Tech/maintenance Reducing The Diameter Of The Octave Pips On My Martin Comm III

Jazz Is All

Member
Messages
861
Location
Barcelona, Spain
Many moons ago when I first got my Buescher TT 4, I read a post on SOTW (of which I was a member for many years) by Bruce Bailey about reducing the diameter of the pips on those horns to improve their intonation up top. Bruce, if you don't know him, is a flute maker, tech, and seller who lives in Florida and knows a lot about True Tones. The method was quite simple to carry out and involves simply inserting a short piece of hollow plastic cut from either a Q-tip or a ballpoint pen cartridge into both pips. That reduces their inner diameter and improves the intonation of the sax. I did that, and Voilà, it worked and I have enjoyed the improved sound of that sax ever since then.

So just a week ago I wondered if that would help out the intonation on my Comm III because let's face it, it isn't even all the way up and down any more than any vintage horn is or can be. So I found some appropriate sized ballpoint pen cartridges with not much ink in the upper part and cut that off. Then I slipped one into the Neck pip and played it. Wow, it improved immediately but when I went to do the same in the body pip I had a hard time doing it from the top of the open tenon end. A combination of poor eyesight lack of light, shadows caused by my hand holding the plastic piece in the tweezers and the piece not going in straight and falling into the bell. I left it for another day.

Yesterday was the day and I decided the best way was to remove that octave key mechanism entirely and put the plastic piece in from the outside. Easy as pie, and it also gave me a chance to oil the rod inside the tube, and now I have my tenor with much more even intonation and putting out altissimo much more easily.

I wonder if anyone else has done this on a 1940s horn too.
 
Not contradicting you per se, but for others who may hit this in the future I would add that what fixes intonation for one person may not actually fix things but may create problems for others (maybe partly due to different tuning spots due to tone production or body differences even when playing the same mouthpiece & reed).

I remember having had problems years ago with the intonation of the 2va right hand on Martin Committee tenors, and I remember having them across years with different Martin tenors. Strangely, now -- and I'm probably not playing the same mouthpiece now, but I have always been a large chamber Link-ish fan, basically always playing a Link-based piece -- anyway, strangely, now, I am on this Martin tenor kick and I don't have those issues with the 2va RH intonation any more. It's possible my ears have just gotten worse with time and age, but I think it's more some change in tone production and technique.

All to say, I have not ever done this for intonation, but my solution for TT altos with poor intonation is "Get an 01 or different neck," which usually works.

FWIW, there is also a mod that used to be more common than it is now where octave pips were *increased* in size, and/or their influence over how fast air moved through them was altered in other ways, for example threading them and so forth. Usually enlarging an octave pip will fatten the voicing of the notes played by hits venting, but also alter intonation. It stands to reason that shrinking the vent may alter voicing as well, but that that may or may not matter or even be noticeable to some players.

There are a lot of interesting acoustic alterations that have been recommended and/or sort of faddish over time on the web, and often you do not get the feedback that really covers all the possibilities or effects -- some of which are quite pronounced.

A good example is a mod that was touted far and wide, years ago, of cutting the octave vent chimneys short, to get some particular effect -- I now forget what that was, because although it did create that effect it usually also introduced whistling on certain notes, e.g. A for the body octave, and some other note for the neck octave. I discarded it and never picked it back up after trying it, back then, and the whistling was very real, but I think I never read anybody but me comment on it after reading about it. I think most people never tried it, and when the person touting it was paid to do it customers either didn't notice or were too afraid to say anything.

I'd be curious to read more experiences with this alteration, too. I am not contradicting you by saying that. I'm saying I'm interested. And adding some backstory/context.

FWIW, of fixes for TT altos that occur to me off the top of my head, indeed most of them are about restricting airflow through the octave pips, not accelerating it.
 
So which direction does this push the intonation? Is it as simple as smaller pip diameter flattens notes played with it, or is it more complex?

I remember reading a paper some years ago where (I believe) all the main variables were considered (ID, protrusion into bore, length of tube) but the results made my head explode. I was looking for a cure for bass sax middle D/Eb but I don't think I found one.
 
I was looking for a cure for bass sax middle D/Eb but I don't think I found one.
I think, as Palo implied in his first sentence, that one size doesn’t fit all. This to me is fascinating because maybe for player A some mod makes it sharp, but for player B it goes flat.

