Tech/maintenance Martin C Melody Restoration

Still fighting some leaks. Several pads had a very coarse surface. Typically I do not set a heavy impression. Looking here you can see the difference of a ironed texture. Good way to check for even contact too.
Had many that were less than acceptable. Completely reset. 1st pic look at pad in lower right. The heavy impression if at all is best to be on key arm side.
Some of the leak issue I also think it’s related to humidity. As installed the humidity was around 28%. Today it is 56%. Then my wife is playing with air conditioner. For the time being I said it outside in the sun for about a half hour. Just enough to warm up. Wedged all the keys closed. I’m going to let it sit overnight.
F414DB1E-E3DF-49E6-8E6C-019BD93E69A0.jpeg
124A3FBB-EE19-4091-800E-58306743A603.jpeg

A36367C0-DDE2-4E45-A12E-430805ABC031.jpeg
F1EA957E-05C7-4926-A8D7-FFE2D67AF5AD.jpeg

1625259510610.webp
 
Last edited:
The joy of tuning with a tuner and a little information from a friend.
Neck with mouthpiece, F4 flat at 345 Hz. Mouthpiece halfway on neck was about exact. Although having two vintage mouthpieces and a modern plastic turd did not help matters much. I actually had better success hitting notes with an RPC Alto. It didn’t fall off the neck but was close and a ton more forgiving. Vandoren Java 2.5 reed.
36CD7AF8-6DE5-4F7B-9B78-682D9371114F.webp
FEED129C-6E2A-480F-B38D-C41A367D552A.webp
6DE997B0-DBA2-40E2-BD3F-792B607AE94C.webp
906C05AD-A37E-4C65-963C-CFB597860393.webp
 
Friday afternoon I put the sax outside on a stand. Let it get nice and warm. Gently wedged all the keys closed and put it back inside. Two days later it failed a vacuum test miserably. Removing the neck and tested again. Perfect ! Well that eliminated leaking pads or tone holes. The neck fit reasonable but not perfect. I needed to work on the receiver more and knew it. A quick smear of beeswax on tenon & receiver sealed well. It will now hold vacuum for :30+ seconds no problem. Temporary fix…
At this point the alto mouthpiece wouldn’t play in tune all the way out.
Back to Selection. The Conn Eagle played the best with a Rico Royal 2.5. A 1.5-2 would just close up. Didn’t have 3 tenor and 3.5 I’m out of shape to play. This is the first time I’m back playing after four years of medical issues.
I used a black rubber glove over bell for leak / vacuum test.
D2490173-4DC0-4786-B866-6F6CC9CFC4E8.jpeg
C3718235-33D1-456D-AC5D-2ACF531E5BF1.jpeg
 
Last edited:
I’m happy now. Took it all apart cleanup work all done. Good oiling and assembled. Plays better on Conn Eagle mouthpiece & 2.5. This thing took an insane amount of time. Although if you’re doing a DIY home project so what…

Fully fettled and actively in use. I’m hoping I can play “Take Five“ by November
1625948413122.jpeg

1625948471576.jpeg

1625948628717.jpeg


1625948754138.jpeg

1625948820532.jpeg
 
Update/six-month report.
It took a while for the pads to stay put. I ended up raising the key heights on the upper stack. Especially the G. That included resetting the octave mechanism. PIA but worth it. I’ve opened the lower stack some, mostly on D. Nothing is stuffy, no warble but the low end still plays a tad flat. Overall it’s very enjoyable to play. It plays well enough. My friend who is a pro player and tech put it on stage. Maybe I’m just too fussy:doh:
2B28E095-AA7D-4F03-AF8C-E49067ACA0A9.webp
E5530541-6D48-4374-8EF8-1CF0915307EB.webp
 
Needed to blow off some steam tonight. Playing is way out of tune but at least you get to hear what it sounds like. In reality I’ve only been playing since November daily. Not much prior to that for four years.
I did this in one take. Buescher C mouthpiece #3 tenor reed.
 
Needed to blow off some steam tonight. Playing is way out of tune but at least you get to hear what it sounds like. In reality I’ve only been playing since November daily. Not much prior to that for four years.
I did this in one take. Buescher C mouthpiece #3 tenor reed.
All you need is to play it against the backing track that you used and it'll be part of a "musical framework", I can see / imagine how this would sound from your playing. You are making strides!

Just download the free version of Audacity where you can import the backing MP3 track and then play along to it while you are recording it. You can also do it the hard way with playing the backing track over the stereo and then play along to it but you won't be able to do any mixing/volume adjustment that way.

