Playing the saxophone Returning Player Vintage vs Modern

Charm03

New Member
Messages
2
Hello,

As the title suggests.. I played saxophone for about 10 years through Elementary School to High School (playing alto and tenor during this period but looking at picking up an alto to start). I sold my saxophone shortly after starting college as I didn't play it as much as I thought I would. I recently have been dying to get back into playing and am looking at picking up a saxophone to start re-learning on. When I dwindled out of playing I was really wanting to get a vintage sax so I've been looking at some local/eBay but am stuck debating whether I should rent-to-own a modern saxophone or find a nice (already overhauled) vintage sax to relearn on.

I have read some other threads about completely fresh students learning on vintage sax's but I feel like my situation is slightly different. Any help/opinions is greatly appreciated! If it helps at all i have been looking at a Buescher True Tone as my vintage option. My local shop has a rent-to-own on a Yamaha 480 so these are kind of what I'm comparing. Obviously the price difference is significant I am just trying to see if re-learning on a Buescher would hinder me at all.

Thank you for any input!
 
I was in a similar position, I ended up back on the horn I played at school, then bought a NWII alto, followed by a NWII tenor.

Try a vintage horn if you can, some say the ergonomics aren't as good as modern horns, where I seem to prefer it, intonation can be funny, depending on mouthpiece choice.

I don't think a vintage horn will hinder you, it might take a little more effort, but that's all part of the fun.
 
If you are just getting back to playing get yourself a mid price Japanese horn, I'm obviously thinking Yamaha, and get back into playing. When you are comfortable and sure you are committed then start looking for a vintage horn if you still want one. It's likely that you won't be able to evaluate a vintage horn if you haven't played for a long while.
 
I am in sort of similar situation. Just picked up my tenor a couple of months ago and re-learning everything. My usual long term horn is a Yamaha YTS62, and just had it serviced after it sat in its case for 20 years. Now it plays like butter. GAS creeped in in an ugly way and very recently picked up a very nicely priced and well setup Selmer Mark VII. It is kind of like a half vintage horn, definitely not like a Buescher or a Conn. After all Yamaha "copied" the Selmer keywork mechanism and further "improves" it. But still, by ergonomics there is night and day difference, and I am well aware of the "dreaded" Mark VII finger stretching keywork design. My heart says I want to have that robust Selmer core in my arsenal, yet I could do much better with the 62. So I would echo a lot of the comments, a mid priced Yamaha horn is a great re-starting point and home base, and go from there when GAS rears its ugly head again.
 
🙂🙂 I started on a really cheap Buffet mid 60's. I seem to remember it was in exchange for a drum kit and the asking price was £400. With a later repad it was everything I needed at the time. I still have it BTW!! Say's alot huh?? Regards 🙂🙂
 
If you have a competent player friend, you could have them "proof" a potential buy at a store. There are many variables involved as some overhauls/rebuilds are better than others, depending on the skill of the repairer.

Of course, buying a new "reputable" make sax from a reputable dealer adds a sense of safety, even if entry level.

Bargain saxes​

I've been reluctant to buy the bargain saxes from the Orient, as their factories vary from excellent to so-so. One I bought was the label "Venus" from China, as doing research a decade ago, seems this brand had positive comments versus others. So far I have their straight soprano sax that I bought in US from Musical Wheel, an E-Bay vendor for $225 US and a tenor sax for $400.

Otherwise, I have steered clear of other labels as research and comments herein this and other forums have exposed their weaknesses, as tempting as price may prove. From what I am told, saxes by reputable manufacturers from 1967 and older generally were of at least intermediate quality.

Bargain sax cases​

After continuous use, the soprano sax of less expensive cloth covered zippered moulded foam, the zipper broke. I replaced the zipper mechanism with an after market. Then the zipper track failed. Now it resides in an aftermarket much sturdier Protec case. The tenor case now is getting more ragged and foresee replacing it in near future.

Thus, the cost of cases enters into the equation. Sometimes spending a little more on a brand name sax may net overall better worth if nothing else, comes with a decent case. My intermediate grade Antigua Winds Low-A Bari (from Taiwan) I bought about 5 years ago came with a heavy duty luggage grade hard case with wheels, cost $2,500 US a couple years ago from Quinn the Eskimo in Seattle, WA, US area. He advertises on The Woodwind Forum.

It was a new in original box discontinued model that sold a few years prior on other on-line big stores for $4,400 US. It plays as well as a pro model.

My older Antigua Winds pro model alto that I bought used on internet auction for $350 US a decade ago plays as well as my Yamaha YAS-61 pro that I had.