Big can of worms here IMO
 
It's much simpler to use a mouthpiece that works than dabble in the modification guesswork area.
I agree. I use to look at the original mouthpiece that came along with the sax when in was new. Try mouthpieces that are in the same style. A mouthpiece with a big round chamber never worked for me on my Martin Committes. Very unstable in the upper register. I think the mouthpiece should be considered to be a part of the saxophone.
 
Since I had my Martin "The Martin" tenor overhauled by Stuart Jenkins at Matthew's Muziek (NL), already several years back, intonation has been spot on for me, including the notorious E2/F2. Besides, the keywork feels like a race car (in the good sense of the word ;-) ).

A Phil-Tone Eclipse works very well for me (and my experience with @Phil has been great!)
 
What kind of chamber does a Phil-Tone Eclipse have?

A Martin (The Martin) original have have a slightly smaller chamber than the bore. A "The Martin" tenor and alto mpc are playing fine on all Committees. But the Martin mpc's are not so good. Meyer, Berg Larsen, Link are often used by Martin players.

I don't know why a medium/small or small chamber is the best for best for me as a Martin Committee player? Any ideas?

I found a very nice mouthpiece to my Martin Committee -38. A small mouthpiece with a small bore and chamber. A bullet high baffle with a slightly roll over baffle mpc. The bore is 2 mm smaller than the bore on my Rovners. This little piece is a heavy one as well. A plasticover reed is just too much "buzz".
Since I had my Martin "The Martin" tenor overhauled by Stuart Jenkins at Matthew's Muziek (NL), already several years back, intonation has been spot on for me, including the notorious E2/F2. Besides, the keywork feels like a race car (in the good sense of the word ;-) ).

A Phil-Tone Eclipse works very well for me (and my experience with @Phil has been great!)
 
Since I had my Martin "The Martin" tenor overhauled by Stuart Jenkins at Matthew's Muziek (NL), already several years back, intonation has been spot on for me, including the notorious E2/F2. Besides, the keywork feels like a race car (in the good sense of the word ;-) ).

A Phil-Tone Eclipse works very well for me (and my experience with @Phil has been great!)

I thought that the "notorious E2/F2" was on The Martin baritones - it certainly was for me.

Rhys
 
Lot to unpack here.

When a saxophone is designed, they have to pick a "design volume" and a "design position" for the mouthpiece, in order to place the tone holes at their appropriate locations along the sounding length of the tube. When the thing's designed, then, there's an ideal mouthpiece internal volume and an ideal place for that mouthpiece on the neck that give the correct tone hole positions for the ideal sounding length that's formed by the combination of neck and tube.

If you have to push a mouthpiece further on the neck than the design position in order to get the average note on the horn in tune, the short-tube notes will tend sharp and the long-tube notes will tend flat. If you have to pull a mouthpiece further out than the design position, it'll be the reverse.

The most common complaints I see about older American horns have to do with needing to pull way out to get the "average note" in tune. And then the upper notes are flat and the lower notes are sharp. And people start putting crescents in the bell key tone holes and raising palm key heights to the moon (which also makes those notes squirrely). Why's this happening? As far as I can tell, the old American horns tended to be designed based on a larger internal mouthpiece volume and a shorter total sounding length than what's common today. Put a modern small chamber mouthpiece on, and it's likely you'll be pulled out a lot further than was intended. Of course, mouthpiece makers make the shank longer so the thing is mechanically secure on the neck, but that doesn't fix the acoustic problem.

But when you drastically change the sounding length of the horn, some other things can happen. Remember the saxophone has a lot of under-vented notes; the bore isn't a perfect cone but instead it's got lumps all down it from tone holes; tone hole sizes and positions have to be fudged due to the undervented notes that arise from needing twelve tone holes to vent an octave worth's of notes but we only have eight fingers to work with. And one of the common issues is the super-sharp middle E and F. Those notes tend a bit sharp on a lot of old American horns anyway, but in my experience the situation's many times worse if you're pulled way way out. For some reason it seems most serious on older American baritones like Martin and Conn.

