Miscellaneous Play Sax With Lol Coxhill

There was a playwright/ poet who was very popular at the time, a hundred years ago or something in Scotland, and the paper full of enthusiasm for this poet, printed. WHARS YER WULLIE SHAKESPEARE NOO. I forget who the poet was, but we all know who Shakespeare is. I think a lot of modern music is a bit like that. Much Ado About Nothing.😉
 
Pretentious - "attempting to impress by affecting greater importance or merit than is actually possessed." - I think this definition applies mostly to what's written about music and the way it's presented by the media, rather than the intent of the musicians themselves. Plus it's entirely subjective as to whether something is affecting greater importance or merit than is actually possessed, there's no objective means of measuring these qualities.
Most musicians don't seem to be bothered about issues of importance or merit, they just get on with whatever they do because that's what they like doing, which will probably involve being guilty of that other cardinal sin, self indulgence - an accusation that can also be levelled at anyone who's ever stood on a stage or performed in public.
In the late 60's and 70's it was perhaps the way that things were presented and written about that put people off - music journalists comparing The Beatles to Schumann and earnest BBC arts programmes telling us what was important - and this lead to the punk era backlash and another set of journalists telling people what was good or bad and writing about 'street credibility' etc, omitting the details about some of their heroes hippy backgrounds and arty leanings - Johnny Rotten being a fan of Hawkwind and Peter Hammill, Keith Levine of PIL being into Yes or Kurt Cobain's love of King Crimson. Sudenly you had to hide your old rock albums and flared trousers and pretend you'd been into the Velvet Underground and Iggy Pop for years.
Nowadays the influence of music journalism on people's tastes seems to be waning, Youtube, Last FM and Spotify etc give people access to a wider variety of music and they can pick what they want without being told what to listen to by a bunch of hacks at the NME. I've met club DJ's and indie musicians who listen to a wider range of music than is imaginable, genres and labels are no longer important
 
So is a lot of old music.

I imagine there were a lot of people around at the time who were convinced that Shakespeare was crap and everyone would have forgotten him in 10 years.

Yeah but you tend not to hear it. A lot of modern music will be forgotten for the same reason. Like yesterday's papers, just used to wrap up the fish and chips.
But I like Philip Glass , and a bit of Steve Reich, not so much John Cage.
 
There was a playwright/ poet who was very popular at the time, a hundred years ago or something in Scotland, and the paper full of enthusiasm for this poet, printed. WHARS YER WULLIE SHAKESPEARE NOO. I forget who the poet was, but we all know who Shakespeare is. I think a lot of modern music is a bit like that. Much Ado About Nothing.😉
John Home - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Douglas_(play)
 
It's interesting, taking about the longevity of music. Salieri was celebrated in his life, poss more than Mozart, but now forgotten.
it's quite possible that Salieri's better known now than he was then. In the 18th century the only way to hear classical music was to attend concerts. How many opera goers were there at that time? And how many people have seen 'Amadeus' or heard Salieri's music on the radio or internet or bought cd's of his work or studied his scores? His music's more widely available in more countries now than it ever was in his lifetime.
The same goes for a lot of other obscure or forgotten music, some artists have had their careers revived due to reissues of their work and internet popularity, not to mention early music consorts and musicologists studying the work of long dead composers and people making reproductions of early musical instruments. There's not a single aspect of music that someone somewhere isn't fanatical about.
 
it's quite possible that Salieri's better known now than he was then. In the 18th century the only way to hear classical music was to attend concerts. How many opera goers were there at that time? And how many people have seen 'Amadeus' or heard Salieri's music on the radio or internet or bought cd's of his work or studied his scores? His music's more widely available in more countries now than it ever was in his lifetime.
The same goes for a lot of other obscure or forgotten music, some artists have had their careers revived due to reissues of their work and internet popularity, not to mention early music consorts and musicologists studying the work of long dead composers and people making reproductions of early musical instruments. There's not a single aspect of music that someone somewhere isn't fanatical about.

Salieri was the Court composer in Vienna, the centre of the musical world at that time. His position was Probably more prestigious and financially rewarding than the leader of the Berlin Phil, or any musical appointment today. The musical buying public of today don't go to see Salieris Operas or buy CD,s of his music in anything like the volume of Sales major composers like Mozart create. Ask the record co. Mozart was a highly thought of composer in his day, but as far as prestige, he was a mere freelancer. From the play and film Amadeus , Salieri is the central character, and through this character we see the genius that is Mozart.
That's how Salieri is remembered, not for his music.
 
So he's not forgotten after all? I wasn't comparing sales of Salieri cd's vs Mozarts, just pointing out that access to his and Mozart's music is probably far greater now than it may have been in their lifetimes. Yesterday's newspapers are now historical artefacts, preserved and studied for their cultural worth.
Popularity is no measure of anything other than popularity. If Mozart is considered to be a major composer due to his popularity, then the composers of 'White Christmas' and 'Rock Around The Clock' must also be considered to be major composers. Or perhaps some other criteria may be a better measure of cultural value?
It's impossible to say why Salieri's music fell out of favour by the 1860's and Mozart's didn't - the attitudes of the world of classical music are a mystery to me - perhaps it was his influence on Beethoven that ensured his longevity, in the same way that a number of obscure blues musicians came to the public's attention due to their influence on the Rolling Stones.
A lot of things that were once forgotten are now being sought after, who'd've though that an obscure folk singer like Vashti Bunyan would be rediscovered and have her music used on a TV advert or a nearly forgotten heavy metal band like Anvil would have a movie made about them?
My point being that it's impossible to say whether a lot of modern music will be forgotten like Salieri. At least there's more permanent recordings of modern music, a lot of which stands a good chance of survival due to the enthusiasm of collectors and archivists. Ours is the most documented era in history, so even if only 10% of it survives, it'll still be a heck of a lot more than previous centuries..
archaeologists like trash and ephemera, it tells them more about the lives of ordinary people than the written documents of the ruling classes.
Mozart and Salieri earned their living by pandering to the tastes of the wealthy elite, Rhianna, Lady Gaga and Beyoncé make their living pandering to the tastes of ordinary people - is there really much difference?
 
I agree there are many composers from the past who are largely ignored. It was interesting, to say the least, to be introduced to German classical radio. After the constant stream of pop classics pushed out by classic fm, I had a major shock. And I started thinking about the difference.

It really comes down to accessibility. Just as much modern music outside of mainstream only appeals to a limited audience, so is classical. Mozart wrote many pieces which are, on the surface, trivial and easy to listen to. They're catchy - but like all good music there's a hidden depth. Some listen superficially, others dig deeper. Formulaic approaches to music - be they modal jazz, 20th century Schoenberg or Coltrane's weird scale don't appeal to all.

Much of the older classical music doesn't appeal - unless you approach it from what's accessible today, but was contemporary then.

Mozart's appeal now is precisely what he was criticised for in his time - the easy, trivial exterior. But there's a depth in many of his works which is often missed.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,068
Messages
578,497
Members
8,131
Latest member
Jef B
Back
Top Bottom