Tech/maintenance Shellac for reflectors or resonators?

I had a bottom B pad fall off, after inspection it wasnt fixed with a lot of shellac. If you were somewhere with no internet connection without advice naturally you would replace them how they were done originally would you not?
Well, I was replacing pads long before there WAS an internet, and I was floating them on a bed of shellac. I invite you to find any actual repair manual or documentation that indicates this supposed resonating effect you're talking about. It doesn't happen.
 
Im just feeling put them in how they were done originally thats all, isnt that the meaning of restoration?
You say "how they were done originally". Which decade, which manufacturer? Conn, Martin, Buescher, King, Selmer, Buffet, A. Sax pere, A. Sax fils, 1850, 1860, 1870, 1880, 1890, ... up to now?

Yes, Conns and Bueschers had non-shellac pads for a while. This was in service to a theory that the user could field-replace the pads. They never mentioned anything about the surface of the pad "acting like a speaker" - because the guys that designed that stuff were engineers and they knew it didn't happen.

It's also generally accepted that the Conn and Buescher no-shellac pads really don't work any better than standard installation, and most techs use regular pads on the Conns and float the Buescher snap-ins on a bed of shellac and then install the snap (if they don't grind out the retaining feature and use regular pads).
 
It is a theory that the movement of reso's can affect sound. As long as there are no hearing tests it remains a theory. Factories often use disolved shellac as glue as it is faster. Techs use molten shellac as it gives more wiggle room to correct small leaks.

The tapping sound difference in the vid can be explained by the difference in size of the reso's. For reso's size matters.
For the sound of the saxophone the quality of the seal is imo more important than special effects of the reso's.
 
Quote from the earlier SOTW thread:

"Yeah, this is complete BS.

The author seems to be speculating all this based solely on the unfortunate fact that what are functionally pad reflectors are misleadingly named "resonators".

In addition to what @Bkenes (correctly) says above, you don't generally want anything other than the air column to "resonate" on a saxophone. Anything else would just lead to rattling sounds."
 
I know how my comments on here must seem like..whos this new bloke telling us weve been doing it wrong for years.but thats not my intention. Thats forums, texting and communication in general these days. I just want to know thats all, and having worked in furniture restoration in the past we tried to repair things back to how they were originally.
Your comments and questions are valued and appreciated. You have brought a new concept to the forum which deserves comment

In this case, what sounds like a new and exciting idea is just pseudo-science...

So you can relax, and simply glue those pads so they sit correctly (and don't fall out, or flap about)
 
Try this study:


I've read the various theories. The one about full or hollow backs to pads is surely invented rubbish.

My only remaining queries on the subject are over the shape and diameter of reflectors, often called resonators. I believe they reflect and barely resonate.

Does use of a flat reflector differ from a domed one or a Noyek type? Would Mickey Mouse or amphibious landing craft silhouette reflectors give a different sound?

And what of diameter? Why are reflectors often sold in 9; 12; 16; 20; 24; 28; 32; 36; 42mm diameters when pads come in 0.5mm increments? Surely there should be a more precise correlation between pad and reflector diameter if it made that much difference to volume or tone or pitch?

My own feeling, it's not scientific, is that the larger the reflector diameter the larger the sound and having no reflector deadens or muffles the sound.

But beware trends too. Large domed metal reflectors seem to be in fashion, in the same way that offset tone holes are (we discussed those elsewhere) but why?
 
Last edited:
Im going to ring up selmer and ask them, matt stroher says he disagrees with them using less shellac and recommends a credit card thickness, I just want to get it right. Shallow conn cups 1970 same stencil and tone hole size as 10m. You know one of those rubbish mexicons that sounds the same but without the crappy wire key guards.
 
Its worth fixing because it sounds lovely after a bit of twiddling and cleaning, apart from having to press hard because of the pads. Ive had 3 directors and one 10m in the past and this badly made mexicon made by jose blindairos and his lump hammer sounds the best out if the lot.
 
Booster, resonator, reflector= flat, domed or waffle/ corrugated disc on the face of a saxophone pad.
The shellac on the backside of the pad can be applied in different techniques. Each technician will have different techniques. As long as the pad seals and desired outcome is achieved. It’s correctly installed.
That is what makes the installation craft difference tech to tech.

Factories often used shellac dissolved in denatured alcohol. The material was brushed into the cup. Pad placed into the cup and then gently heated to flash the alcohol out. This allowing the pad to stick into the cup. A quick production method.
 
Im going to ring up selmer and ask them, matt stroher says he disagrees with them using less shellac and recommends a credit card thickness, I just want to get it right. Shallow conn cups 1970 same stencil and tone hole size as 10m. You know one of those rubbish mexicons that sounds the same but without the crappy wire key guards.
Why not take Matt Storher's advice?

