Saxophones Sax recommendations, and an interesting idea.

No-one has mentioned Cannonball yet, which isn't that surprising as stockists are few and far between. However our trans-atlantic cousins rave about them, and people on this board are probably heartily sick of me and Amaranth singing the praises of our tenors. Well worth a try. Ignore the BS about the inset stones by the way - Cannonball honestly believe they make a difference, but no-one else does.
 
I've tried P. Mauriats tenor 66rl and Cannonball tenor as well. I think the model was called Mad Meg . Both very good saxes. They recently started to sell Cannonball here in Sweden. The Cannonball company has been through a lot of models. But it's a good sax, with or without the stones!

Talking about Tawainese saxes we should mention Jupiter XO (alto and tenor) as well. Just goldlaquer or unlaquer. Really nice saxes and at a nice price as well. The Jupiter company has all their models still in production. From 500 to the new XO.
 
Went to denmark street on saturday and tried a couple - a yani 991(901? I forget which I tried) which felt like a really fantastic instrument, a p mauriat something (Β£2k pricetag) which was fine but didn't spark anything.

Anywho curious to know opinions on this http://sax.co.uk/acatalog/s2altocl.html

I know that price reduction isn't actually that big, as other retailers sell the unengraved SA80II for about Β£2.8k. Not actually tried one of these but a family member has one, so can easily have a go.
 
Hi Adam!

I play a Ref54 Matt finish and absolutely love it (Steve Howard and others don't seem to rate it, but it is quite a wonderful instrument - I remember reading a brilliant thread on the other Sax website a few years ago entitled "Best Alto" which was won hands down by the Ref54, which has the zing factor OK). The sax.co.uk offer looks really good - be sorely tempted if I was starting from scratch.

But very tempted with the Borgani/Rampone & Cazzani altos.
Kind regards
Tom
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Ignore the BS about the inset stones by the way - Cannonball honestly believe they make a difference, but no-one else does.
Yes I saw a rather fiery thread on SOTW. It seems he honestly believes it so what can you say.

When I tried a few Cannonballs at the frankfurt Musikmesse, I was surprised at how loud they are compared to any other Taiwanese horn. That may or may not be a good thing depending on what you want, but they felt very nice to play.

When I picked up the baritone, after playing a few notes the stone on the neck fell. It didn't sound any the worse for it though!
 
the problem with cannonball saxes form a dealer point of view is you are not allowed toadvertise that you sell them -! dont ask why

john myall music in croydon sell the following instruments which have been set up by my good self or one of my colleagues:

cannonball saxes, yamaha, mauriat, yanagisawa, selmer(paris), keilworth, trevor james, we also have some secondhand stock you can try.

address: 46 south end croydon CRO 1DP TEL 02086628400 WEB www.justflutes.com Im there this friday and most thursdays if you need any technical advice.


If you want to know about our after sales, warranty, service or general customer service just ask Old git, or half diminished or young col or jonf all of which have used our services.
 
A very sound endorsement from me for the services of Griff and colleagues at Jonathan Myalls. A distinctly quirky and characterful shop, in an amazing old building. Quality of workmanship is first rate and rates are reasonable. Good range as well, far more than you might expect from the frontage of the building. One of my two favourite shops. The other is the Crowborough sax.co.uk - totally different set up, truly vast with colossal stock. The thing that links the two is ace service from knowledgable, friendly staff who are passionate about their subject. It's a delight shopping in either.
 
Went to denmark street on saturday and tried a couple - a yani 991(901? I forget which I tried) which felt like a really fantastic instrument, a p mauriat something (Β£2k pricetag) which was fine but didn't spark anything.

Anywho curious to know opinions on this http://sax.co.uk/acatalog/s2altocl.html

I know that price reduction isn't actually that big, as other retailers sell the unengraved SA80II for about Β£2.8k. Not actually tried one of these but a family member has one, so can easily have a go.

Pretty good deal, but to be honest I have always found Selmers a bit over-priced. I think they're selling on their name to a degree. Also, be aware they don't supply cases except with the Ref series, and I for one would change the mouthpiece. I've had Selmer S80 mouthpieces before and I find them very woolly, dull and a bit quiet.

You might love it, of course. When I was trying saxes before I bought my Yanagisawa tenor I tried some Selmers. This is a very personal thing, but a bit like with Harley Davidsons, I find less is more - the cheapest in the range for me was the best, although I still didn't quite gel with it. But as I say - you may love one. Tom's is obviously great for him, and he might not get on with my choice. So personal. It's fun trying out loads of horns, though, isn't it?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
And one more thought. If you're in sax.co.uk London, and have Β£3k to spend on an alto, they have a used Selmer Ref 54 and Yanagisawa A9930 within budget. Either could be a great option for you
 
Hi Adam,

I recently bought myself a new alto. I chose a Yamaha 82Z from sax.co.uk and I love it.