The acoustically sound solution here is to use a mouthpiece with an appropriate chamber size - for the particular horn. Then you put it on the neck at the appropriate point so the distance from the tip of the mouthpiece to the end of the horn is about what the horn was designed for. As I've said, in most cases I think that's going to be a larger chamber piece, further on the neck. And yes, Virginia, large chamber mouthpieces with high baffles and bright sounds do exist.

It's my opinion that as long as you keep going with a setup that forces you to deviate excessively from the sounding length the horn was designed at, by either pulling way way out (or pushing way way in, but that seems much rarer), all these efforts at fiddly-dicking around with octave vent diameters, key heights, crescents, etc., are just putting patches on symptoms, not addressing root causes.
 
One of the few sources of information I have been able to find has been the paper by Arthur Benade that I have attached. The hand drawn illustration on the last page contains a lot of information. Reading that portion of Benade's book: Fundamental's of Musical Acoustics helps to understand some of the terms and abbreviations used in the formulas. What I want to call attention to is Benade's comment to his friend George Jameson who was a master repair technician and student of acoustics that he added at the bottom of the page: "A FINAL WORD: THE EXACT SIZE IS NOT CRITICAL" referring to the diameter of the octave vent.

he only other information I can offer on this topic is from Gary Scavone's Thesis. He writes that the body octave vent is in the ideal location for the note F and the neck octave vent is in the ideal location for the note B. The further away a note using this octave vent is from the ideal note, the sharper the note will be when the octave vent is opened
 

Attachments

I will say that different instruments place the octave vents in different places. I've looked at my different horns and the lower vent position with respect to tone holes varies by up to a whole hole (?) And visually you can see that neck vents are in a lot of different places. So for the one particular model, it may well be that the notes F and B are targeted, but I'd suggest that's not always the case.
 
I am reminded of a story a "friend" recently experienced. He is a landlord for a house full of Stanford post-docs -- people very gifted in abstract/analytical thinking, probably none with IQs under 130. During lockdowns, two tenants of his who share a bathroom informed him, "Bathroom light fixture seems to be going out...it appears to be a wiring problem."

He texted back, "What is it that indicates it's a wiring problem?"

They informed him, "Well, the way the lights are behaving, we can tell it kind of has to be a wiring problem. The two bulbs are both flickering, so...." They are both science/engineering background, one is geologist, the other a computer science post-doc.

Landlord friend gets in touch with his contractor bud's son-in-law -- a GED high school graduate whom contractor detests for being kind of a stupid buttholio -- who is a licensed electrician.

They schedule all the stuff that needs to be scheduled, which is kind of complicated because this was during lockdowns and his property has half a dozen tenants, not just these two lightbulb analysts. When I say that, you can see where this is going from the wording....

Landlord and friend's son-in-law, the electrician show up at the appointed time, house is empty, and they go in through a back door to minimize Covid concerns -- it's a big production because of the pandemic timing.

Electrician goes in bathroom, flips light switch two times. Stands there a moment. Flips switch again.

"You got any fresh lightbulbs?" Electrician says.

(It's good to flip the light switch and actually touch the bulbs!)

I don't find that this particular (octave pip) question comes up that much any more, thanks to changes in what players are playing, these days, as compared to 20 years ago, and as well a more widespread literacy in the various ways to address, for example, sharp high notes in old TTs (most people know that an 01 neck change will solve that, in particular, for example). A bigger factor is probably that more people play new PRC and Taiwan saxophones that don't have these kinds of issues, which means fewer of them are playing vintage American or other horns in the same pricing rung that do have them. I personally still see the place of a good TT alto -- nothing modern has that bottom to the sound, or that particular kind of classic sound and character. But I would and have solved that issue via neck substitutions, since discovering that that's a workaround. I really have not had anybody ask me for pantyhose or a sleeve insert or anything like that in over 12 or 15 years.
 
Last edited:
I will say that different instruments place the octave vents in different places. I've looked at my different horns and the lower vent position with respect to tone holes varies by up to a whole hole (?) And visually you can see that neck vents are in a lot of different places. So for the one particular model, it may well be that the notes F and B are targeted, but I'd suggest that's not always the case.
Interesting observation. I am going to watch for that from now on. There is a simple way to test which note(s) are in the ideal location for the octave vent. That is to play each note in its lower register and then "overblow" the note to its harmonic an octave higher. Then add the octave key to see how many cents sharper that makes the note compared to the harmonic pitch.
 
