Tech/maintenance Question, my saxophone is cracked

It's all brass there, every thing has the same coefficient of thermal expansion. You can thermal shock it for 50 years and there won't BE any thermal stress.

As square as that crack is to the edges, I wonder if the clamp was originally two pieces and brazed together? A failed seam could occur when tightening it due to bad substrate preparation or a cold joint.

At any rate, it needs to be fixed, because the clamp's no longer doing its job of mechanically fixing the bell-bow assy to the main tube. I already mentioned the ways this could create problems.

If the clamp can be removed without removing the bell-bow assembly, then I'd take it off, silver solder the crack, pollish it up, and reinstall. If the bell-bow assy has to come off, I'd separate it, clean the pookie off, and solder that joint; then you can repair the clamp and reinstall.

If you're all verklempt about losing lacquer finish on the clamp when it's repaired, you could TRY to find a replacement.
 
It's all brass there, every thing has the same coefficient of thermal expansion. You can thermal shock it for 50 years and there won't BE any thermal stress.

As square as that crack is to the edges, I wonder if the clamp was originally two pieces and brazed together? A failed seam could occur when tightening it due to bad substrate preparation or a cold joint.

At any rate, it needs to be fixed, because the clamp's no longer doing its job of mechanically fixing the bell-bow assy to the main tube. I already mentioned the ways this could create problems.

If the clamp can be removed without removing the bell-bow assembly, then I'd take it off, silver solder the crack, pollish it up, and reinstall. If the bell-bow assy has to come off, I'd separate it, clean the pookie off, and solder that joint; then you can repair the clamp and reinstall.

Good stuff, turf3. I don't know this part well enough to know how its made.

Still waiting to hear from a repair tech that has seen these bits - 1-piece band vs 2-piece (ala Selmer). A 2-piece band can be replaced without removing the bow (unless you want to reseal the joint).

Here's a short video of the Selmer-style body band (aka joint ring):
View: https://www.youtube.com/shorts/LkQuq1tdHWo

Edit: Here's an expanded schematic from Yamaha - looks like a 1-piece joint ring (although we still don't know how it is manufactured).

 
It's all brass there, every thing has the same coefficient of thermal expansion. You can thermal shock it for 50 years and there won't BE any thermal stress.

As square as that crack is to the edges, I wonder if the clamp was originally two pieces and brazed together? A failed seam could occur when tightening it due to bad substrate preparation or a cold joint.

At any rate, it needs to be fixed, because the clamp's no longer doing its job of mechanically fixing the bell-bow assy to the main tube. I already mentioned the ways this could create problems.

If the clamp can be removed without removing the bell-bow assembly, then I'd take it off, silver solder the crack, pollish it up, and reinstall. If the bell-bow assy has to come off, I'd separate it, clean the pookie off, and solder that joint; then you can repair the clamp and reinstall.

If you're all verklempt about losing lacquer finish on the clamp when it's repaired, you could TRY to find a replacement.
I was wondering about the same thing.
BTW, interesting spelling of verklempt, I haven't heard that word in about 4 decades but we called it verklemmt.
 
Actually AFAIK it originates in the electrcian's trade, "was man tagsueber verklemmt, kann man am Abend verloeten". which is an idiom for "whatever you steal in a day, you can drink away at night"
My gramps was high voltage electrician at Thyssen and he did not like some of his colleages who dug out copper lines to sell them on the black market - and then he had to fix the damage the next day.
In addition, it's a colloquialism for overly prude.
 
I rather suspect it was in Yiddish long before there were electricians. Means "overcome with emotion". Quick Google search claims it's drawn from Middle German.

Anyway, old jazz guys here in the US tend to use a fair number of Yiddish expressions.
 
I rather suspect it was in Yiddish long before there were electricians. Means "overcome with emotion". Quick Google search claims it's drawn from Middle German.

Anyway, old jazz guys here in the US tend to use a fair number of Yiddish expressions.
The funny thing about German language is that the same words can have completely different meanings in different regions. Ask somebody in Northern Germany for a Schnalle (belt buckle) and they send you to a department store, ask somebody in Southern Germany and they'll send you to a brothel.

But there are a lot of Yiddish influences for sure, especially in the Bohemian area.
 
The bottom bow joint is glued on - but the clamp is a single piece job with a pair of screws for tightening it up.
I've never seen one that's failed in this manner. The crack looks suspiciously straight, as though it's followed a seam - but I really can't imagine they'd have made this part in two sections. There wouldn't be any point.
I suppose you could say 'Classic Grifith's crack' but I seriously doubt there'd be enough stress on the clamp to propagate that kind of failure.
Bit of mystery - and about the only thing that makes any sense would be a flaw in the alloy...and even that's a bit sketchy.

Cheap enough to fix - I can't imagine a replacement clamp is all that expensive - but it really does need sorting out pronto otherwise nastier things might happen.
 