Because I live on an island in the Caribbean, I wasn't able to try any instruments out. Probably it was madness to spend so much on an untried instrument, but I don't regret it...the Yamaha does everything I hoped. Like you, I wanted to buy a sax that I wouldn't have to replace. I read all I could, emailed dealers asking stupid questions and then had a friend pick it up and bring it with him when he visited. I was happy to buy Yamaha untested because I believe they have very high quality control standards, so one horn is probably going to be pretty much the same as another off the line.

It is LOUD though, with an RPC mouthpiece on it. When I put down my Martin tenor and pick up the new Yamaha alto, I have to step away from the mic, otherwise I just blow everyone away.

I wanted an alto with a very bright, modern sound and I think I've got it.

Good luck with your search.

Martin
 
If you want to know about our after sales, warranty, service or general customer service just ask Old git, or half diminished or young col or jonf all of which have used our services.

Totally brilliant in all areas bar one - it's a bloody long way from where I live! Everyone in the shop is great from Jonathan the owner through to weekend peeps. And of course our own Griff, sax technician extraordinaire!

Is that OK Griff? >:)

I used to be an alto man and my fav was without doubt the Selmer reference 54 Flamingo that I tried at sax.co.uk. Stunning in every way. Beautiful tone and fantastic light action. I was going to buy one but then met Andy Sheppard and Andy Brush at Myalls and ended up buying a Mauriat 66RUL tenor. No regrets though.

At the time I had a Keilwerth SX 90R alto that I bought s/h from my then teacher. It was a bit of a dog in some ways and I never really got on with it what with those damn rolled tone holes and the constant sticking pads!!! πŸ™
 
Thanks for all replies, exceptionally useful bunch you are!

Myalls... That shop was mentioned to me recently, I admit I didn't really pay much attention at the time though I have just been forwarded an email about a sale you're having. Another to add to the list to visit!

When I actually come to do my experiments in April, I'll add in any 2nd hand instruments in the shops I visit. Any opinions on the trev james, or kielwerth saxes? Most of the shops in my reach sell them, though i've not seen anything said about them.
 
T James saxes are nice but a bit pricey particularly the custom models having said that if you want a silver bodied brass crooked sax with black keys it can be yours - thats why they call them custom - you choose what you want - TJ's are made in Taiwan - at TJ's own factory - the parts are then shipped to the UK and they are then assembled here.

Keilworth saxes are made in Germany and are well built instruments, they have big chunky pearls and on the high end models like the SX90R they have rolled tone holes and adjustable palm keys. we have one tenor - an SX90R in the shop that blows a dream - its under 2K which is Β£600 cheaper than sax .co.uk (its old stock) heck I would have had for myself If I could somehow explain why I needed it to my wife!

If you can get to the shop on a Thursday morning and let me know if you are coming I can put some time aside to advise you from a technicians point of view.


Griff
 
Adam,
Jonnie Myall is a music shop owner who doesn't want to be a millionaire. A friendly place, which allows you plenty of time to try out mouthpieces and saxophones. Croydon has three music shops up and down the main drag plus a good luthier and Myall did not even throw me out the first time I went in, trying to locate decent banjo strings!

Had two flutes and a flugelhorn from them but the clincher is the workshop. a flute genius and head maker, Ian and Griff who's skills I have benefitted from on woodwind and brass instruments. Own a Hanson ST-8, all silver and gold plated bling and was in the shop trying and buying a Java 75 when this bearded feller comes up and says, "I've never tried a Hanson, do you mind?". Off he trotted and soon I heard sounds that I will never aspire to on the saxophone, that is good ones. He wandered back and remarked "Not bad but are you having trouble with the low notes?", "Yes." "Let me go and get a screwdriver.". This was followed by an explanation of what was wrong, the G# screw, what he was doing and why. When I enquired how much for this magical service, I was politely advised to go away. After a year, Griff rebuilt the Hanson and made and fitted a special key to help a partially handicapped friend to play her recorder. The Hanson was a completely different instrument, infinitely more playable and I even left my beloved RPC 'piece in the case if he wanted to try it. Lin is still playing the folk clubs with her melodeon, fiddle and special recorder.

