Playing the saxophone Playing tenor like an alto and vice-versa

The only thing we older musicians, run out of, is time on the green side.
Yes! :old: I recently turned 71 and although in good health without any underlying conditions (as far as I know.....) I realise that given the ageing process I'll probably have only 10 or so years of playing, which is about the same amount of time it'll take to get any good!

I'm really really enjoying it though and being in the here and now rather where I could be is pleasing. When I look back to December 2024 I've come a long way but I know it's just the start of a long journey.

I will attempt your @PiccoloPirate suggestions above. Thanks.
 
That exercise was what Joe Allard taught to my legit sax players/teachers, starting in the late '50s.
My flute playing/knowledge was from the legit players that studied with Arthur Lora.
Hope the exercise helps.
 
Thanks @CliveMA nice examples. I've thought of the alto as the equivalent of a lead guitar and the tenor as the bass in an ensemble/band.
Have you noticed which voice, alto v tenor, is the more common in rock or blues?

Regarding jazz bands: Yes, sections have a lead alto. Have you noticed which voice is the more common solo voice? Hint: In most big bands, they sit next to the rhythm section.

I'm an old beginner and the deep and sultry vibe is my preference. However, Desmond's Take Five is sublime too. It was the first jazz song I ever heard as a youngster and was immediately taken by the rhythm and time changes. I enjoy listening to alto players e.g. Parker, Desmond, Adderly, Stitts, Hodges, Konitz, et al. but the more I'm learning and practicing the more the tenor appeals to me.
Maybe you just prefer tenor. I do. It can do anything that you choose to imagine. If you cannot get a particular sound that’s in your head to come out of the tenor, that’s on you - not the instrument. If you want to swap horns to tickle your pleasure, that’s up to you, but if you choose, like many of us, to commit to one instrument, the tenor is quite up to the task.
 
If you want to swap horns to tickle your pleasure, that’s up to you, but if you choose, like many of us, to commit to one instrument, the tenor is quite up to the task.
The more I play the tenor the less I want to pick up the alto.
Yesterday I started on the alto and surprisingly managed ok after a few minutes adjusting my embouchure and mpc position.
BUT it didn't excite me like playing the tenor. I know that altos are less forgiving and can sound shrill and tinny in the wrong lips but I believe my tone is coming along, it is the pitch of the alto that I didn't like (with me, not with any of the greats above!).
After I'd done the scales and a couple of tunes I swapped to the tenor and immediately felt 'at home', even putting it on and holding it felt better!
Given my potential playing-time left, as mentioned above, I think I'd rather concentrate on one and get good(ish) rather than adequate on both.
 
My two great Tenors, appeared in a dream last night.
"Bel Air, they said, you should have said, like a '63 327 spit window Vette".
My bad.
So the Alto was like a late '63 F-4C, with a Penthouse button.
And the Sopranos, think SR-71.
Although the curved Borgani Sop, pitiful scale. Teacher let us play it, so we knew what not to buy. 😵‍💫

View attachment 28619
Tsk... Tsk ...
I like my curved Borg, sweet tone, good intonation but, arguably, extremely sensitive to regulation. So, I can make it "unplayable" in a matter of 5 minutes but I can let out the air of 2 of your Corvette tires in less time. And dance circles around it with the Bel Air.

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lSbpRBoEM2A
 
I have read here and there comments along the lines of 'alto and tenor are different beasts so should be played differently', 'you can't play tenor like an alto', Miles Davis allegedly telling John Coltrane not to play tenor like an alto.

What does this mean? Is it to do with phrasing or one is better suited to melody and the other harmony? Is it the pitch of the tune? Favouring the bottom end of the alto rather than the high end and altissimo?
IMO, it has to do with style and tone. Alto, it's okay to play it "brightly". The rule is basically, "there are no rules". It is a preference for a tenor airy, breathy, soft tenor sound, especially on jazz ballads especially in the lower register.

Yet, I've heard rock played on a tenor with a bright tone like an alto, and it sounded good. In non-jazz music more along classical lines, a brighter sound sometimes fits better. It is just a matter of perspective and preference.