Fun instruments​

Also bought a plastic Venus Eb sopranino clarinet from Musical Wheel for under $100 US (now sold out). Back then I gather he had a large lot of them and so I took the dive. It's intonation is not that great, requiring me to play it in tune, but I made do. I could see how a beginner could struggle with such an instrument. I love it, because for a time I tucked it away on travel, plugged my netbook with mp3 backing tracks ripped to files, used the motel's TV for amplification, had fun jamming with it.

Closing​

Since I do most of my repairs, I make do with what I have. However, what is good for me may not be good for others. However being older now, just like me and others here, I'm sure you'll make the right decision.

I do have an old Bundy II alto sax, it plays okay but has more key clicks as it uses cheaper engineered mechanics. I have used it for inclimate weather playing, like for bell ringing for The Salvation Army donation kettles at store fronts. Bought it 23 years ago when getting back into playing, has been a solid practise instrument and good backup for my other alto when it's in repair.
 
Hello,

As the title suggests.. I played saxophone for about 10 years through Elementary School to High School (playing alto and tenor during this period but looking at picking up an alto to start). I sold my saxophone shortly after starting college as I didn't play it as much as I thought I would. I recently have been dying to get back into playing and am looking at picking up a saxophone to start re-learning on. When I dwindled out of playing I was really wanting to get a vintage sax so I've been looking at some local/eBay but am stuck debating whether I should rent-to-own a modern saxophone or find a nice (already overhauled) vintage sax to relearn on.

I have read some other threads about completely fresh students learning on vintage sax's but I feel like my situation is slightly different. Any help/opinions is greatly appreciated! If it helps at all i have been looking at a Buescher True Tone as my vintage option. My local shop has a rent-to-own on a Yamaha 480 so these are kind of what I'm comparing. Obviously the price difference is significant I am just trying to see if re-learning on a Buescher would hinder me at all.

Thank you for any input!
First off I believe many vintage models are perfectly good for absolute starting players. There's a bit of sillinness to the argument that they are not. Some are not. But many models are.

With that said as you used to play and you wanted to get a vintage horn, and want to now...go for it. You have some playing experience already.

BEWARE - eBay vintage horns will NOT be in play condition unless the seller guarantees it is !
 
When I dwindled out of playing I was really wanting to get a vintage sax so I've been looking at some local/eBay but am stuck debating whether I should rent-to-own a modern saxophone or find a nice (already overhauled) vintage sax to relearn on.

I have read some other threads about completely fresh students learning on vintage sax's but I feel like my situation is slightly different. Any help/opinions is greatly appreciated! If it helps at all i have been looking at a Buescher True Tone as my vintage option. My local shop has a rent-to-own on a Yamaha 480 so these are kind of what I'm comparing. Obviously the price difference is significant I am just trying to see if re-learning on a Buescher would hinder me at all.

Thank you for any input!

Some Buescher TrueTones are really great horns. I prefer the models that have the "nail file" G# key (vs "push-button" aka "typewriter" G# touch). Condition is everything when playing vintage horns. In good fettle, they can be wonderful - any horn is poor condition is a pain to play.
 
Beware of pre-1928 Martins as they don't have the C# adjuster and it makes intonation sharp in the palm keys. Some Indianas based on earlier tooling may have this issue too.
 
Beware of pre-1928 Martins as they don't have the C# adjuster and it makes intonation sharp in the palm keys. Some Indianas based on earlier tooling may have this issue too.
Maybe you missed this.
I have read some other threads about completely fresh students learning on vintage sax's but I feel like my situation is slightly different. Any help/opinions is greatly appreciated! If it helps at all i have been looking at a Buescher True Tone as my vintage option. My local shop has a rent-to-own on a Yamaha 480 so these are kind of what I'm comparing. Obviously the price difference is significant I am just trying to see if re-learning on a Buescher would hinder me at all.
 
Maybe you missed this.
I reread the first post. Buescher True Tones are a solid choice with great intonation and ergonomics! They have a smallish bore and bell but play nicely. The Yamaha is also a good choice but won’t have the sound / character of the Buescher. I play a vintage horn for this reason. The Buescher will be easier to fall in love with and cherish as a piece of history. But if you want the most modern engineering and a horn almost any tech can work on, go with the Yamaha.
 
Maybe post the serial # of the Buescher you're looking at so that the particular vintage can be determined. Generally a later instrument has better keywork and intonation and will have a Front F.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,063
Messages
578,432
Members
8,130
Latest member
tommyliehe
Back
Top Bottom