Mouthpieces mouthpiece question - 5c vs factory

Keep the Yamaha 5 C mouthpiece. The stock mouthpiece may look the same but it is not.
I play Yamaha 5 C mouthpiece on alto and tenor sax.
All the reeds and ligatures fit well on the 5C .
What strength reeds do you play? Synthetic or cane reeds?
As a comeback player I like the easy of the 5C and synthetic reeds.
Reeds I play on my alto sax are the Legere 1.5 Studio cut, 1.5 American cut, 1.75 (2 of them) American Cut,
Although I no longer own a Tenor kept the 5C and 1.5 American and 2.0 Studio cut .
Yes I do use the Tenor sax mouthpiece and reeds on my alto.
 
one, or it'd cost way more than $50 to pay a mouthpiece expert to do the measurements.
I agree but also think it’s unnecessary, the proof is in the playing
Now if for some reason an experienced professional saxophonist found himself in possession of a mystery no-name mouthpiece and some mystery no-name reeds, he might well find that they work just fine.
True, I think I mentioned that would be best. It’s more realistic to think a teacher would do this as opposed to finding that rare being, professional saxophonist,
I would certaintly be comfortable to play most any professional gig on a Yamaha 5C mouthpiece with Rico #2 reeds
Me too, but also on any mouthpiece if I like it, whether a 2k grail Guardala or a noname or a Sharkbite.
 
I've used a yam 5c on SATB with no problems. Not my favourite but quite useable.

The baritone 5C got me out of a hole when I dropped my Selmer piece.

Checked them all on a flat surface and found no flaws.

Tough plastic too. I dropped the alto on a hard floor with no damage.
 
First, buy some more reeds. I suggest Rico 2 1/2 strength for adult beginners. Strength 2 is OK, but you will very soon (like in a few weeks) be ready for the 2 1/2. Get 5 or 10, try them all, play the one that works best.

Second - as has been said, the Yamaha 5C is a known quantity and I believe it would be foolish to send it back.
 
I don't understand why you're so set on OP trying to use his mystery no-name stuff instead of just getting some good cheap stuff that he knows won't cause problems.
That may be because I didn’t make my thoughts clear enough.
 
First, buy some more reeds. I suggest Rico 2 1/2 strength for adult beginners. Strength 2 is OK, but you will very soon (like in a few weeks) be ready for the 2 1/2. Get 5 or 10, try them all, play the one that works best.

Second - as has been said, the Yamaha 5C is a known quantity and I believe it would be foolish to send it back.
If the OP is still undecided, essentially I think that @skeller047 has summed up all the advice here.

No name in-the-box mouthpieces have a track record of being awful to ok, but Yamaha mouthpieces have a good, proven track record. You should be confident that the Yamaha will offer no-hassle playing. But get a few trustworthy reeds too.
 
I readily admit I am also biased AGAINST no-name mystery reeds, and biased FOR reeds made by a company that actually puts their name on the thing. Again, I vote for the #2 or #2.5 Rico reed for the beginner.
Starting about 10 years ago, it has now been at least 4 or 5 years since I last bought "no name" reeds from the China. These were offered for under $10 for 10 reeds. Interestingly, I found that some brands actually were decent, some were overall a waste of money.

Even the "good brands" I had success on came and went on E-Bay (no longer available).

2014-11-14 Riyin & Happy Reeds.webp

Example of two brands from China I purchased 9 years ago. Happy brand is no longer available on US E-Bay, but the Riyin still are, $5.10 + $4.08 delivery per box of 10 alto sax reeds. The Lade brand seems OK. YMMV - your mileage may vary, everyone's expectations are different. With these type reeds, IMO just order one box. If it meets your expectation then order more.

My motivation was during the time my "company" pensions were my only income (we were at the "so-called US gov defined" poverty level) but we safely made ends meet as we owed no banks - all paid off) plus we don't have expensive habits (like tobacco and alcohol). Then became eligible to draw the government pension (Social Security - I paid dearly into it for many years) 5 years ago, so now I can afford brand name reeds.
 
Riyin - terrible brand name for something you put in your mouth, I can't help thinking of Ricin
Given that they originate from China, I seriously doubt they would use "black ops" to target saxophone and clarinet players. :confused: :w00t:

An interesting article, Use of Ricin: Is This Amateur Hour? - bellingcat . Derived from the beans of the Castor plant, it is poisonous, however, appears that one must inhale or ingest a sufficient amount for it to do its job. Since the scare sometime back, both US and UK postal centres now have ricin detection equipment.

I don't know about the beans, but components of the Castor plant are used in making Castor oil, a product basis for 2 cycle motorcycle racing oil, model hobby motors, and pharmaceutical use such as relief of constipation.

The name "Riyin" may have more significance in the Chinese language. They seem to prefer names inferring happiness or good luck. I recently ordered "Keurig" cup boxed bulk coffee capsules from Amazon. Being the least expensive, it was an off-brand name of "Happy Belly". They keep my "belly" happy. :banana:

Here is a partial review of the Riyin brand:


So far from my personal use and what others say, seem to be a decent budget brand. :sax:
 
Remember - you are not running to the finish line. You - most of us - are evolving step by step; learning, developing knowledge and skills and physical control etc.
Got yourself some 1.5ers? Spend some time with them. Hours of practice. Get used to them. Play tunes. Do exercises. Master them. Then try the 2z etc.

I rather suspect that @ghostler and others could get on with about any reed due to skill and experience but has a preference established over time.
 
2025-02-15 Alto Selmer S90-190 vs Mendini2.webp


Without doing any measurements (e.g., like simply taking a set mechanic's feeler gauges to measure tip gap,) by "eye balling", seems my recently purchased Cecelio Mendini alto's mouthpiece matches my Selmer S90-190 mouthpiece. I have yet to do a play comparison, which would reveal if there were any differences.
 
The finish line exists for us with OCD - Obstenant Coffin Dodgers. :old:
Ah, the Great finish line. Maybe my epitaph should be something like “he Petered out..”

Or for those State side that might not be familiar with Spike Milligan - “I told them I was ill”
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,062
Messages
578,402
Members
8,129
Latest member
Bartman
Back
Top Bottom