What Ian refers to as the weekends peeps, are all undergrads at the London Music Colleges, know their stuff, and just in case you are a jazz, rock or blues fan, they have to study these forms for a period and do not put down non classical music forms.

Good shop full of good guys and girls. Put it on your list now, and if you PM me when you are going, will buy you lunch and a pint at a nearby hostelry and without offering any advice but try and attend when Griff is there as he is incredibly helpful.

No connection except as a satisfied customer although Griff is the West Country ambassador for the CaSLM. πŸ™‚
 
Yup, I'll second that about Myall's as my local shop. All very friendly. Griff gave my Mauriat its first year service recently and it feels really nice again. Was going to offer that OG stood you lunch, but as he has offered I would come along to make sure he keeps his word.
Colin
 
Turns out the shop I thought you were on about I'd actually called Myatts, doh! Either way, Croydon is still perfectly within range.

When and if I do get round to visiting, it'll likely be sometime in April- this weekend I have crowborough pencilled in - don't let that stop Old Git buying you all lunch though!

Thanks for all the generous offers!
 
So my travels this weekend took me to Sax.co.uk in Crowborough, and wow, what a place. I think I had a go on just about every single sax between 1.5 and 3k that they had in stock. The thing I noticed is that while most of them are perfectly fine and obviously aren't 'bad' instruments, a few in particular stood out as immediately more comfortable or 'compatible' with me.

Quite a few of them I could find something I didn't like within 5minutes and put them down there and then, the ones I kept coming back to were Yanis (I found these by far the most comfortable to hold and play), a Selmer and one of those Italian jobbies Pete mentioned.

The Yanis were lovely but I didn't like the sound I was getting when pushing them. Very nice played softly but I'm concerned I'd forever hold back if they get overbright when blasted a bit. I experimented with the 901, 991, 902 and 992.. To be honest I'm damned if I can tell the difference. The Bronze one did seem a little 'darker' (whatever word you might want to use) than the Brass, but not 600 quid's worth of difference. Aside from the obvious extras in the build between the 901 and the 991, couldn't tell the difference in sound. A proper blind test will be more definitive there.

Selmer SA80II had a very nice tone, I liked the sound I was getting out of that, when pushed and played softly. It was the middle of the three, the safe choice if you like. Would want to change the thumbhook on it but otherwise it was probably the most all-round sax I played for sound (with regards to the sound I'm after), ergonomics and price point.

Then I tried a Rampone and Cawhatsit. Because of this I'm now in a bit of a pickle. The sax was stunning, looked incredible and felt different to everything I'd tried so far, but by not 'uncomfortable-different'. It felt very individual and unique. The sound I got out of was similarly capable of making me go a bit gooey and weak at the knees, but the tradeoff was that I found it a lot harder to play. Needed a lot more air through it (I think the guy mentioned it had a wider bore than most) and, perhaps exaggerated because it was the last I tried and by then I'd been playing for 3 hours, so my lip was starting to go a bit, I found it very hard to get stable notes out at the top of the register.

So, do I go for one with an amazing sound that I can't actually properly control yet, try to develop my breathing, and grow into it (and with that, get all the obvoius and fully justified comparisons that will get drawn with someone owning such an instrument without actually being able to play it), or go for the sax I find easy to play, and try to develop the sound?

The plan as it stands now is to continue practising and focus on playing more loudly (I tend to practise very softly all the time, as there are always others around) to get better used to blowing through more and see how I find the R&C when I go back in April. The final instrument left to try is the Walstein M2, which I'm hoping to have a go on next weekend, before I try my blind test idea in April. I also want to have a quick peek at 2nd hand instruments available, just to see what's what.
 
Hi Adam!

I agree about Yani's - a little too bright for my taste (I have the T901). The R&C is an excellent sax. I nearly bought one about 4 years ago, but got my Ref54 for only Β£240 more. If you like the R&C it would be worth trying the Borgani's that they have at Sax Heaven in Oxford (prices are at least Β£1200 cheaper than current list price, and also handmade in Italy).

It's surprisingly easy eliminating instruments that are just not OK - harder making a final choice. If it is any help I think that high notes are achievable on all saxes - you just have to unlock the secret of how.
Good luck with your continued search.

Kind regards
Tom😎
 
Adam

I have a R&C R1 Jazz saxello. It is beautiful and I was lucky enough to get it second-hand. I'm nowhere near an expert but I would suggest that its very hard to find something that is perfect in every way so whatever you choose will inevitably end up being a compromise in one way or another.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,063
Messages
578,419
Members
8,129
Latest member
Bartman
Back
Top Bottom