If you use Audacity or any other SW Package, use headphones to isolate the backing track from your own recording. Then when you listen to the full track, you'll hear where your pitch and timings are off, you can't do that with an isolated recording (I mean you can, theoretically but it'll be a lot harder). This is going to speed up your tone and timing development by a factor of at least 10 and it'll be so much more fun to play that way. Any old laptop will work for that, it should work with a tablet, too but this is where some of the clunkier hardware will have some advantage.
 
Since this thread has been revived, I have to admit I am a bit confused about the "rubber glove over the bell" vacuum or suction test. It is common practice to test the vacuum on flutes, oboes, and clarinet with bladder, cork or synthetic pads that are completely airtight. I have done it both ways with a Magnehelic and by blowing or sucking air with the end of the instrument plugged. On a well made instrument with toneholes that are intact a reading of zero on the mag indicates a leak free tube. What puzzles me about using this technique on saxophone is the fact that most pads are porous to some extent and in terms of the instrument as a whole, that porosity is cumulative. My question is where is the line drawn on where the amount of pressure loss is acceptable and where it is not.

A tech in Arizona who posts on repair facebook sites does a whole saxophone leak test with the rubber object over the bell using a Magnehelic set a 8in.H2O input pressure. A zero would be a perfect reading and an 8 would indicate "free flowing air" through the tube. He claims his pad work is leak free when he gets a reading of 7. I know that another well known tech uses a similar "measuring technique" as well which I think is based upon the amount of time before either the positive or negative air pressure is lost due to leakage. If you don't mind my asking, how do you describe the way you are doing it?
 
Since this thread has been revived, I have to admit I am a bit confused about the "rubber glove over the bell" vacuum or suction test. It is common practice to test the vacuum on flutes, oboes, and clarinet with bladder, cork or synthetic pads that are completely airtight. I have done it both ways with a Magnehelic and by blowing or sucking air with the end of the instrument plugged. On a well made instrument with toneholes that are intact a reading of zero on the mag indicates a leak free tube. What puzzles me about using this technique on saxophone is the fact that most pads are porous to some extent and in terms of the instrument as a whole, that porosity is cumulative. My question is where is the line drawn on where the amount of pressure loss is acceptable and where it is not.

A tech in Arizona who posts on repair facebook sites does a whole saxophone leak test with the rubber object over the bell using a Magnehelic set a 8in.H2O input pressure. A zero would be a perfect reading and an 8 would indicate "free flowing air" through the tube. He claims his pad work is leak free when he gets a reading of 7. I know that another well known tech uses a similar "measuring technique" as well which I think is based upon the amount of time before either the positive or negative air pressure is lost due to leakage. If you don't mind my asking, how do you describe the way you are doing it?
I actually did the test with a lightweight glove and a heavy weight. Both as vacuum and pressure. Due to the lack of testing equipment I didn’t have any other options. Largely I was after checking the neck joint fit.
I have no basis which to work from. So in reality I’m guessing if it holds pressure or vacuum for 15 to 30 seconds it’s good. My theory is any leaks respond instantly while playing.
 
I use the glove technique too, after I saw it on one of Matt Storher's videos.

I used to have a perfect little ball, that I stole from my kids back in the days when they were little, to do a similar thing on sopranos.
 
I've used it, too on my 1898 Conn alto, that's how I found the crack in one of the tone hole chimneys, which was not visible with a leak light because of the obstruction of the view by some of the other key work but I could hear the hissing. There wasn't really anything scientific about the way I did it, just suck as hard as I could and watch the glove come back out of the bell really fast. And it took me a dozen attempts until I was able to pinpoint the issue but it was still only about 5 min total time. Quick and dirty at its best but it solved the problem.
 
It’s been a while since I posted on this one. It’s actually become one of my more favorite horns to goof around on. Playing that is. It took a long while to get everything to settle. But now it’s rock solid. It plays best with the Conn Eagle mouthpiece. Recently I’ve been playing with a Rico Blue box #3. That made a huge difference just a step up from a #2. Thanks @LostCircuits for the tip.
I haven’t played this one for over a week but here’s tonight‘s result on a half hour playing.
4A39FC48-B242-440F-9495-1CBE8020DF33.jpeg

I need to get around to lowering the lower stack keys about 2-3 mm. About 3-4 mm on the low C……I think ?
1657357698542.webp
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,069
Messages
578,512
Members
8,131
Latest member
Jef B
Back
Top Bottom