Playing the saxophone Taking a break from lessons?

Yes that reminds me of when I did a few private lessons.

I had one student I gave the task of learning to play In The Mood. She went away and came back a week later for the lesson. I said have you learned it then?, and she said no, sorry.

OK I said I'll see you next week instead then as there's nothing to do this week. She was a bit disgruntled.
I hope you charged for the week even so. When I was teaching I did the same thing a couple times. Generally students got the message, and either paid more attention or quit.

If a student had a good reason for not working on what we agreed on, then I found something to work on with them, but otherwise just kicked them out and practiced. Or had a second cup of coffee…

He's on holiday so I haven't seen him since the beginning of July (hence all my questions on here :rolleyes:). I mentioned it to him then and he said ok but let's finish Abracadabra (beginners' book) to ensure the foundations are solid.

He's a good responsive teacher and we get on so I'm sure when we next meet in a couple of weeks he'll see my progress and agree to a new approach. Personally I feel with my daily practice, the weekly practice I get with the band and some coaching from the leader, having a check up lesson once a month should do for now.
Yes a good frank discussion is warranted. It IS important for you to master fundamentals, like all scales in all keys, but that work can be tailored to suit your current playing situation.

I’m not so sure about the monthly schedule, you haven’t been playing that long, and it’s all too easy to get into a bad habit, especially when you are confronted with a new or challenging situation. Consider whether you are taking saxophone lessons or music lessons. Or both. Saxophone playing is a physical thing, and requires physical skill, so weekly or bi-weekly coaching may be more useful. Something to consider.
 
Tbh, it might be interesting to go and have a one off lesson out of interest, to see what they'd say and if there's any useful suggestions ( apart from 'give up' ! ) as to a way ahead.
The big snag is of course to find the 'right' person that could give some meaningful insight, rather than the usual going through the motions type.
 
Thanks @skeller047
It IS important for you to master fundamentals, like all scales in all keys, but that work can be tailored to suit your current playing situation........not so sure about the monthly schedule,
I do scale and arpegggio exercises daily and have most of them down now; a bit hesitant on B/Cb, Gb/F# Db/C# but those just need more practice. I can play from Bb1 to ~E3, F3 and F#3 not so well. Learning the Cycle of 4ths/5ths has been very enlightening and helpful in understanding scales, accidentals, chords, and intervals.

The band practice helps my reading, timing and general musicality. I also do some tone work on the mpc daily. Theory I do myself, a couple of hours per day reading the TTS books, Teal, O'Neill, and Rae. I'm self disciplined and very motivated as I am enjoying it so much

I'll see what he suggests in a couple of weeks. With the extra input I'm getting I feel monthly is enough.
 
I do scale and arpegggio exercises daily and have most of them down now
Blimey, I wouldn’t particularly say that myself. Can you play F# major starting on the 5th? D harmonic minor starting on a B? Scales rarely start on the tonic note in pieces or work like that in impro.

How about articulation? Can you hear a tongued note but not the act of tonguing?
 
@Pete Effamy I can play most of the 'easier' scales from the non-root but it's not automatic yet, some thinking involved.
F# major is all #s except for the 4th (B) so starting from the 5th is C# D# E# F# G# A# B C#.
Harmonic minors ok as long as I remember they're natural minors with a #7. D harmonic minor from B (?Bb?) is Bb C# D E F G A Bb (I like the exotic 'oriental' feel of the minor harmonic).
My articulation is improving, but can be a bit audible at times.

I understand that you might be a bit skeptical as I am just a novice with less than a year's experience. I am a fast learner and according to my teacher and band leader I am making remarkable progress all considered.

I know I'll never be great but good and competent will do for me! It's for my fun and enjoyment, not for a career or aspirations to be a star player.

Cheers for the input.
 
Harmonic minors ok as long as I remember they're natural minors with a #7.
The pedant in me needs to tell you that's a major 7, not a #7 (which would actually be the '8').

Another way to think of harmonic minor is: 1 2 b3 4 5 b6 7. For comparison, natural minor is 1 2 b3 4 5 b6 b7. It really pays to know your scale degrees numerically. The major scale is the foundation for that. Those accidentals are applied to the major scale degrees.

Sounds to me like you're making great progress, cappers. Keep it up.
 
OK,
natural minor = 1 2 b3 4 5 b6 b7
harmonic minor = 1 2 b3 4 5 b6 7 so the 7th of the NM is raised by a semitone.
Is 'they're natural minors with a sharpened 7th' not correct?

Maybe I was told this shortcut to avoid confusion with major 7 - 1 3 5 7 and dominant 7 - 1 3 5 b7? Major 7 is a 1/2 step below the root, V7 a whole step.

Am I wrong or just not using the correct terminology or thinking?

Thanks
 
OK,
natural minor = 1 2 b3 4 5 b6 b7
harmonic minor = 1 2 b3 4 5 b6 7 so the 7th of the NM is raised by a semitone.
Is 'they're natural minors with a sharpened 7th' not correct?

Maybe I was told this shortcut to avoid confusion with major 7 - 1 3 5 7 and dominant 7 - 1 3 5 b7? Major 7 is a 1/2 step below the root, V7 a whole step.

Am I wrong or just not using the correct terminology or thinking?

Thanks
You are correct in that the harmonic minor raises the b7 of natural minor by a half step. When you raise b7 a half step, you get the major 7.

Keep in mind these formulae using numeric scale degrees are based on the scale degrees of a major scale. For example, in the scale of F# major, the '3' is A#, but it will still be designated the '3' (not #3). If it's an A natural, it will be designated b3. And so on. It's good to know the numerical scale degrees for the notes in all 12 major chords.

