Personally, I feel "in writing" is the best way to negotiate things like a refund. It lets me at least appear calm and collected, and means I'm not rushed or put on the spot. I see phones as those things that random salesmen and "Injuries specialist lawywers" (i.e. shysters) use to make my life miserable. On the whole, Alexander Graham Bell has a lot to answer for. However, I do get that email sometimes just plain breaks down.
I wasn't going to go into the details, but since you ask, here goes.
I have to admit, I thought the same thing about repairmen being used to more expensive saxes. He's the expert though, so I have to listen to his opinion about the mechanics of a sax. I went there to ask for it, and I got it. It would seem a bit stupid to completely ignore it. The music shop he does work for sells a £500 Elkhart tenor sax, so I guess he's used to something more than just Yamaha/Selmer etc, whether he approves or not.
The main faults were pads not seated correctly, and needing a lot of pressure on the keys to make them seal well enough to play the low end of the scale. I'd worked up to that over a two week period, and was beginning to be able to get low notes, but not great and not consistently. They were a bit flat too - from low D downwards. When I managed to get low Bb, that was in tune, according to ClearTune. Playing up from the first octave to middle D, legato (bottom end of the second octave, with the register key), was giving me problems too - I was getting a nasty squawk. At first I thought it was overblowing, but that didn't seem quite right. I think more likely, one of the left hand keys wasn't closing quite when I expected it to.
As it was my first tenor, I thought it might all be my fault, so I took it to be checked and adjusted, to make sure. Sadly, I wasn't the main problem.
It also had a shallow dent around one of the posts - at the top of the hinge rod for the high F# key. I asked if that actually mattered - I'd have guessed it didn't, but he told me it put keys out of alignment. Even so, if that, and the intonation on the low notes were the only problems, I'd have kept it. And no, it didn't get dented, or dropped, or banged against anything while I had it, and it arrived in a box with no signs of damage, in a well padded, unblemished case, so my guess is that it wasn't damaged by the courier. To be fair, it was easy to miss the dent though - I managed to not see it for two weeks. He spotted it as soon as he picked up the sax.
There was also some sealant (probably epoxy, apparently) bulging out of the seam between the body and the bow, inside the bore. There was a noticeable blob protruding above the low Eb tone hole. From messing about with keyless flutes and whistles, I've found a protrusion inside the bore is not a good thing. He didn't see it as serious, just a bit shoddy. I would guess it contributed to the low end intonation problems, but I'm no expert.
I'd decided I'd be happy to pay to get it regulated, just for the convenience, if that's all it needed. I was hoping that would come to £30-£40, at most. He estimated it would cost over £100 to get it playing properly, if he did the work, and told me in no uncertain terms he had no desire to, and I shouldn't bother. His advice was to send it back, and after thinking about it for a while, I decided to do just that.
I'm not fussy about instruments, but I do expect them to be fully functional, when I buy one new. That's actually the most I've ever paid for an instrument. When I spend that much again, I'll want to see it, and play it, before I part with the money.
I don't need my instruments to be perfect - I have a Chinese G clarinet (pitched between a Bb and an alto clarinet) that's hopelessly out of tune (i.e. some way off a recognisable scale), that I just love, despite its faults. If the pads didn't seal, that would be a different matter. My soprano sax is a Chinese Venus that was around £200 new, and I'm very fond of that too. My alto is nicer - a Trevor James Revolution II, but I just got lucky on buying that second hand. I got to play that briefly before I bought it, though, so I did get some idea of how well it worked. Quite well. One day it will get serviced, but for now, I'm fine with it as it is.
On the plus side, I've now got a mini-statement from a cash machine that tells me I've had a refund of the price of the sax - less the postage to send it to me. I am a little bit miffed at paying postage both ways on an instrument that didn't work properly - much more to send it back than it cost to get it sent to me - but that's life. At least it's done with.
This sort of thing was the reason I chose not to buy from Gear4music. I asked them once and they told me they don't check things over before they're sent out. Fair enough; that's their policy, but that's not a game I want to play. No one's perfect, of course. An instrument can be checked, and faults can still be missed, I suppose. Possibly this one just missed being checked all together. In future I'll give more serious thought to buying secondhand, face to face.
Hmm... I could certainly use a hug, but the cost of having myself shipped to Basingstoke would be prohibitive.