He might know a thing or two
 
Im going to ring up selmer and ask them, matt stroher says he disagrees with them using less shellac and recommends a credit card thickness, I just want to get it right. Shallow conn cups 1970 same stencil and tone hole size as 10m. You know one of those rubbish mexicons that sounds the same but without the crappy wire key guards.
So you're going to call Selmer (which Selmer? Selmer Paris? Conn-Selmer-whatever-they-call-themselves-this-week?) and ask them how to replace pads in a 50 year old Mexi-Conn tenor?

Yeah, right.

Why not just float the pads on a bed of shellac LIKE EVERY PROFESSIONAL SAXOPHONE TECHNICIAN IN THE LAST FIFTY YEARS does it?
 
having worked in furniture restoration in the past we tried to repair things back to how they were originally.
I'd guess, then, you've come across "restoration" jobs by folks who didn't know what they where doing or had weird theories about how stuff works.. a botched job.

I've re-padded my horn, no tech would be impressed - anyone can and you can to. Will it be a "restoration" or a botch?
 
Last edited:
Fishing down in Islamorada, back in the
early'80s, met a Conch Republic Lady, who rebuilt speakers for musical gear.
When I asked her, what was the most difficult part of the work, she replied,
gluing in the little chairs for the musicians.
Great sense of humor, possibly from
a steady diet of, smoked square grouper.
 
I like the crushed flakes, too, if I'm starting from a clean cup.
The cheese stick version is just so... stringy....

From an acoustical standpoint, a pad that's only supported around the perimeter's going to be just
as dead as one that's securely anchored in something solid. The thing's felt and leather, and every
one I've ever removed or replaced has had the 'resonator' solidly attached to the felt.
The tiny amount of energy in a sound wave's not going to move the 'resonator' enough to
make it into a source.... and even if it did, it's never going to be an amplifier, so any acoustic emission
from the thing is going to be orders of magnitude less than what it's absorbing. As in, 'I can't hear you...'

The surface of the 'resonator' is going to be reflective- but from the standpoint of wavelength,
even the largest keys on a bari are sitting at about 5khz, so they are going to have limited
effect on the spectral content of what's coming out of the body or the bell. Loudness?
Sure, why not? But certainly not much...

t
thinks the flat washer look is nice.
 
Leather absorb energy. Metal/nylon/ceramics .... reflect energy. You get a bigger sound/tone with metal/nylon/ceramics ... reflectors. Big reflectors reflects more energy. The material of the reflectors is not making any differnce to my ears. But the size of the reflectors is doing more to the sound.

It's the I.D. of the tone hole rim that's is important when it comes to reflectors. Not the pad.

I/we was more picky when we installed pads with custom made reflectors on my Martin saxes, than I was when I installed standard pads with resonators/reflectors. Why, beacause they are rather expensive.

I have flat oversized custom made reflecors on my Martin Committe saxes. Give my Martin saxes a little bit bigger sound. Sterling silver or brass? Sterling silver reflectors on a Martin with solid nickelsilver keys is nice. Soundwise I can't hear any difference.

In the end it's the treatment you give the pads and relectors/resonators tha's makes differences. If you don't take good care of the pads that holds the reflectors/resonators you will have problems. Both ss and brass will corrugate if you don't dry and sometimes polish the reflectros/resonators.
 
In developing my synthetic pads I made the reflector area almost as big as the tone hole. Initially I thought that I would need to put some sound absorbing materials on the reflector area to get a dark sound. To my suprise the sound became dark enough when, over the years, the seal improved. Since then I am looking if there are leaks so small that you can't hear a difference. Still not found such a thing.
 
When I disassemble a horn to fit my pads I take many measurements and write them down on a standard template diagram for that model. These include cup diameter; tone hole diameter from the old pad impression; and cup to tone hole offset, i.e. the amount of non-concentricity.
The latter is to both check how close the new pad edge is to the closest tone hole edge to confirm sufficient pad edge overlap (bearing in mind there's a small gap between pad and cup to allow self-levelling), and also allows me to fit the largest reflector taking account of this offset.
In practice, because of standardised reflector sizes, I tend to go quite a few mm under the max reflector size.
I'm working on deleting add-on refectors entirely and using the stainless steel backing disc instead, removing the centre on the synthetic pad to any custom diameter to leave a circle of sealing material around 5-7mm wide (again, to allow for offset) around the edge of the pad backing disc.
Simpler, lighter, custom made to suit individual requirements.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,063
Messages
578,425
Members
8,129
Latest member
Bartman
Back
Top Bottom