Don't get confused by the chord symbol V7. That's a chord symbol. It designates a dom7 chord with a b7: 1 3 5 b7. And while it's true that when discussing dominant chords, the b7 is often referred to as the '7', but that's because the subject is a dominant chord, and it's understood to have a b7. Which I agree is confusing. Even a minor 7 chord is designated Dmin7, which just means it includes the 7th of the chord, which again, is a b7. Which is why we call a minor chord with a major 7: Cmin/maj7.

Got all that? Sorry, it is somewhat confusing until you get used to it. But, once again, if you raise a b7 a half step, you get a major 7. You won't likely see a '#7' in a chord because that designates the '8' - the '1' which is the chord root.

Hope all that makes sense.
 
Got all that? Sorry, it is somewhat confusing until you get used to it.
It's actually even more confusing when the interval of a flatten 7th is actually referred to as a minor 7th interval

So both a minor 7 chord and a dominant 7 chord have a minor 7 interval. So it can be confusing when just saying minor 7th unless you make it clear whether you are talking about the interval or the chord symbol.

But the term dominant 7th never refers to an interval, only the chord type (but 9 times out of 10, or more) the term dominant chord does mean a chord has that minor 7th interval.

In fact, regarding intervals, calling it a minor 7th interval is less confusing than calling it a b7 interval, because that interval may or may not have a ♭, the 7th could also be ♮

Eb to Db = minor 7 interval

G to F = minor 7 interval
 
Last edited:
What about me, said one of the three.

IMG_4933.webp
 
But the term dominant 7th never refers to an interval, only the chord type (but 9 times out of 10, or more, the term dominant chord suffices as a dominant chord always has that minor 7th interval. In fact calling it a minor 7th interval is less confusing than calling it a b7 interval, because that interval may or may not have a ♭, the 7th could also be ♮

Eb to Db = minor 7 interval

G to F = minor 7 interval
Excellent point. But this is why I mentioned the fact that it's necessary to know the major scale degrees because the numerals are in reference to the major scale, or in the case of a chord, to its root.

For example, yes F natural is the b7 or minor 7 interval if G is the chord root or the 'root' of a G major scale. G to F. So, to get there you have to realize that F# is the major 7th interval: G to F#, and the '7' in a major scale. Eventually, you'll just know it, without having to think about it.

It all sounds a lot more confusing trying to explain or write out than it really is. That's why I keep banging on about knowing the 12 major scales and the numeric degree of each note in each scale. For example, so you instantly know that in the key of G, the 7 is F#, the 3 is B, the 6 is E, etc. And in the key of B, the 7 is A# (I tend to think of the enharmonic, Bb), the 3 is D# (b3 is D), the 5 is F# (so the b5 is F), the 6 is G#, etc. And on & on.

Knowing this stuff makes it easier to play in all 12 keys because you get familiar with the sound of various intervals, licks, phrases, etc. That sound will carry over into another key if you use the same intervals or 'numeric' formula. One quick example. I like the tritone interval (especially in the blues). So, I know I can get that in any key by playing b5 to 1 (or vice versa). I can also get it playing 6 to b3, which I use quite a bit in the blues. Also, sticking to the blues, if you have a favorite blues scale lick, you can quickly transpose it to any key once you have the various scale degrees used & the rhythm down. edit: You'll mainly do it by ear, without having to think all that through (but you'll know how it works).

I didn't start out to write such a long post but once I got going, I couldn't stop. Hopefully I'm not beating this to death.
 
In fact, regarding intervals, calling it a minor 7th interval is less confusing than calling it a b7 interval, because that interval may or may not have a ♭, the 7th could also be ♮

Eb to Db = minor 7 interval

G to F = minor 7 interval
So minor 7 intervals could be say C to Bb, D to C, E to D, A to G, G to F etc all are 10 semitones? Major 7 intervals being 11 semitones e.g. C to B, D to C#, A to G#, G to F# etc?

Getting there I think. Thank you.
 
I didn't start out to write such a long post but once I got going, I couldn't stop. Hopefully I'm not beating this to death.
Not for me, more grist to the mill :thumb:

necessary to know the major scale degrees because the numerals are in reference to the major scale, or in the case of a chord, to its root.
Yes, I am thinking more and more in scale degrees rather than note names as it makes sense and is convenient and transferrable.
I noticed the other day I was thinking '3 is E, 7 is B in the key C major' etc. Studying chord make up helped.
Drip by drip....many thanks.
 
Last edited:
So minor 7 intervals could be say C to Bb, D to C, E to D, A to G, G to F etc all are 10 semitones? Major 7 intervals being 11 semitones e.g. C to B, D to C#, A to G#, G to F# etc?

Getting there I think. Thank you.
Yes, but thinking in semitones although accurate is less useful IMO for music based on tonal major, minor or modal systems. As opposed to twelve tone or atonal, etc. EDM or whatever various other systems
 
Yes, but thinking in semitones although accurate is less useful IMO for music based on tonal major, minor or modal systems.
That's for sure. I really can't imagine thinking in 10 or 11 semitones. I can easily manage up to around 3, but even there, it would be much simpler to call that a minor 3rd. It's easier to envision and especially to hear say, a b5 (tritone) interval than '6 semitones' (and I had to count semitones up from C to Gb, to get that number).
 
No problem. To understand tritones I wrote down the chromatic scale and counted the degrees and realised there were either 10 or 11 semitones in minor7 or major7 intervals. Now I can see the difference I can relate that to more conventional nomenclature.

I like the concept of tritones to resolve a passage back to the tonic. I had thought of them as more of an effect due to their dissonance - the Devils Interval - two tone sirens, Purple Haze and Black Sabbath. :rolleyes:
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,058
Messages
578,289
Members
8,127
Latest member
PJ2116
Back
Top Bottom