Tech/maintenance Martin C Melody Restoration

Seing the quality of your work, I feel like I did a really miserable job a few years ago. Being the same model makes it easy to compare. Now, it was my first overhaul and repad. There is a learning curve. Starting with a C-Mel closing on 100 years is not the best of choices...
Don’t be so hard on yourself. The job you did was best to your experience level. Sometimes you have to get your hands dirty to learn. It’s not a perfect world and I’ve made a few mistakes on this one too. I should have known better than to experiment with a new anti-flux and solder on a silver plate:doh:

On a sidenote. I have 50+ years mechanical experience. My trade is commercial printing. I’ve restored pocket watches and watches for over 25 years. Competitively raced off road / speedway motorcycles for a little over 50 years with all my own maintenance. During which I restored over 55 street motorcycles. Seven body off frame car restorations. I worked as an engine mechanic on a NASCAR team two years just for fun.
Somewhere in the middle of all that I’ve built two houses.
At one I had a in house pet pig…..
 
Well, I really am an 'amateur' compared to you.

Always looking to do things right and improve what's in my hands, but an amateur nonetheless... I studied engineering basics but got diverted into IT as an accident of life. I still like to work on hands on projects when I can and I'm usually not ending in too much of a mess.

But, I have to say that what you are doing here is very nice and gives me a very positive push to revisit my own job.
 
Well, I really am an 'amateur' compared to you.

Always looking to do things right and improve what's in my hands, but an amateur nonetheless... I studied engineering basics but got diverted into IT as an accident of life. I still like to work on hands on projects when I can and I'm usually not ending in too much of a mess.

But, I have to say that what you are doing here is very nice and gives me a very positive push to revisit my own job.
Thanks for the compliment. Although I will say look around. I feel like an amateur around Steve. The best learning mistake is one that you do not repeat. If you’re not making mistakes you’re not learning. The shellac sticks I made are like baseball bats. Had to break one and half and re-melted to a usable size. Stick happens !

Any questions / pictures you would like to post about your sax on this thread be my guest. It a Martin.
image.webp
 
I would be interested in how you transformed the flakes into sticks. 😉
I used a large propane torch with the flakes in a pyrex baking dish.
They are all hand shaped. I wanted all the sticks the same size for the testing noted in post #95. I mounted a sticks over a pie tin in front of a space heater. 8 to 10 hours at a time for three days. The material never sagged. Placement moves 0-8“ in a enclosed room. Heater output was 178°. The weight of the each stick averaged 1.7 ounces. 17 x 15 mm 9 inches long lol. I sent my findings to Matt S. He uses a different product. Performance was comparable.
1621545045857.jpeg

1621545125167.jpeg


1621545419314.jpeg

1621546014349.jpeg
 
Last edited:
I used a large propane torch with the flakes in a pyrex baking dish.
They are all hand shaped. I wanted all the sticks the same size for the testing noted in post #95.
They look very uniform for "hand shaping". I experimented with making sticks using shellac flakes from Ferree's a few years ago. I used silicone "ice trays" for making ice pieces that fit into plastic water bottles. I melted the flakes in a pyrex measuring cup and then poured the molten shellac into the mold. I found out later it would have been easier and less messy to fill the molds with flakes and then heat them in the oven. After trying the homemade sticks which worked pretty well, I found I preferred the more expensive sticks sold by Ferree's.

melting the shellac flakes.webp
the melted shellac in an ice mold.webp
the homemade sticks next to a purchased .webp
 
They look very uniform for "hand shaping". I experimented with making sticks using shellac flakes from Ferree's a few years ago. I used silicone "ice trays" for making ice pieces that fit into plastic water bottles. I melted the flakes in a pyrex measuring cup and then poured the molten shellac into the mold. I found out later it would have been easier and less messy to fill the molds with flakes and then heat them in the oven. After trying the homemade sticks which worked pretty well, I found I preferred the more expensive sticks sold by Ferree's.

View attachment 18280View attachment 18281View attachment 18282
Ready-made sticks are actually a reasonable value now that I’ve had this experience. Especially when you can buy 12 for $50 delivered. that’s providing they are 1 ounce sticks.
My 1Lbs of flakes was just shy of $38 delivered. Then factor in your time & propane. This took me a little more than an hour.

