Almost any rendition would improve “God save Charlie". The Pistols had the right idea.
I just found this X link posted on the opening page of SOTW. I only have limited outside read only mode without an account, but SOTW allowed me to open the thread (read only) discussing this X video:
The general criticism expressed was the sax presentation along with the string bass was not done is a respectful "professional" manner one would normally achord to one nation's song.
Personally I see nothing wrong with making it swing a little, with bends, scoops, vibrato on and off, arpegios here and there, etc., as long as the essence of the melody comes through and the people enjoy listening to it.
My criticism is less toward the saxist and more to the bassist, his beat was a little too liberato, a little too "free". Nothing wrong with him jazzing it up a little, but seemed not even jazz coherent, a bit more abstract "beatnik" like. Both could have done better, plus I think it would have helped out these artists' popularity, something that is essential in the music world.
What do you think?
You seem to be on both sides of this. Which is it: “Personally I see nothing wrong with it” or is due “a sense of reverence”?I think it more of, having lived this side of pond and knowing more of the cultural expectations, from that perspective it could have been done better.
The song being the National Anthem holds a greater importance especially in light of national history and heritage to be a song that has a sense of reverence about it.
In the past some time back, I remember seeing televised a top notch high school choir group gave such a presentation, and it was greatly appreciated by the crowd.
Would this be type of performance be acceptable for say, the playing of "God Save The King" at a major sports event?
Who's this Charlie you speak of..Almost any rendition would improve “God save Charlie". The Pistols had the right idea.
A ‘proper’ one.Who's this Charlie you speak of..
Who's this Charlie you speak of..
Which raises an interesting doing lyric question. "Queen" and "regime" rhymed but had it been a king, "king" would have had to rhyme with something else...Almost any rendition would improve “God save Charlie". The Pistols had the right idea.
Best not to get into that part of the discussion then. Nor discussion about the merits of the UK monarchy, I know it's not strictly political but could be viewed as suchAt the risk of descending into politics, I suspect most of the negative reactions have racism at their root.
It’s getting more difficult by the day. Thanks for the reminder.If someone is truly performing the SSB, as best as they can, and it's not to your liking, try to remember, it's the Land of the Free, and the Home of the Brave. 🎶🏴☠️🎶
I know you were not referring to my comment, which was about how other nations view one playing their National Anthem as a comparison for acceptability in play, since we are an international community here.Nor discussion about the merits of the UK monarchy,
Clearly no. If a jazz artist is hired to play a venue where people dislike jazz, that is hardly going to affect future gigs at appropriate venues.I would think for an artist that to play a rendition that may be questionable in the eyes of some may possibly compromise a future hiring for a job, no?
I think the difference is that the (defacto) GB national anthem (GSTK/Q) is mostly used in ceremonial situations (and played by a forces band) and international sports appearance - but is quite rare otherwise. The occasional dunken crowd, maybe and it used to be played by the BBC to let people know it's time to switch off the telly and go to bed... Not to mention that Wales and Scotland have their own song and other songs - eg land of hope and glory, Jerusalem, rule Britannia - might also put in a show. And lots of football clubs have their own songs.People are people, and at least I would think one would expect for example, "God Save The King" to be played in a respectful, tasteful manner
