lovely bikini wearing ladies, who were looking for a wedding.
Piccolo power. πŸŽΆπŸ΄β€β˜ οΈπŸŽΆ
 
Pete, that piece was one of two, that was practiced for the auditions.
The sight reading was just a page they put on the stand, gave you a minute to look at it, and said, play.
Ah well that isn't sight reading. One of the very few auditions Ive done was for the BBC Northern Radio Orchestra. There was sightreading which was a pice in F# on piccolo, inclucing fast sixteenth arpeggios up to A, alternating major and minor, followed by playing a standrd with solo (no music ), I think it was There will never be another you so that was alright but no, I didn't get the job but made some friends, Munch Manship and Steve Shaw
 
@PiccoloPirate, thanks for your posts on Dans Fantastique as 'audition music'. To me (as a lazy Big Band amateur), it was quite shocking to realize that some (upcoming) classical sax players can learn to play music of this complexity. My eyes glaze over just looking at it. The tenor sax part just towers (out of sight) of what I'm capable of learning!

FWIW, as a 'beginner' (30 years ago, aged 40), my 2nd tutor -at a local music school - was a classical sax player so I did learn to play some (much simpler) classical pieces. After a couple of months, we had a 'head to head' discussion when I said that I really wanted to learn to play Blues/Jazz. He eventually agreed on condition that I played all the 'dots' precisely as written.

At the time (and for the next 5 years), I played in a local 'Wind Orchestra', whose repertoire was 'light classical'.

I've never regretted learning to play 'classical music'. It gave me a really solid grounding in learning to sight-read and to play sax with dynamics, articulation, etc. I've carried this ' solid grounding' through to playing in Big Bands and (for the past year) in a Blues/Rock/Pop band.

FWIW, I've also learned a lot from playing in a 'Blues/Rock/Pop band', Not in terms of 'reading music' - I play only with lyrics + (concert) chords for guitarists and keyboard player. So I've learned to quickly transpose (on the fly) between 'concert chords/scales' to the equivalent tenor sax chords /scales. I've also learned to play in (transposed) chords/scales that are common for bands to play in but not in Big Bands.

For example:
E -> F# (tenor)
B -> C# (tenor)
 
I saw my teacher earlier today for the first time in two months.

He asked me to play a few songs from the Abracadabra beginners book with no backing to hear where I'm at. Included a couple of new ones from the end of the book. Seemed to go OK but he noted my timing and articulation need more work. Played some scales and arpeggios then checked my long tones with a meter and apparently they were good. We also played a duet from Santin's Creative Saxophone Duets.

He agreed that with the weekly two hour band practice and my own daily practice, monthly lessons should suffice now. We will concentrate on timing, articulation, dynamics, soloing and any band music I'm struggling with. Lessons will be from James Rae's 36 More Modern Studies for Solo Saxophone. This is level 3+ and more in keeping with the music I'm playing with the band.

I'm happy with that.
Next lesson in a month and three short pieces from Rae's book to practice.
 
I saw my teacher earlier today for the first time in two months.

He asked me to play a few songs from the Abracadabra beginners book with no backing to hear where I'm at. Included a couple of new ones from the end of the book. Seemed to go OK but he noted my timing and articulation need more work. Played some scales and arpeggios then checked my long tones with a meter and apparently they were good. We also played a duet from Santin's Creative Saxophone Duets.

He agreed that with the weekly two hour band practice and my own daily practice, monthly lessons should suffice now. We will concentrate on timing, articulation, dynamics, soloing and any band music I'm struggling with. Lessons will be from James Rae's 36 More Modern Studies for Solo Saxophone. This is level 3+ and more in keeping with the music I'm playing with the band.

I'm happy with that.
Next lesson in a month and three short pieces from Rae's book to practice.
Great News!

I've not used James Rae's 36 More, but the first book of modern studies. There's some nice pieces in that, so I hope it's as challenging & enjoyable for you.

Timing - Seems to be an everlasting challenge for me :doh: The soloing in a band highlights this for me (and a few others in the section) and the tendancy seems to be to rush solos. Sounds like good advice & plan from the teacher!
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,058
Messages
578,289
Members
8,127
Latest member
PJ2116
Back
Top Bottom