I’ve seen your attempt at making these into bars posted somewhere else. Thanks to that I avoided repeating the exercise.
I like the idea of the silicone molds, but I would be suspicious of that working in the oven. I had actually considered liquefying the product in denatured alcohol. This is the method for applying it to furniture. So I figured it would work for bars. Pour and just let it evaporate. How much yield in one pour could get interesting. Not to mention the additional expense. It’s better to buy these ready-made.
FYI Los Angeles county has banned the sale of denatured alcohol for environmental reasons. The juice is like liquid gold around here. I’m saving what I have for my pad lamp.
Anyone tried using 151 Bacardi for their lamp ?
 
Ready-made sticks are actually a reasonable value now that I’ve had this experience. Especially when you can buy 12 for $50 delivered. that’s providing they are 1 ounce sticks. My 1Lbs of flakes was just shy of $38 delivered. Then factor in your time & propane. This took me a little more than an hour.
That is a good price. The Ferree's amber shellac I prefer is now $17.38 a stick or $162.56 a dozen. 😵 Their flakes sell for about $31 per lb.
I’ve seen your attempt at making these into bars posted somewhere else. Thanks to that I avoided repeating the exercise.
I like the idea of the silicone molds, but I would be suspicious of that working in the oven. I had actually considered liquefying the product in denatured alcohol. This is the method for applying it to furniture. So I figured it would work for bars. Pour and just let it evaporate. How much yield in one pour could get interesting. Not to mention the additional expense. It’s better to buy these ready-made.
Some of the molds are advertised to withstand temperatures up to 446° F. The melting temperature of shellac is around 160°. I tried dissolving some flakes in alcohol and waiting for it to evaporate, and abandoned that idea because it took so long.
FYI Los Angeles county has banned the sale of denatured alcohol for environmental reasons. The juice is like liquid gold around here. I’m saving what I have for my pad lamp. Anyone tried using 151 Bacardi for their lamp ?
That's unfortunate. Alcohol has so many uses in my shop, and I don't even use an alcohol lamp. It works great when cleaning old shellac out of keycups while they are still warm.
 
I’ve seen your attempt at making these into bars posted somewhere else. Thanks to that I avoided repeating the exercise.
I like the idea of the silicone molds, but I would be suspicious of that working in the oven.
I used some silicon molds to melt flakes in the oven and it worked. Unfortunately, for some reasons the resulting sticks don't melt easily and don't stick as the shellac I normally use from the MM gun.

The gun has it's issues too, when you need to replace the cartridge and there is shellac all over that you need to melt and clean up to install the next cartridge...
FYI Los Angeles county has banned the sale of denatured alcohol for environmental reasons.
I'm intrigued by this use of shellac and since I love to work with wood and build stuff, I need to investigate and give the furniture thing a try. I've seen such beautiful lacquered pieces of furniture...

I was just trying to find my sticks and they are nowhere to be found... My bench has become such a mess over the last year that I have almost not used it; It's a shame! I might give it a go over the next couple of days as we're enjoying a long week-end and the weather is not gonna be great...
 
Just had a look at MM site and they do offer a 'Z-GUN SHELLAC GUN - REPLACEMENT PARTS' that shows the limitation of the gun... At a price that is slightly higher than a cartridge, you better not replace it too often!

The cartridge, that is probably less that a stick, costs $16,30. FWIW!
 
I used some silicon molds to melt flakes in the oven and it worked. Unfortunately, for some reasons the resulting sticks don't melt easily and don't stick as the shellac I normally use from the MM gun.

The gun has it's issues too, when you need to replace the cartridge and there is shellac all over that you need to melt and clean up to install the next cartridge...

I'm intrigued by this use of shellac and since I love to work with wood and build stuff, I need to investigate and give the furniture thing a try. I've seen such beautiful lacquered pieces of furniture...

I was just trying to find my sticks and they are nowhere to be found... My bench has become such a mess over the last year that I have almost not used it; It's a shame! I might give it a go over the next couple of days as we're enjoying a long week-end and the weather is not gonna be great...
When I originally contacted <!--45-->With Shellac, it is all about the Finish they denied any knowledge of shellac for instruments. although they are very knowledgeable about woodworking finishes.

BTW it’s an excellent wood finish. https://www.google.com/search?q=amb...hUKEwjP2fS_i-PwAhV2HzQIHUKVCAAQ4dUDCBA&uact=5

I’m wondering if you smoked the shellac in the oven. It has a low smoke point. I’m guessing under 200° F. While heating the stick over my alcohol lamp I do not let it smoke.
I’ve heard all kinds of stories about the MM gun. Keep me posted on your parts inventory.

When you find your shellac look to see if my new packages of sandpaper are with it. I don’t remember where I put them:doh:
 
Last edited:
That is a good price. The Ferree's amber shellac I prefer is now $17.38 a stick or $162.56 a dozen. 😵 Their flakes sell for about $31 per lb.

