- Messages
- 7,981
- Location
- Bristol, UK
Strictly speaking, Carols don't have to be Christmassy, but mostly they are nowadays.
Strictly speaking, Carols don't have to be Christmassy, but mostly they are nowadays.
Not according to Wikipedia.Do they have to be Christian ?
Rhys
I've just looked it up in Grove: "A medieval strophic song in English or Latin, beginning with a burden (refrain) which is repeated after each stanza..."There must be something else that defines a carol though as a repeating verse/chorus form is probably the most common form of song.
No. Whilst they are usually religious or moral stories, but they were also used for secular events, sung to popular melodiesDo they have to be Christian ?
Rhys
Also, wouldn't it be a bit weird to put Rit.. in a repeated phrase?
Commenting on the fly. 🤔I'm sure the discussion of the entomology of "carol" is what cracked it.
The last bit isNot really. It's just a tempo marking.
A repeat.Oh tidings of comfort and joy
Comfort and joy
Oh tidings of comfort and joy
That'd be Dipteroligy ... As opposed to dipsomaniaCommenting on the fly. 🤔

Here's one to dance to:I've also been told that proper carols were suitable for dance, eg. "We Saw Three Ships", unlike "O Come All Ye Faithful" which would be classified as a Christmas hymn rather than a carol.
Keef is a busy boy in that one.
