Tech/maintenance Measuring octave pad stickiness.

How are you measuring the mucus to pad area ratio? How do you achieve a uniform coverage? The mucus would need to be spread to exactly the same thickness across the pad. This also applies to all other contaminants, and in equal measure by weight, volume, whatever. I believe your parameters are flawed in this respect. It is an impossible and pointless experiment. Do correct me if I am clueless!
 
Pork snot is less sticky. Also The surface tension of this issue being tested will vary depending on the skin used. I’ve no experience with pork snot on kangaroo rump.
I do have some experience in testing leather. Mostly abrasion tests with asphalt. Mass and velocity greatly affect its long-term usefulness. Treatment and Coatings have zero benefit in this regard.
 
Last edited:
How are you measuring the mucus to pad area ratio? How do you achieve a uniform coverage? The mucus would need to be spread to exactly the same thickness across the pad. This also applies to all other contaminants, and in equal measure by weight, volume, whatever. I believe your parameters are flawed in this respect. It is an impossible and pointless experiment. Do correct me if I am clueless!
Well,.. I used 0.3 gr of spit which contains approximately 3 mg of mucus. I spread this over the metal surface of the octave pip and closed the pad for 10 minutes. It is not necessary in this test to use equal weights to compare different sticky substances on stickiness. The point of this experiment is to compare different possible scenario's relevant for saxophone playing which could cause stickiness and select one that has a stickiness comparable to the force of the springs. With mucus I will only go as far as the use of spit and avoid the heavy snot as it is not a likely scenario and would upset Jimmymack.

I have been to a mucus workshop where we spoke for 4 hours straight on the properties of mucus. In such an environment I would use different test protocols and use a medical defined mucus substitute. But that doesn't seem appropriate here.
 
Pork snot is less sticky. Also The surface tension of this issue being tested will vary depending on the skin used. I’ve no experience with pork snot on kangaroo rump.
I do have some experience in testing leather. Mostly abrasion tests with asphalt. Mass and velocity greatly affect its long-term usefulness. Treatment and Coatings have zero benefit in this regard.

It is good to know that I don't have to test pork snot. Do you think that a saxophone is abrasive enough to remove the coating of a leather pad? Until now I think that the coating is the relevant testing surface.

As it is very hard to find out which coating is used on which pad I just call it a leather. My guess is PU.
 
Sticking force. And the force would be around 0.05N (rounding).
You are right, except that it is breaking force. If I use this language in a scientific school on the play ground the other kids will not play with me.
But using scientific correct language among musicians feels wrong. I prefer to use the relatable weight of playing cards and try to avoid zeros after the decimal point (5dN). I use power instead of force because when people tear something apart they can make a reasonable guess of the energy used, but not of the force at breaking point. In this way I try to avoid the voodoo of lab coats and glasses.
 
Is there a fundamental difference, in this context, between gob, spit, mucos and swet?
The mucus and the watery fluid in spit comes from two different glands. In order of the mucus to watery fluid ratio these glands produce sweat, tears, eye fluid, spit, and mucos in different parts of the body. Most sweat doesn't contain mucus with the exception of sweat coming from mucosa tissue.

Some bacteria in the body produce other types of slime based on carbohydrates.
 
Last edited:

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,070
Messages
578,529
Members
8,132
Latest member
LouisJR
Back
Top Bottom