Tech/maintenance Measuring octave pad stickiness.

My mistake. I now realize that relevance and reasoning are not appropriate to this thread.

FWIW, I, too, am a former reviewer for Elsevier (and author), but my area of expertise is outside the scope of smearing goo on things to see if they stick.
Mistakes can't be helped if it is out of your field. But you are promising in smearing without reasoning.
 
I agree, it takes twice the time to fill out the paperwork than doing the experiment. I used a 62mm pad instead of a 8 mm. concerned on getting stuck in a nostril.
Yes we did have chimpanzees at the LA zoo. They have been given a promotion. If you wish to speak to one of them call City Hall.
That will give a lot of new CGP (chimp generated paperwork).
 
test 20: 100g sugar in 1l water 24h waiting time gives a sticking power of 35g 70% of the baseline, that's certainly annoying when playing.
test 21:residual stickiness after test 20 is 15g.
Cleaning: a small ring of crystalized sugar was formed on the pad. It took long to clean and it gave minor, but lasting damage to the pad.
test 22: baseline is 50g.
test 23: 100g inverted sugar in 1l water gives a sticking power of 15g after 10m waiting.
test 24: 100g inverted sugar in 1l water 24h waiting time is pending.

The word inverted means that it contains lots of fructose that will reduce crystallization.

After invert sugar it is time to test beer.
 
test 20: 100g sugar in 1l water 24h waiting time gives a sticking power of 35g 70% of the baseline, that's certainly annoying when playing.
test 21:residual stickiness after test 20 is 15g.
Cleaning: a small ring of crystalized sugar was formed on the pad. It took long to clean and it gave minor, but lasting damage to the pad.
test 22: baseline is 50g.
test 23: 100g inverted sugar in 1l water gives a sticking power of 15g after 10m waiting.
test 24: 100g inverted sugar in 1l water 24h waiting time is pending.

The word inverted means that it contains lots of fructose that will reduce crystallization.

After invert sugar it is time to test beer.
test 39: inadvertently made ginger beer
 
test 24: 100g inverted sugar in 1l water 24h waiting time 35g sticking force.
test 25: residual stickiness after test 24 20g.
Cleaning is pending as the invert sugar requires even more cleaning than the sugar solutions.
The beer test has to wait for the weekend.
 
After reading to the end of this, I am completely gobsmacked...

...and yet, strangely interested in the data synopsis that drips out of it at the end.

t
can only add dog drool to the data pool.
I am also surprised by all the ruckus for these simple measurements. Originally I wanted to have an idea how bad it is was for a saxophone player to drink during gigs. I couldn't find any relevant studies, so I planned some quick and dirty research on sticky materials and leather pads. The alternative was to write a research proposal, wait a few year for a grant and work two years on measurements and reporting, which is a bit mew......

From the first results it looks that you have to drink water during gigs and have to dry your instrument after playing.
It is still possible that new measurements show that some components combined will act as a super glue, but that would surprise me.
Even when you drink only water and clean properly there is some stickiness left which is comparable of playing on an instrument that isn't oiled for one months, which is not so bad.

This weekend it was too warm to do measurements. I will finish them in my own time.

Now about your proposal to ad dog drool.
In a study on the differences between dog drool and human spit 2532 differences where found. Therefore it is unlikely that testing this substance will help saxophone players. But it might get me a nomination for an IG Nobel prize.
 
Surely the pad would be compromised after the first substance application thereby rendering any further tests upon it void?

It is impossible to prevent some of each substance entering the pad's skin.

My synthetic pads are waterproof and airtight. They could all be removed, washed, and replaced in 15-20 minutes. But saliva borne stickiness may still affect them in play, until this is done.
 
Surely the pad would be compromised after the first substance application thereby rendering any further tests upon it void?

It is impossible to prevent some of each substance entering the pad's skin.

My synthetic pads are waterproof and airtight. They could all be removed, washed, and replaced in 15-20 minutes. But saliva borne stickiness may still affect them in play, until this is done.
Some centuries ago a student of Heraclites mentioned that it is impossible to do one thing twice in the same way. Having that in mind I made a test set-up which measures added stickiness after the pad confirms to a baseline test. As long as the pad has this baseline stickiness the tests are valid.

There is more than 4 centuries experience with leather around felt in pads. By replacing the inherent sticky ones and cleaning after playing, people are so accustomed to the residual stickiness that it is hardly noticed or measured. This gives your invention a USP in cleaning.

ODW list:

USP: unique selling point
ODW: onbekend drieletter woord
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,070
Messages
578,524
Members
8,132
Latest member
LouisJR
Back
Top Bottom