@turf3 (quoting isn't working for some reason)
I didn't measure from the tip, but the bass piece was pushed in past the end of the cork so it wasn't showing at all. The bari piece was about in the middle. So I suspect you're correct that my modern horn was indeed designed for the smaller chamber.
I didn't do much testing of the upper range on the bass piece unfortunately. But I can say the bari piece is easy to play in the palm keys and altissimo. In fact, I can go from altissimo G another full octave to the next higher G, far higher than my altissimo range on alto and tenor (D is my practical max on those).
Regarding square vs round, a square can be narrower and shorter than a circle of equivalent area. So it's really squeezing a larger chamber into a smaller footprint by using a square. If electro-magnetic waves in cylindrical versus rectangular waveguides behave similarly to soundwaves, the square has a lower cutoff frequency and greater bandwidth. So maybe that translates to less high frequency attenuation, hence more brightness in theory? Maybe I'm darkening it subconsciously to get my ideal sound.
TLDR, bari piece is easy to play and sounds great.
I didn't measure from the tip, but the bass piece was pushed in past the end of the cork so it wasn't showing at all. The bari piece was about in the middle. So I suspect you're correct that my modern horn was indeed designed for the smaller chamber.
I didn't do much testing of the upper range on the bass piece unfortunately. But I can say the bari piece is easy to play in the palm keys and altissimo. In fact, I can go from altissimo G another full octave to the next higher G, far higher than my altissimo range on alto and tenor (D is my practical max on those).
Regarding square vs round, a square can be narrower and shorter than a circle of equivalent area. So it's really squeezing a larger chamber into a smaller footprint by using a square. If electro-magnetic waves in cylindrical versus rectangular waveguides behave similarly to soundwaves, the square has a lower cutoff frequency and greater bandwidth. So maybe that translates to less high frequency attenuation, hence more brightness in theory? Maybe I'm darkening it subconsciously to get my ideal sound.
TLDR, bari piece is easy to play and sounds great.
