- Messages
- 2,582
- Location
- Hyde. Tameside.
If looked into there are probably many songs about controversial and objectionable subjects but should they all be banned?
And who by?If looked into there are probably many songs about controversial and objectionable subjects but should they all be banned?
And who picks which ones?And who by?
The Mary Whitehouse / snowflakes / cancel culture mobs?
Awesome kickin' song
The two are not necessarily mutually exclusive.No, it’s crude, macho, misogynistic stuff with a strong smell of racial stereotyping hanging around.
I don't think anybody here has suggested banning anything but they can still be commented on. Anytime anybody criticises a song, book, film or whatever for being of dubious taste they tend to quickly get accused of wanting to ban them. I think that e.g. Under My Thumb and It's a Man's World are pathetic, ignorant displays of mysogyny, and have done for over 30 years, I don't want them banned, I don't turn off the radio if they come on, but I do want to be able to say what I think about them without being dismissed as some Woke reactionary. Is criticism to be banned?If looked into there are probably many songs about controversial and objectionable subjects but should they all be banned?
No one here suggested banning them, it was that in the real world there are such attempts.I don't think anybody here has suggested banning anything but they can still be commented on. Anytime anybody criticises a song, book, film or whatever for being of dubious taste they tend to quickly get accused of wanting to ban them. I think that e.g. Under My Thumb and It's a Man's World are pathetic, ignorant displays of mysogyny, and have done for over 30 years,
My students ask me what kind of music I played. When "Brown Sugar" came up they told me it was inappropiate for a teacher to sing and play songs like that.I also have been playing that song for years. Yeah it’s risqué and lewd, but racist?…
The lyrics give Jagger/Richard’s view of How It Was a couple of hundred years ago. As far as I can see they don’t applaud or encourage that sort of behaviour now.
- But I accept that others may have different takes on it. I guess I’ll never be playing it again.
.- Tell them not to be judgmental, or they’ll learn nothing.My students ask me what kind of music I played. When "Brown Sugar" came up they told me it was inappropiate for a teacher to sing and play songs like that..
- Tell them not to be judgmental, or they’ll learn nothing.
I agree. A couple of weeks ago our Big Band was playing Chattanooga Choo Choo and I fell to thinking about "pardon me Boy", and "Boy, you can give me a shine". I imagine nobody would have batted an eyelid when the song was written but in the 21st century it got me feeling a bit uncomfortable; although I'm not about to stop playing it. If that qualifies me as a snowflake then so be it.I don't want them banned, I don't turn off the radio if they come on, but I do want to be able to say what I think about them without being dismissed as some Woke reactionary. Is criticism to be banned?
Well that’s my point. Uncontroversial wording in 1941 but we wouldn’t use it now.When it was written shoe shine boys existed so what was wrong with that wording.
Yes, you should leave them as written otherwise you lose the flavour.EDIT a quick search shows that line is now often replaced with "That's on the Tennessee Line". I should be pleased but it just sounds wrong to me. Probably just as well we play it as an instrumental.