One IMO doesn't need to achieve a true currently preferable "breathy" tenor sound with say some of Glenn Miller's songs and jazz of the era. It is more important to play it in tune and technically correct especially in the sax ensemble portions.

IMO, one can forgive the "tone", but not out of tune and bad notes, if you know what I mean.
 
Well, this is one of those comments that can mean pretty much whatever you decide you want it to mean.

In jazz, there certainly have been general styles of playing that are associated with alto and those with tenor. It could be that someone playing more "alto" style patterns could be admonished. It could be that a tenor player who constantly picks notes high on the horn is interfering with an alto player or a trumpet player who likes to play in the low register. It could be a tone quality comment. If Miles actually said this to Trane (which I doubt the accuracy of that attribution), it could have just been Miles taking the pI$$ as he often liked to do.

Look up the story on how Miles told Bill Evans he would need to be properly initiated into the band.
 
Treat them as separate instruments, don't make the mistake of thinking the tenor is a bigger alto or the alto is a smaller tenor, but playing one of them can help the other.
Go with the one that excites you the most, for me its alto but years ago I was a tenor player.
 
Treat them as separate instruments, don't make the mistake of thinking the tenor is a bigger alto or the alto is a smaller tenor, but playing one of them can help the other.
Go with the one that excites you the most, for me its alto but years ago I was a tenor player.
Definitely, as I have found already, different handling and tempo as it were to continue the car analogy.

I'm loathe to part with the YAS-25, my first love who got me started. It seems a shame for it to sit around unplayed, but I wanted a tenor in the first place for its sound, and now I've got one (YTS-25). I'm not aspiring to be a pro or a gigging player so not worried about missing opportunities by only playing a tenor.
 
I'm loathe to part with the YAS-25
Hold onto it.

Like you, I reach for the tenor most days.
Then one online chappie started to produce a series of pedagogically oriented duets with arrangements/recordings for AA/TT and AT (T part is transposed)... Now, once I've got as good as I can on TT, I have a go at AT because, why not. It's my time, I can do what I like.
And, bonus, doing so gives one a feel for your thread question.
You never know.
 
You see, we all think of Miles as this very stern guy who would bust you in the chops as soon as he'd look at you, but that's not the whole Miles. From what I can gather he was a very sensitive guy, who put on a harsh veneer, and who also had a dry sense of humor. Read his "autobiography" and a lot of that comes through even despite his attempts to come across as a bad MF.

So, anyway, the Bill-Evans-joins-Miles story, and you've got to think of the Bill Evans of the late 50s, crew cut, dorky glasses, earnest as all get-out.

The story runs, that Evans had played for Miles, had sat in with the band, Miles was pleased with what he heard. So he tells Bill, "Well, Bill, you're in the band, if you just pass the initiation. You see, before you can join this band - well, you've got to make it with all the guys in the band."
Bill says "You mean F?"
Miles: "Yeah, then you'll be in the band."
Bill thinks a little while and then says [and you've got to imagine this in his most earnest, crew-cut, dorky glasses voice]: "Well, you know Miles, I really want to play with the band, and I admire all the things you guys do, but I just don't think I can do that."

Whereupon Miles smiles, says "My Man!" puts his arm around him and laughs, and Bill's in the band.
 
I wonder how many of you can sing. If you do, it is easier to realize that you use the instrument you have. Neither woman nor man is told to sing a particular genre because of their range.

Ever play a piano? Mark the range of the keyboard with the range of an alto sax. Now do the same with markings to indicate the range of a tenor sax. Is your choice of song driven by the notes of either range? Notice also that the ranges are similar than different.
 
I have seen, but can't remember where, a video of a recognised alto player demonstrating Vandoren reeds on alto... He had started his career playing clarinet. His alto tone in the demo sounded so clarinet-like as to make no difference (quite alarming to this listener)

So

Perhaps, in turn, the alto and tenor voices can be made to play with little difference... but surely you'd have to have an unusually rigid internal voice to overcome their sonic differences
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,061
Messages
578,382
Members
8,129
Latest member
Bartman
Back
Top Bottom