Saxophones Sax Dakota SDTS-1022 Straight Tenor Saxophone

Messages
3,089
I found the following for sale on Sweetwater:
It's price is listed at $4,989.00 (£3,689.69).

2025-09-23 SW Sax Dakota SDTS1022 Straight Tenor Saxofón.webp


It resembles a sop with tenor neck. This is the first time I have seen a tenor done like a sop. Interesting, no?
 
Yikes ! does it stand on the floor then ?
No, it just extends further down. Think of your curved bell tenor having its low elbow being straightened with the very bottom being bent forward.

I suppose a very short person may struggle with it.

Manufacturer's webpage:

The following are short 1 minute demos:

Tim Price plays Straight tenor saxophone by Sax Dakota:

Sax Dakota Namm Show 2020 with straight alto and tenor in duet:

It seems for the average person probably would have enough clearance without touching the ground. One would probably have to make their own stand for it.
 
I wanna see the duet of curved sop and straight tenor - strictly for laughs. I agree that mic'ing the long horn would be a pain - as would projection of the bell notes.

What's the case look like for the tenor? I doubt that it breaks down beyond removing the neck. From a design standpoint, the elongated tenor must have a lot of flex in the long rods actuating the bell keys. I wouldn't like that.
 
Keilwerth and Sakkusu have both done straight alto and tenor's, they weren't big sellers, not sure if they do them today.
During a search, a few Keilwerth hits came up. I didn't chase that, so don't know the availability.
They would be harder to mic up
Challenging? Yes. Harder? I think they are doable, depends on setup. Use a standard mike near the bell end?
difficult to hear yourself.
I dunno. The demostrations showed them doable, probably no different than an alto or bass clarinet. Would I buy one? No. I suppose for the person wanting to make a statement, may be for them.
 
I've got a straight alto made by Keilwerth and reviewed by Steve Howard. It plays well but the sound is a bit remote and the balance of the instrument a little weird. I've never seen the straight tenor in person and I think it is much less common than the already rare straight alto.

LA Sax also sold straight altos and tenors but I'm not sure who made them and whether they were any good.

Hard to believe, but there have also been straight baritone saxophones made, I think always by modifying an existing bari and probably just for the novelty effect. Here is a video of one such straight baritone:

View: https://www.instagram.com/reel/DIVCra9JJK-/


Rhys
 
I've got a straight alto made by Keilwerth and reviewed by Steve Howard. It plays well but the sound is a bit remote and the balance of the instrument a little weird. I've never seen the straight tenor in person and I think it is much less common than the already rare straight alto.

LA Sax also sold straight altos and tenors but I'm not sure who made them and whether they were any good.

Hard to believe, but there have also been straight baritone saxophones made, I think always by modifying an existing bari and probably just for the novelty effect. Here is a video of one such straight baritone:

View: https://www.instagram.com/reel/DIVCra9JJK-/


Rhys
Wow, first time I've seen one of these, would think the rim of the bell would be easy to bump on the floor.
 
They would be harder to mic up and difficult to hear yourself.

Challenging? Yes. Harder? I think they are doable, depends on setup. Use a standard mike near the bell end?
Mire complicated to mic up unless in a hall or good studio room. For home recording when you often need close mic because the room acoustics aren’t ideal then you either have to have the mic further away to get a good balance of the while range or you’d want a two mic setup for better close recording.
 
More complicated to mic up unless in a hall or good studio room.
Actually, I was thinking of just that, studio or stage. But you have a good point when it comes to close quarters like a home studio. In that case I imagine one would have to experiment, and try different microphone setups, along with different types of mic's, maybe a combination of mic's.

It would be good if someone with practical experience mic'ing these were to chime in on they did it.
 
Actually, I was thinking of just that, studio or stage. But you have a good point when it comes to close quarters like a home studio. In that case I imagine one would have to experiment, and try different microphone setups, along with different types of mic's, maybe a combination of mic's.

It would be good if someone with practical experience mic'ing these were to chime in on they did it.
This was probably the reason they never sold well, why complicate matters when there is a perfectly good non straight tenor readly available.
 
This was probably the reason they never sold well, why complicate matters when there is a perfectly good non straight tenor readly available.
For the same reason back 13 years ago is why I bought a straight sop instead of curved. The other was more expensive and the straight did the same job.

The straight tenor is for someone who wants to make a statement with it. It's just a another choice in our free world. Everyone is different. I don't see many jumping on the bandwagon, else all the other manufacturers would be offering one, too.
 
For the same reason back 13 years ago is why I bought a straight sop instead of curved. The other was more expensive and the straight did the same job.
Except it doesn't - the curved sop is easier to mic and let's the player use a neck strap while more easily achieving an improved angle between mouthpiece and face.
The straight tenor is for someone who wants to make a statement with it. It's just a another choice in our free world. Everyone is different. I don't see many jumping on the bandwagon, else all the other manufacturers would be offering one, too.
The straight tenor, in contrast, provides no benefit other than - as you note - a statement. It would be tremendously awkward on the bandstand and very challenging to mic well. No chance of sitting while playing unless you carry a tall stool, or like to perch on the edge of an elevated stage.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,058
Messages
578,301
Members
8,127
Latest member
PJ2116
Back
Top Bottom