Playing the saxophone Playing from memory

I can hear a known tune in my head (and sing it) but have to rely on reading music to play it. What I hear in my head doesn't sync with my fingers.

When I'm improvising my fingers seem to sync with my head. Simple stuff, a few notes from an appropriate scale, concentrating on timing, rhythm and melody. It seems to work and makes up for my novice tone.

What I can't fathom when improvising/jamming - am I playing what I'm hearing in my head or hearing what I'm playing as they seem almost coincidental?

And why I can't do this for tunes I know?
 
And why I can't do this for tunes I know?

Practice. It's a skill like any other. Improvising's a skill, playing written parts so they sound alive is a skill, playing written parts from memory so they sound alive is a skill. It takes hours and hours of practice to get to the point where you sound naturally talented. πŸ˜‰

I don't know about anyone else, but I have to put a huge amount of time and effort into playing a particular set of songs so that I can go in front of people and look like I'm not trying.

Today I was learning a sax solo from a Christmas song that I'll be playing at a few shows this December. It didn't take very long to work out what the original solo was (thankfully it's a poppy rock n' roll song rather than something by Coltrane :rofl: ), but I still then put the 45 second solo into a loop and spent the next 30-40 minutes playing this looped solo until it started to become second nature. I'll do the same thing tomorrow, too, until this solo stops being me playing someone else's solo and starts to become mine. Thankfully, in this case it's not exactly an iconic solo so once I knew how the original went I could start having a bit of fun with it without it becoming noticeably different to a casual listener.

Basically, you'll get there. Probably not tomorrow, but perhaps the next day. The trick is to keep going and have fun while you do it.
 
I memorize a tune first off by learning it by ear, then playing it over and over until I have the melody and rhythm firmly implanted in my mind, and the pattern internalized in muscle memory. I'm definitely not thinking about every note. But I do tend to remember the starting note, as well as the key of course. Earlier in the thread @Linky Lee mentioned the starting note. When I think of the starting note, I tend to think of it numerically. For example, the '5th' of the key. But bottom line, knowing the melody is essential.

I also find I remember a tune far better after playing it on the bandstand a few times. And of course, if I go too long without playing it, I might lose it to some extent. So, in that case I have to review it to get it back.
 
I like to β€œunderstand” the tune in the sense of what key is it in, what notes in the scale are being used, what notes out of the scale, etc. Also maybe the chord structure, but that’s less important than the melody itself. Until it comes time to solo on it, of course.

I find that trying to play it on both alto and tenor really improves my understanding of the song. Because now I know it in two different (saxophone) keys, I understand it better, and am not depending on fingering patterns.

I also find I remember a tune far better after playing it on the bandstand a few times. And of course, if I go too long without playing it, I might lose it to some extent. So, in that case I have to review it to get it back.
This is definitely true for me too. Something about playing it live, with others, makes it go deeper.
 
I memorize a tune first off by learning it by ear, then playing it over and over until I have the melody and rhythm firmly implanted in my mind, and the pattern internalized in muscle memory. I'm definitely not thinking about every note. But I do tend to remember the starting note, as well as the key of course. Earlier in the thread @Linky Lee mentioned the starting note. When I think of the starting note, I tend to think of it numerically. For example, the '5th' of the key. But bottom line, knowing the melody is essential.

I also find I remember a tune far better after playing it on the bandstand a few times. And of course, if I go too long without playing it, I might lose it to some extent. So, in that case I have to review it to get it back.
I don't think of a starting note as the xth of key Y. For me it is more the "shape", i.e. the fingering of the particular note than anything. From the starting note, everything else is just intervals.

Exception, I really work on a specific solo for a given song in a specific key. But aside from that, I don't care what key it is in as long as it's not F# - I'm kind of tone deaf in that key - but other than that, play the tune in C, D, E, G, F, it really doesn't matter to me, I just play it.
 
Everybody's brain functions a bit different. Music is like language for the right hemisphere.

To me, memorizing written music is kind of backwards because the written stuff isn't actually music. It's just notation--symbols that represent sound. Written music is just a way for one musician to communicate a musical thought to another musician when sound isn't an available medium and the communication of it suffers a bit as a result. Just like what I'm doing right now with words. What you're looking at right now isn't English. You're looking at symbols that represent the language. So, language is what's spoken (or, at least, understood in your brain from the symbols). Written forms always follow spoken forms, not the other way around. Everyone knows how to speak before they can to read.

