Playing the saxophone Playing tenor like an alto and vice-versa

Posit an imaginary world where Adolphe Sax never created the Alto. You only have Tenor and Soprano. Has anything been lost given it all can be played on Tenor/Soprano?
This would have an effect on sound of traditional AATTB saxophone section.
 
Posit an imaginary world where Adolphe Sax never created the Alto. You only have Tenor and Soprano. Has anything been lost given it all can be played on Tenor/Soprano?
Hummm... Slightly dodge counterfactual.
Adolphe developed many kinds of instrument-o-sax most of which didn't make it out the door or faded away, later variations bloomed and faded...
... The popular core of what's left fits the 4 voice model, seems to me, lots of composers and arrangers think in - without, as Lostcircuit says, stressing the musicians. So, maybe, for your proposition to work the structure of western music would have to be different? Too much Historical materialism?
 
An alto is only good for harmony (like the lesser Jackson brothers)?
Usually, the 2nd alto player is the harmony for lead alto, but I have seen stage band music that has a solo for the 2nd alto. Or, whilst the 1st has a solo, the 2nd alto along with the tenors and maybe the bari have a countermelody, answer part, or background chorus where the 2nd is the lead.
 
Usually, the 2nd alto player is the harmony for lead alto, but I have seen stage band music that has a solo for the 2nd alto. Or, whilst the 1st has a solo, the 2nd alto along with the tenors and maybe the bari have a countermelody, answer part, or background chorus where the 2nd is the lead.
If you're talking about scholastic big band charts, the roles may be fairly narrowly defined, but professional big bands do all kinds of things, including switching parts. In one band I was in, I was on lead alto but my clarinet playing is weak, so for charts with a lot of clarinet stuff the 3rd alto player, a fine clarinetist, took the lead part. He was plenty capable of playing lead alto though he didn't prefer it. But his clarinetting was far superior to mine. You never know where the doubles will land, and different charts are written all sorts of different ways.

And of course this all presumes the typical five man big-band sax section. Go to three horns and put them in a salsa band or a funk band and the roles will be all different.
 
If you're talking about scholastic big band charts, ....
Thanks for your inputs.

I was speaking of the military bands I was with. Yes, sometimes it was like published Nestico stuff. Sometimes we broke into smaller bands, say 9 piece. And yes, where a player was weak, someone else would take his/her ride. Sometimes we played stuff written by one of members. But you are right, the rules are, there are no rules.

As far as professional? I dunno. I got a pay check every month, for whatever worth it was plus a small retirement out of it. :mrcool
 
The saxophone sound is (IMO and profs who taught me arranging and orchestration) best used for section work in the more consistent area of its range. Hence if you just had sopranos and tenors plus baritone, you may find in the harmony parts soprano having to play a lot of very low notes and tenor having to play a lot of high notes.

Both of these can be harder to get a good blend in certain scenarios. I have found this to be the case even when you have altos to a certain extent unless you are always careful about picking the right key for getting the best section sound and blend.
 
If anything, it is closer to a tenor than an alto. Both in range and timbre. But it is not that simple, because the differences between the different brands/models are more pronounced than e.g. on tenor. Some of that relates to the choice of MPC, for example my Holton plays fine with any "Meyer" alto clone/derivative and the neck tip is too small for tenor MPCs unless you double up on the neck cork. It has a distinct tone, which is different from that of e.g. Buescher/Martin/York, which are way more tenorish. And then you have the Conn in its various iterations, straight neck, curved neck, front F etc. depending on vintage.

The Conn straight neck is definitely the easiest to play (it uses a tenor neck diameter) in terms of the ergonomics, you don't develop instant shoulder and arm cramps like with the Martin (probably the worst in the bunch).

The tone/timbre is 90% a matter of the MPC very similar to tenor or alto. You put on a high baffle paint peeler and you get a loud, edgy tone etc. My own experience is that it really doesn't matter too much whether I am on tenor or c-mel when I am miked to play with that rock band I am in but some songs just line up better with the c-mel. So it is mostly the range and a bit of the timbre that make the difference but I can't get as loud on c-mel as on tenor (hint, I've been told that I am too loud more than once).

I don't know what else to tell you other than it is easier for me to double on tenor and c-mel than tenor and alto but it may be just the choice of the specific songs and my own "frequency of use" (80% tenor, 15% sop, 3% c-mel and ~2% alto, bari etc).

One thing I can definitely tell you is that it is easier to find a guitar player who can do Hallelujah in concert C than in Bb or Into the Mystic in F rather than Eb.

There are numerous good and even more bad c-mel recordings on YouTube, Mike Smith, Michael Ausserbauer, Dave Pollack etc. and my own stuff:

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xKQvMLujdKo


I let you be your own judge.

