So my travels this weekend took me to Sax.co.uk in Crowborough, and wow, what a place. I think I had a go on just about every single sax between 1.5 and 3k that they had in stock. The thing I noticed is that while most of them are perfectly fine and obviously aren't 'bad' instruments, a few in particular stood out as immediately more comfortable or 'compatible' with me.
Quite a few of them I could find something I didn't like within 5minutes and put them down there and then, the ones I kept coming back to were Yanis (I found these by far the most comfortable to hold and play), a Selmer and one of those Italian jobbies Pete mentioned.
The Yanis were lovely but I didn't like the sound I was getting when pushing them. Very nice played softly but I'm concerned I'd forever hold back if they get overbright when blasted a bit. I experimented with the 901, 991, 902 and 992.. To be honest I'm damned if I can tell the difference. The Bronze one did seem a little 'darker' (whatever word you might want to use) than the Brass, but not 600 quid's worth of difference. Aside from the obvious extras in the build between the 901 and the 991, couldn't tell the difference in sound. A proper blind test will be more definitive there.
Selmer SA80II had a very nice tone, I liked the sound I was getting out of that, when pushed and played softly. It was the middle of the three, the safe choice if you like. Would want to change the thumbhook on it but otherwise it was probably the most all-round sax I played for sound (with regards to the sound I'm after), ergonomics and price point.
Then I tried a Rampone and Cawhatsit. Because of this I'm now in a bit of a pickle. The sax was stunning, looked incredible and felt different to everything I'd tried so far, but by not 'uncomfortable-different'. It felt very individual and unique. The sound I got out of was similarly capable of making me go a bit gooey and weak at the knees, but the tradeoff was that I found it a lot harder to play. Needed a lot more air through it (I think the guy mentioned it had a wider bore than most) and, perhaps exaggerated because it was the last I tried and by then I'd been playing for 3 hours, so my lip was starting to go a bit, I found it very hard to get stable notes out at the top of the register.
So, do I go for one with an amazing sound that I can't actually properly control yet, try to develop my breathing, and grow into it (and with that, get all the obvoius and fully justified comparisons that will get drawn with someone owning such an instrument without actually being able to play it), or go for the sax I find easy to play, and try to develop the sound?
The plan as it stands now is to continue practising and focus on playing more loudly (I tend to practise very softly all the time, as there are always others around) to get better used to blowing through more and see how I find the R&C when I go back in April. The final instrument left to try is the Walstein M2, which I'm hoping to have a go on next weekend, before I try my blind test idea in April. I also want to have a quick peek at 2nd hand instruments available, just to see what's what.