Likewise, music is sound. Memorizing music off a page is like trying to learn a language by reading it from a book. I know that's what people do, but it's backwards. You learn a language by speaking it and learn music by hearing it.

When I have a song memorized I don't think about what fingering or note name comes next. I think of where the music is going and the fingers just do it.
 
Everybody's brain functions a bit different. Music is like language for the right hemisphere.

To me, memorizing written music is kind of backwards because the written stuff isn't actually music. It's just notation--symbols that represent sound. Written music is just a way for one musician to communicate a musical thought to another musician when sound isn't an available medium and the communication of it suffers a bit as a result. Just like what I'm doing right now with words. What you're looking at right now isn't English. You're looking at symbols that represent the language. So, language is what's spoken (or, at least, understood in your brain from the symbols). Written forms always follow spoken forms, not the other way around. Everyone knows how to speak before they can to read.

Likewise, music is sound. Memorizing music off a page is like trying to learn a language by reading it from a book. I know that's what people do, but it's backwards. You learn a language by speaking it and learn music by hearing it.

When I have a song memorized I don't think about what fingering or note name comes next. I think of where the music is going and the fingers just do it.

Much better said than my bit. Yet I was aiming at trying to make it a little more relevant to the beginners who started this off. Lots of good comments since that are mostly going in the same direction. You've got to hear the music.

Altogether this unfortunately points out where a lot of music teaching (IMHO) doesn't encourage listening as much as playing by via visual means. It's an academic means of getting a learner started, yet doesn't seem to stray very far from keeping it all visual. Balance with auditory learning is needed but doesn't fit comfortably withing academic teaching. It's not just listening to records/others. It's listening to yourself and at least attempting to play something that you can hear that you want to play. There are no shortcuts and continuing to rely on visuals for an auditory medium is a very long way around to being able to play as you would sing.
 
For many, when they look at written music, be it for piano, saxophone, a string quartet or an orchestra, that notation becomes music in their mind, although It is not audible to others.

Ever go to lower the volume, or turn the radio off, in your vehicle, and find that the radio was not on? πŸ˜΅β€πŸ’«

Strange, that you can fit so many musicians in your head, with instruments, chairs and stands.
A Marshall head, with two cabs and a Tele, takes up just a little more space, than a Bari. πŸŽΆπŸ΄β€β˜ οΈπŸŽΆ

The musical mind, a gift from Mother Nature.
 
When I think of the starting note, I tend to think of it numerically. For example, the '5th' of the key.
This illustrates what I always say, a little music theory is a great aid to memorising a melody and knowing any notes relationship to the key (center) is crucial to that process. For example knowing in your head the next note is a step down is one thing, but without knowing the key you still have to guess whether it’s half or whole.
 
And why I can't do this for tunes I know?
I think what's going on under the bonnet is a lot more complicated than folk neurophysiology would have it. There are many pathways, from Memories at various depths to "consciousness" or motor control or whatever.
All those pathways have to be built and are built through repeated practice - like discussed Post in thread 'Got a new tenor mouthpiece' ...
... So, yeah, practice. Repetition. Playing by ear,.from the page, from memory, whatever
 
To me, memorizing written music is kind of backwards because the written stuff isn't actually music. It's just notation--symbols that represent sound. Written music is just a way for one musician to communicate a musical thought to another musician when sound isn't an available medium and the communication of it suffers a bit as a result.
+1. A lot of good points in your post, Tuppertn. What is often missed when simply reading music off the page are all the inflections, articulation, and other audio effects that aren't, or can't be, notated. This is especially true of jazz/blues music, where the exact rhythmic feel, 'special effects', & tonal characteristics cannot be notated effectively. You have to hear them and absorb them in your playing. Take the concept of 'swing' for example. It's just not there in the notation. You have to hear it and feel it to play it. This may go a bit beyond the basic memorization of a tune, but it's extremely important. Of course, to some extent the 'interpretation' of a melody is up to the individual player.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,059
Messages
578,315
Members
8,127
Latest member
PJ2116
Back
Top Bottom