Tech/maintenance Measuring octave pad stickiness.

After cleaning the pad every day for more than a week the stickiness of the invert sugar is still present and I couldn't start with the beer test.

It is safe to say that invert sugar is really sticky and should be avoided when playing the saxophone. Most beverages with sugar and acid contain invert sugar. Also avod honey. Just for he sake of it I keep cleaning it every day with a moist cloth.

Gob will not help here as the enzymes in it don't affect the components of invert sugar.
 
5 pages. What have we learned that has some application?

Don't drink sticky sweet drinks while playing (or ever except for hangovers, IMHO).

As for sticking "power"? What? Should we be pressing the octave key harder? Lighter? Can we contrast different makes of pads? Or should pad manufactures be quoting "X cards sticking power" on their data sheets?
 
5 pages. What have we learned that has some application?

Don't drink sticky sweet drinks while playing (or ever except for hangovers, IMHO).

As for sticking "power"? What? Should we be pressing the octave key harder? Lighter? Can we contrast different makes of pads? Or should pad manufactures be quoting "X cards sticking power" on their data sheets?
I haven’t seen any correlation between drinking and sticky pads. Is there a mechanism that makes that connection? You would have to blow the drink into the horn, and even then I doubt that it would make much difference to an octave key atop the neck.

What condiments do you prefer in a nothing sandwich?
 
I haven’t seen any correlation between drinking and sticky pads.
A couple of post above
It is safe to say that invert sugar is really sticky and should be avoided when playing the saxophone. Most beverages with sugar and acid contain invert sugar. Also avod honey. Just for he sake of it I keep cleaning it every day with a moist cloth.
I'm only following the experimental result reports...
 
A couple of post above

I'm only following the experimental result reports...
Woodpad is applying goo directly to the pads as far as I have seen. True? How would it get there in similar concentration under real playing conditions? Has anybody reported a sticky octave pad that they can correlate to drinking beer between sets?
 
Woodpad is applying goo directly to the pads as far as I have seen. True? How would it get there in similar concentration under real playing conditions? Has anybody reported a sticky octave pad that they can correlate to drinking beer between sets?
Again, I was following woodpads conclusions. If you have an issue with them, way not ask him? Maybe he'll be interested in your opinion?
 
Woodpad is applying goo directly to the pads as far as I have seen. True? How would it get there in similar concentration under real playing conditions? Has anybody reported a sticky octave pad that they can correlate to drinking beer between sets?
Not quite...but I can relate the tale of a West Indian flautist who brought a flute in that was absolutely covered in brown sticky goo. Turns out there's a popular beverage which appears to be made by mixing Guinness and condensed milk together - and this bloke liked to knock it back inbetween playing the flute. Never seen anything like it before or since. Couldn't save any of the pads.
 
How about WD40?
Proper engineering


1000000342.webp
 
I am also surprised by all the ruckus for these simple measurements. Originally I wanted to have an idea how bad it is was for a saxophone player to drink during gigs.
This is a different question than sticky pads. From the saxophonist’s perspective, drinking on the gig improves it. From the band leader’s perspective, it is the opposite. From the audience’s perspective - really depends on how well they are listening, so in reality, no effect.
 
Today I couldn't find a trace of sugar after cleaning The pad is still sticky. The leather smell has become stronger. There is no smell of decay. Somehow the leather became sticky after treatment with small amounts of water and sugar. Seems like the end of the experiments with this pad.
 
Not quite...but I can relate the tale of a West Indian flautist who brought a flute in that was absolutely covered in brown sticky goo. Turns out there's a popular beverage which appears to be made by mixing Guinness and condensed milk together - and this bloke liked to knock it back inbetween playing the flute. Never seen anything like it before or since. Couldn't save any of the pads.
That must be Jamaican Guinness punch.. It is really very bad for pads. Especially the emulsifiers necessary to keep the condensed milk from shifting.

Thanks for the demonstration that traces of everything you drink during playing can be found on the pads afterwards.
 
Last edited:
That must be Jamaican Guinness punch.. It is really very bad for pads. Especially the emulsifiers necessary to keep the condensed milk from shifting.

Thanks for the demonstration that traces of everything you drink during playing can be found on the pads afterwards.
It would be handy to assume so, but given that quite a lot of the goo was present on the keywork I rather suspect that a certain amount of spillage was involved.
However, if you're after some empirical data I routinely take to the stage with a bottle of beer beside me - and have never suffered from sticky pads. But then I'm not one of those players who, at the end of a gig, tips their horn up and empties a load of moisture out of the bell. And neither has my bare brass horn gone green. I'm just not a 'wet' player - though quite a few of my clients are.

It's perhaps all about the variables...
 
A half year after the test with invert sugar the pad is still sticky.

This stickiness is not caused by residual sugar, as it is cleaned repeatedly, but by a permanent change in the pad leather.

It is probably a reaction between reducing sugars and the collagen in the leather which forms advanced glycation end products. In humans this reaction ages the skin faster.

Maybe it is better to avoid food and drinks with reducing sugars or a combination of sugars and acid regulators when playing the saxophone. This includes honey, fruit drinks, cola, peanut butter jelly sandwiches and a lot of sweets

I remove the pad and put in a new one to test if beer is really safe.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,070
Messages
578,528
Members
8,132
Latest member
LouisJR
Back
Top Bottom