Saxophones Sound improve over time - Is this true?

Mix O Lydian

Member
Messages
219
Location
England
About two months ago I bought a Trevor James "The Horn" Revolution Tenor. Long story short, it's about 25 years old and the sax has been safely stored and unplayed for at least 22 of it's 25 years.

I could not play it at the time of collection (because new to tenor and it had a narrow basic MP and a 1.5 reed so couldn't get a peep out of it) but it was in great condition and the seller was trustworthy. And it was cheap.

Anyway, once I sorted out a better mouthpiece and reed and got my tech to do a few tiny little tweaks, it plays.

I recently had a discussion with someone about this sax because for a tenor I felt that it would have a louder, fuller sound with more projection. It sounds nice and in tune, but it's quite mellow and much quieter than I expected, and I can't seem to amp it up. (Which could just be me of course).

Anyway .... This person said because the sax has not really been played, despite it's age, it's like a new sax and the sound would improve over time because the sax has not been played enough for the brass to "wake up" and develop more resonance. They said that the pads, corks and mechanism would loosen and it would sound more free blowing over time. 🧐

I can relate to the sax sounding better in a practice session, once it has warmed up, but this person was almost saying that the sax would wear in with use, like a pair of shoes?

So guys, is this true? 🤔

Ps: MP is Yamaha 6c (which I bought as a cheap temporary measure to see if tenor was right for me.) Reed is Legere American Cut size 2.5.
PPs. I play Otto Link size 6 MP on Alto, with 2.5 reed
 
OMG, 🙁 I knew it was rubbish, armchair physics. But it was said to me, to my face, with absolute earnest. I didn't know how I should respond, so I just said "oh, that's interesting....."

I think, sometimes I am just to polite to call out BS when it surfaces.....
Like most things reaction depends on who it is friend or stranger.
'That's interesting' is useful as it can be genuine or sarcastic.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
I think, sometimes I am just to polite to call out BS when it surfaces.....
It's hard to know how to respond in that situation; not waiting to be rude.
With my other half's mother - who knows everything for a fact because she's 20 years or so older, I just keep my earbuds in. On noise cancelation.

I'd suggest pulling your phone out and in 4th wall breaking, Louis Theroux, style say "and here we see the result of our crumbing school system"
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
A horn not played for a while can dry out and develop small leaks and regulation issues which can affect output. Playing it can add moisture making things swell and settle. Didn't that guy cause an Internet storm by taking his horn into the shower.

New horns that have been poorly set up can settle in and become better or worse.

All the organic bits and pieces on a saxophone can be affected by use or weather or storage conditions. The metal not so much until corrosion makes an appearance and has an effect

They do get better as you get used to them but that's about you.

It's easy to see how these things can get misinterpreted by the uninitiated or unknowledgeable.

Your horn will appear to get better as you get used to it. Sometimes your sound can seem quiet to you but be loud to others. The deeper sound of the tenor can be deceiving when switching from alto. Same with the baritone.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
Bugs and worms can eat pads in an instrument that's left untouched for lengthy periods (my piccolo just suffered this, now I need to repad it). If you don't use key clamps, pads and corks can swell or shrink, making for tiny leaks that can adversely affect response.

But the big factor is that the more you play a particular instrument, the more you adapt (without realizing it) to its acoustic idiosyncrasies and develop the ability to play it properly and get the most out of it.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
So plot twist....
Yesterday I was randomly offered to opportunity to buy a YTS 275 tenor at a good price, from a friend, during a chance conversation.
So I did. Of course.
I'm using the same mouthpiece and reed that I used on the TJ. The difference is like night and day! The 275 is easier to play, sounds full and rich, I can get all the low notes effortlessly. It's less clunky. It's perfect! 😁.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
I'm using the same mouthpiece and reed that I used on the TJ. The difference is like night and day! The 275 is easier to play, sounds full and rich, I can get all the low notes effortlessly. It's less clunky. It's perfect! 😁.
Look it over closely. I bet there's a Klangboden hidden somewhere on that 275. Possibly in the bell...
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
OMG, 🙁 I knew it was rubbish, armchair physics. But it was said to me, to my face, with absolute earnest. I didn't know how I should respond, so I just said "oh, that's interesting....."

I think, sometimes I am just to polite to call out BS when it surfaces.....
I was wondering how you came to the assessment in your original post:

About two months ago I bought a Trevor James "The Horn" Revolution Tenor. Long story short, it's about 25 years old and the sax has been safely stored and unplayed for at least 22 of it's 25 years.

I could not play it at the time of collection (because new to tenor and it had a narrow basic MP and a 1.5 reed so couldn't get a peep out of it) but it was in great condition and the seller was trustworthy.
FWIW, although the metal doesn’t change with playing, the soft materials may - especially if the pads have dried out and are less supple, less able to seat properly. Get your horn checked for leaks and adjusted for optimal performance. After that, it is up to you to learn good air support and blow all the way through the horn. Mouthpiece/reed matter - it all has to be sorted.

Enjoy the path.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,058
Messages
578,300
Members
8,127
Latest member
PJ2116
Back
Top Bottom