I thought that the "notorious E2/F2" was on The Martin baritones - it certainly was for me.

Rhys

It may very well be that my Martin tenor originally (when I got it) suffered from incorrect key heights, leading to a sharp right hand.

Anyway, a proper setup a couple years ago (almost ten years now?) solved that for me. The mouthpiece I prefer on it, a Phil-Tone Eclipse, is in the same category as the OL Tone Edge; medium large chamber, roll over baffle. What sets the Eclipse apart from my two OLs is the evenness of playing. With the Tone Edge, I always had the feeling there were some notes I had to work harder on, to make them sound good.
 
It may very well be that my Martin tenor originally (when I got it) suffered from incorrect key heights, leading to a sharp right hand.

Anyway, a proper setup a couple years ago (almost ten years now?) solved that for me. The mouthpiece I prefer on it, a Phil-Tone Eclipse, is in the same category as the OL Tone Edge; medium large chamber, roll over baffle. What sets the Eclipse apart from my two OLs is the evenness of playing. With the Tone Edge, I always had the feeling there were some notes I had to work harder on, to make them sound good.

I had it on Martin Committee tenors (more than 1) in the past, in the 2va F/F#/E area, but I don't any more. The Martin C tenor I recently OH'ed for myself is actually the easiest of the tenors I keep for myself to play in tune without much effort.

It's possible a mouthpiece change is related, but I think it's just changes in control (the longer and more you play, the more control you have, without even thinking about it). When I felt the 2va right hand was uneven, it was with an older II-V-I brass Ponzol, which has something of an unusual facing by today's standards, i.e. as compared to contemporary norms, which seem to me (so far, as a noob to refacing) to basically follow three types of curves. I play a different II-V-I today from then (but still an older brass .110, with identical facing numbers to my old one -- which not all II-V-Is have), but I also found Stephan Kammerer's Omnis .110 to be a nice match to Martin (gives some focus to a horn and intensity that has an overabundance of breadth and darkness) was easy to play on it.

I suspect improvements in the facings of the mouthpieces most people play -- especially people making posts on the internet, as opposed to not making posts on the internet -- have better facings than the pieces people played in the past.

Keith Bradbury's (aka Mojobari's) sharing of information both in forums/discussion groups and on Youtube, as well as elsewhere have greatly influenced a whole generation of mouthpiece refacers and designers in terms of how detailed and technical their approach to facings is today.

I have some mouthpieces that are exceptional players by now-famous/vaunted mpc specialists whose facings are not as even (meaning that have some skewed/uneven places in the facings) as some of the facings on relatively new refacers who are sort of hot/renowned at present. The standard and expectation of not just refacers but players is much more technical than in the past as far as facings. That will tend to create better results (i.e. widespread technical standards/norms being raised, even if mainly in terms of facings, but to a lesser degree in terms of baffles, volumes etc. etc. etc.) all around for people on horns particularly in the area of response, but also of intonation. It can literally lead to horns not seeming to have problems that the *horns* were thought, or experienced, to have in the past, due to mouthpiece anomalies being sort of more regular (even if what was regular was their not being more regular, in a different way, relative to each other).

A TLDR way of saying all that, shorthandedly: with my Ponzol II-V-I there are two possibilities, both absolutely for sure in play: (1) I'm used to my Ponzol, from playing it or its nearly identical twin for 20 years, even if without discipline, and it's like an appendage of my body. My mind moves it unconsciously, the same way as your mind moves your hand or eyes, to touch or see something (this isn't unique, I think every player with good tone production is like this on any piece they have played for more than a few years). And, (2) it's possible the newer Ponzol I'm playing is slightly better than its predecessor. #2 is sort of confirmed by how easy it is for me to play in tune (at least to my own aging ears, that aren't as pitch sensitive as 10 years ago) with a 10MFan Showtime and the Kammerer Omnis, while being unfamiliar with them. I have trouble "saying" things with those pieces, because bending notes and the inherent voicings of notes on them is different -- which points to my not having very good control of them, as well as to their likely being inherently easier to play in tune on most horns (at least for me, with my physical and technical/tone production attributes).

Intonation is certainly not "just" in the horn, ever.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,076
Messages
578,681
Members
8,136
Latest member
peterdehelegrote
Back
Top Bottom