Playing the saxophone Playing tenor like an alto and vice-versa

My teachers always said to be on the safe side but no harm in writing more outer stuff if you know the players, ie you can write altissimo for saxophones but only if you know the player, likewise C and above on trumpet (and ideally keep it much lower if there are long sessions involved). Even high note specialists won't thank you for overdoing the high E - G.
Actually, the reason why I posted the particular example was my impressions from last Monday's rehearsal in support of the discussion.

It may not be the best example, touching high D only. I just happened to have my folder conveniently available to me and a little time to do some scanning.

It not very often that the tenor is used in unison with the oboe, flutes and clarinets in the tenor's higher range and without the altos. Most of the time, I would be providing bottom, playing at least an octave lower, which is right there where the tenor sounds best. The altos would be playing along with the upper woodwinds, an octave higher than me.
 
If anything, it is closer to a tenor than an alto. Both in range and timbre. But it is not that simple, because the differences between the different brands/models are more pronounced than e.g. on tenor.
A C-soprano is in the range of a soprano. A Mezzo-soprano is a F-alto. A C-melody is in the range of a tenor so it's maybe more correct to call a C- Melody for C-Tenor? A C-bass saxophone is called C-bass saxophone. Maybe it's Martin fault that we called C- Tenors for C-Melody? Martin C tenor home model, keyed from low C to to C3 (no side keys, no bell keys, no plame keys) made the C-tenor popular? Easy to play the melody or singing lines, just read over shoulders of the piano player. I don't know ..... .
 
Actually, the reason why I posted the particular example was my impressions from last Monday's rehearsal in support of the discussion.

It may not be the best example, touching high D only. I just happened to have my folder conveniently available to me and a little time to do some scanning.

It not very often that the tenor is used in unison with the oboe, flutes and clarinets in the tenor's higher range and without the altos. Most of the time, I would be providing bottom, playing at least an octave lower, which is right there where the tenor sounds best. The altos would be playing along with the upper woodwinds, an octave higher than me.

It is interesting to hear from someone so passionate about playing tenor sax in community band. I couldn’t do it anymore. I’ve played those parts and it often feels like they are just doubling other parts, whether it is low brass, low reeds, or whatever. I get that it’s about building textures, etc. I am glad that you can enjoy it.

I prefer playing tenor sax in a quartet setting (classical or jazz), where there are so few possible lines that everything matters. Similarly in contemporary big bands, I like that each part has its purpose, few lines are doubled, and everyone matters to the extent that playing through a chart reveals when anyone is missing.

While I can appreciate that the low end of the tenor has a function in doubling low winds, I love to explore the entirety of its range.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,061
Messages
578,382
Members
8,129
Latest member
Bartman
Back
Top Bottom