The bottom bow joint is glued on - but the clamp is a single piece job with a pair of screws for tightening it up.
I've never seen one that's failed in this manner. The crack looks suspiciously straight, as though it's followed a seam - but I really can't imagine they'd have made this part in two sections. There wouldn't be any point.
I suppose you could say 'Classic Grifith's crack' but I seriously doubt there'd be enough stress on the clamp to propagate that kind of failure.
Bit of mystery - and about the only thing that makes any sense would be a flaw in the alloy...and even that's a bit sketchy.

Cheap enough to fix - I can't imagine a replacement clamp is all that expensive - but it really does need sorting out pronto otherwise nastier things might happen.
How do they put the clamp into position, put it just above as they join the two halves of the body or slide it down after?
A possibly, probably, ridiculous idea is that someone bent it open a bit for convenience then used the screws to tighten the clamp which stressed it.
 
A one piece clamp would have to be slipped on before joining the bell-bow assy to the main tube, then moved into position and tightened.

One would assume that the clamp is made from three pieces - the ring, made straight and rolled into a ring; the flange with the threaded screw holes; and the flange with the unthreaded screw holes, the three pieces being silver soldered together after rolling the ring, and then finish machined. That process wouldn't leave any kind of a seam in the ring. But the crack sure looks like a failure at a seam.
 
A one piece clamp would have to be slipped on before joining the bell-bow assy to the main tube, then moved into position and tightened.

One would assume that the clamp is made from three pieces - the ring, made straight and rolled into a ring; the flange with the threaded screw holes; and the flange with the unthreaded screw holes, the three pieces being silver soldered together after rolling the ring, and then finish machined. That process wouldn't leave any kind of a seam in the ring. But the crack sure looks like a failure at a seam.
I have seen similar localized failures on fragile tensile samples that were mishandled and accidentally bent and re-straightened.
 
It's just that it's brass for crying out loud, highly ductile, and from the size of the component (compared to the wee screws used to tighten it), it ought to be hell for stout. I agree, "bent and straightened" seems the most likely cause, but I'm not enamored of it.

At any rate, the root cause isn't really important, but this condition does need to be repaired chop chop, before it leads to leaks, especially in the bell keys. First prize would be to get a replacement clamp. Second prize would probably be to solder the joint and then solder the clamp over it. I mean, really, how many times in the life of a horn do you ACTUALLY need to take off the bell-bow assembly? I have five curved saxophones and not a one of them as far as I can tell has ever had that joint taken apart, and they range from 50 to 90 years in age.
 
At any rate, the root cause isn't really important, but this condition does need to be repaired chop chop, before it leads to leaks, especially in the bell keys. First prize would be to get a replacement clamp. Second prize would probably be to solder the joint and then solder the clamp over it. I mean, really, how many times in the life of a horn do you ACTUALLY need to take off the bell-bow assembly? I have five curved saxophones and not a one of them as far as I can tell has ever had that joint taken apart, and they range from 50 to 90 years in age.
If I were asked to repair this clamp I wouldn't bother with trying to (silver) solder the crack - I'd just soft-solder a patch over it. Plenty strong enough for the job in hand, and a much cheaper/quicker job.

Having to remove a bell is not a particularly common job (baritones excepted) - but the big advantage of a glued joint is that there's very little chance of damaging the finish. Realignment is easier too, as you have some time before the glue cures to make small adjustments in the bell angle. This can be a huge time/cost-saver when it comes to getting the key cup alignment bang on.
 
@JayeNM Do you know this model's body band configuration?
YES, it is a 34 Allegro, SAME BODY SPECS AS A Yama 62...so a 62 band should work on this fine, the tube and bow dimensions of the two are the same, I believe.

34 was the same body as a 575....

Going here: Parts List Search System

Typing in 34 gets nothing, but 575 gets this result:
Screenshot 2025-04-17 093527.webp
 
So that is your part #, official Yama part #. From there, either:

1) find a tech who can order Yama parts (in US, Allied Tech Supply carries Yama parts and a tech can order from Allied, hopefully Allied has it)

2) Order directly from Yama. In US, Yama has a parts dept in LA, so I then go to a DIFFERENT website, www.yamaha24x7.com

sadly, plugging in that part # gets no result, 😳....so LA doesn't carry it. OR the part # has been superceded, just as likely,

So, all is not lost.

NEXT....

Starting back at the beginning, first website, if I put in a model 62 instead of a 575, I get this list:
Screenshot 2025-04-17 095658.webp


I next click on the series of the 62 which existed when the 575 and 34 Allegros existed (via their listed date ranges)....then view its diagram, which shows part 28, and going to list again I get this part #N0420034

62.webp


for a double check I click on another 62 that existed at the time of the 575, and I confirm the part # listed is the same as above....
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,060
Messages
578,329
Members
8,128
Latest member
Roger Atlas
Back
Top Bottom