Some of the molds are advertised to withstand temperatures up to 446° F. The melting temperature of shellac is around 160°. I tried dissolving some flakes in alcohol and waiting for it to evaporate, and abandoned that idea because it took so long.

That's unfortunate. Alcohol has so many uses in my shop, and I don't even use an alcohol lamp. It works great when cleaning old shellac out of keycups while they are still warm.
Well it would be interesting to see how the suppliers are making our supplied sticks. Obviously someone has figured out the process.


One of the complexities of stick shellac shopping is size, or is it weight ? Yeah +/- $32/lb is about right for flakes. Pricing is all over. None actually list the size or weight of the product.
That said, one of the clear synthetic MM sticks would do a tenor. Alto about 1-1/2” leftover.…. And all that depends how concave the cups are.
This C Martin the cups are reasonably flat. I used less than a half a stick of brand Pigs.
999EEFDF-646E-441B-9C19-0CD86255F595.webp

Not a very good picture sorry. Martin is on the left. A Holton alto on the right. The Martin cup is much flatter. Less to fill.
1621888479329.webp

Everything ready to go I started installing the pads. Gently heating and applying the shellac in a continuous motion. Working from the outside in. Making sure to apply an even amount and thick enough. No voids.
If you’ve never done this before practice on some old pads. Too much and you will have a mess oozing out the edges of the cup. Too little and the pad will be insecure and cause leaks. I did a few here to show potential issues. I reworked them after the photograph.
189E1580-CB26-4217-BA6A-C82CB8C5C567.webp

Safety note; always have a fire extinguisher in your work area. Wear safety glasses. Shellacs sticks extremely well to everything. Including your skin. I keep a bottle of chefs spray burn treatment on hand.
 
Everything ready to go I started installing the pads. Gently heating and applying the shellac in a continuous motion. Working from the outside in. Making sure to apply an even amount and thick enough. No voids.
If you’ve never done this before practice on some old pads. Too much and you will have a mess oozing out the edges of the cup. Too little and the pad will be insecure and cause leaks. I did a few here to show potential issues. I reworked them after the photograph.
We are on the same page. I like to cover the entire back of the pad with shellac with a tad extra in the center to facilitate "floating" and to accommodate the "bowl" in the key cup. I worked with an excellent woodwind tech in a music store who was trained by his father-in-law who was an "old school" tech who used a lot of shellac on the pad and then heated the keycup and pressed down hard on the resonator with a wooden hammer handle. It was done to intentionally force shellac out of the edges of the pad.

The theory behind it was to insure that no moisture could enter the key cup at the sides of the pad which might cause deterioration of the cardboard and felt on the back of the pad. As you might imagine it looked like crap. He was the same tech who never used a leak light on saxophones---just a feeler gauge. That said, his work on clarinets, flutes, and oboes was first rate. I used to tease him about not using electricity because he was Amish (he was Mormon, of course 🙂 )
 
How much to apply varies from unit to unit and your style. Everyone is different. So here is how I approached this one.
Average cup depth at rim.
1621889638691.jpeg

Average pad thickness. When measuring make sure you’re not on top the resonator.
1621889741176.jpeg

Thickness setting of cup to tone hole face.
1621890063676.webp

Do the math. Compensate as needed. Leave a little wiggle room. these I needed to add more. I’m also using a new material. Getting a feel for it. Partly the reason I had not gone closer to the edge.
1621890303063.webp
 
While the shellac is still hot flatten on a stone. Voids, bubbles or irregularities will be obvious.
in this picture you can see the material sagging. Also one void. Look for your consistency around the outer edges.
1621890924052.webp

A visual on the stone also will show you if your work is staying flat. Works as a visual thickness gauge too.
A couple of these are very warped. The flatter the better !
1621891090181.webp
 
Heating cup I place the shellacked pad in and give it one full turn. I feel this evens the shellac around the pad / cup. There is a certain feeling of how the pad turns in the cup. Just the right amount of shellac it feels like you’re turning it on butter. Not enough and it feels like you’re dragging an old boot. I didn’t have any shellac out my edges.
E84525A7-E31F-4828-AA72-94D630CDA172.jpeg

If everything works as planned the finished product should be close to fit.
1621891744526.jpeg

1621896689893.jpeg

1621896802552.webp
 
Last edited:

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,069
Messages
578,512
Members
8,131
Latest member
Jef B
Back
Top Bottom