Oh and I did a little fun project where somebody asked me to do a sax track for a cover version of "We Used to Know" (Jethro Tull), where I played alternating c-sop and c-mel flamenco lines but they haven't done the mix yet.
 
The saxophone sound is (IMO and profs who taught me arranging and orchestration) best used for section work in the more consistent area of its range. Hence if you just had sopranos and tenors plus baritone, you may find in the harmony parts soprano having to play a lot of very low notes and tenor having to play a lot of high notes.
Yes, I understand what you mean.

Case in point, there is a pleasing sounding song our community band is playing for our May 15 Spring Concert. It is River of Life by Steven Reineke. It is not a technically difficult tune, graded as 2+. Those curious,
describes it, available for sale. Here it is being performed by a competent symphonic band:

On my tenor sax, it has me playing in soli with the flutes, clarinet and oboe. This is a bit unusual, as it has me playing in the upper range that is a natural for the alto sax. However, Reineke has the alto saxes playing a completely different line.

This is the part. I play up to high D in unison starting at Measure 19:

2025-04-26 River of Life pagína 1c.webp


Although I back off to balance with the upper woodwinds (rehearsal had roughly 5 or 6 clarinets, an oboe, bassoon and 3 flutes), IMO it just doesn't seem as pleasing to the ear as an alto would sound. However, that is how it is written, and just like in all music taskings, we musicians just do it.
 
Ok, how does the C melody fit into this discussion? Not in terms of transpose etc. But range, tone, or whatever?
In my experience, it doesn’t. Admittedly I have only played a few but it seems to me a compromise that doesn’t exhibit either the best aspects of a tenor of the best aspects of an alto. It could just be me or it could be the mouthpiece of course.
 
On my tenor sax, it has me playing in soli with the flutes, clarinet and oboe. This is a bit unusual, as it has me playing in the upper range that is a natural for the alto sax. However, Reineke has the alto saxes playing a completely different line.

This is the part. I play up to high D in unison starting at Measure 19:

View attachment 28713

Although I back off to balance with the upper woodwinds (rehearsal had roughly 5 or 6 clarinets, an oboe, bassoon and 3 flutes), IMO it just doesn't seem as pleasing to the ear as an alto would sound. However, that is how it is written, and just like in all music taskings, we musicians just do it.
That is certainly within the natural range of the tenor. It should sound as full as any other pitch. I find that the notes above the staff are among the strongest if one is trying to project.
 
I always found D to be on the edge of being too high for comfort within a written part. I’d find Eb, E and F certainly a bit tricky especially for unisons. This is also what I was taught.
 
I always found D to be on the edge of being too high for comfort within a written part. I’d find Eb, E and F certainly a bit tricky especially for unisons. This is also what I was taught.
It just dawned on me, River of Life by Steven Reineke described by the sales web link I provided, mentions it is used in academic circles for competition and grading. The ulterior motive may be to put certain instruments at their edges to see how well the band overall performs when stretched.

So, the way scored may have been purposely done with this in mind.
 
It just dawned on me, River of Life by Steven Reineke described by the sales web link I provided, mentions it is used in academic circles for competition and grading. The ulterior motive may be to put certain instruments at their edges to see how well the band overall performs when stretched.

So, the way scored may have been purposely done with this in mind.
Or it may have been scored such that the desired voices were well within their natural ranges and that the composition lends itself well to ensemble opportunities within the score with an emphasis on blend and dynamics.

We know neither what the judges are looking for on this piece nor what the composer intended. In the absence of facts, we have more degrees of freedom with which to wave our arms.

FWIW, in the context of literature for the saxophone, this tenor part is really laid out for easy playing.
 
So, the way scored may have been purposely done with this in mind.
Which is absolutely fine.

My teachers always said to be on the safe side but no harm in writing more outer stuff if you know the players, ie you can write altissimo for saxophones but only if you know the player, likewise C and above on trumpet (and ideally keep it much lower if there are long sessions involved). Even high note specialists won't thank you for overdoing the high E - G.
 
AFAIK, a few marches put the tenor into the D - F range, however it didn't seem to detract from the piece. Just depends on the piece, IMO. I guess it is a combination of perspective and preference.

Perhaps mind over matter? (If you don't mind, it don't matter?)

Laying all facetiousness aside, the piece is more of a tonal poem, IMO. Even though technically it is not difficult to play notewise, it is the balance between the sections and within each section, maintaining proper dynamics, attacks and decays as directed by the conductor, even adding contrast by exaggerating the dynamics under the conductor's control.

This is what makes it a beautiful piece of tonal artwork.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,061
Messages
578,382
Members
8,129
Latest member
Bartman
Back
Top Bottom