I like the crushed flakes, too, if I'm starting from a clean cup.
The cheese stick version is just so... stringy....
From an acoustical standpoint, a pad that's only supported around the perimeter's going to be just
as dead as one that's securely anchored in something solid. The thing's felt and leather, and every
one I've ever removed or replaced has had the 'resonator' solidly attached to the felt.
The tiny amount of energy in a sound wave's not going to move the 'resonator' enough to
make it into a source.... and even if it did, it's never going to be an amplifier, so any acoustic emission
from the thing is going to be orders of magnitude less than what it's absorbing. As in, 'I can't hear you...'
The surface of the 'resonator' is going to be reflective- but from the standpoint of wavelength,
even the largest keys on a bari are sitting at about 5khz, so they are going to have limited
effect on the spectral content of what's coming out of the body or the bell. Loudness?
Sure, why not? But certainly not much...
t
thinks the flat washer look is nice.