Tech/maintenance Martin C Melody Restoration

Well padded narrow jaw pliers, boards with holes drilled, proceed slowly and check your work a lot.

While professionals have all kinds of tricks to straightening rods and tubes, for those of us where speed isn't money, hand bending carefully and checking against a known flat surface (or indicating in the lathe as you show) will get them plenty straight enough.
I was looking to improve on the handles with holes drilled.
hand bending well only get you so far. A little too much and you’re screwed. The piece I’m showing above is 6 inches long. @.028 run out the rod binds. yeah I can get that one straight.
 
The way I was taught to straighten bent hinge tubes (key barrels) was to insert a perfectly straight rod into each end and make a mark with a Sharpie at the point it meets resistance. The bend in the tube is between the two marks. Then the straight rod is inserted into the tube and you view each end to try to see a "crescent" opening on one side of the rod. Then you take the tube with the rod inserted and place supports (or fingers) under it at each mark. Then you turn it so the side opposite the crescent is up and give it a tap between the marks with a small plastic hammer. You move the rod and check for friction and repeat if necessary. Sometimes there are bends on more than one plane which makes it a bit more complicated. My standard for straightness is to be able to drop the rod into the end of the tube held vertically and it falls quickly through it.

1620860937567.jpeg
 
The way I was taught to straighten bent hinge tubes (key barrels) was to insert a perfectly straight rod into each end and make a mark with a Sharpie at the point it meets resistance. The bend in the tube is between the two marks. Then the straight rod is inserted into the tube and you view each end to try to see a "crescent" opening on one side of the rod. Then you take the tube with the rod inserted and place supports (or fingers) under it at each mark. Then you turn it so the side opposite the crescent is up and give it a tap between the marks with a small plastic hammer. You move the rod and check for friction and repeat if necessary. Sometimes there are bends on more than one plane which makes it a bit more complicated. My standard for straightness is to be able to drop the rod into the end of the tube held vertically and it falls quickly through it.

View attachment 18207
Thank you for your posting.
I was already applying these techniques in post 34/35. Still looking for something better as some need more finessed straightening. I can’t post the video but the rod did drop straight through.
26151CF5-42CB-4C8A-95AC-D7EE9E4DB552.webp

1620862803149.webp

I’ve got some ideas in the works.
 
I’ve got some ideas in the works.
So have I.

I'm not going to share my barrel straightening method just yet. All of the above work fine - with a bit of patience and skill - but I'm working on perfecting a different method.
As and when I come to any conclusions, I'll be happy to share - but in the meantime...don't wait up.
 
Will this contraption work ? Will pigs fly 😵
:optimistic:
View attachment 18214
This Jules Verne gadget actually works. Amazingly quite well too ! Still like all prototypes some quirks to be worked out.
1621106397434.webp

Four positions measured. Now the part is +/- .004 end to end. Off the lathe the rod moves freely.
1621106715602.webp
I have pictures of all four positions of both ends & middle . I’m only showing the ones with the maximum measured runout. Look at the middle to follow relationship of the four positions
1621107128969.webp

1F91F8C7-5C25-4E37-81EB-2AE4C6680321.webp
98B303C4-353A-4143-B2A2-0D51B070C8BA.webp
 
This move bent the tool some. All-thread is not exactly hard material. I will say I had a decent amount of pressure on the part.
I’m guessing somewhere around 15 to 20 kg / 30-40lbs

BCA8B708-C849-49FD-AD91-FCC6D1CAB01D.jpeg

The finished work. Need to Polish and it’s all done. Regulation and pad time.
7938DC9D-D5EC-496F-B10A-88CA9649997D.jpeg

1621108541530.png
 
Last edited:
Last few corrections. Bell key system was way out of adjustment. Now adjusted to a reasonable specification. Enough room in three locations for 1 mm or less cork.

Before. With the LH Bb touch fully depressed (right red) the key itself on left is still fully open. Notice the huge linkage gap midway.
The green lines show where I’m guessing correct is. Anything wrong and you will feel it in your pinky finger.
1621312141821.webp


After.
E8F65521-09B4-48A8-B59E-EE7FF4F85C27.webp
0BAAC312-A1A4-4C31-A1AD-8932B3EE2875.webp
 
A brief word about shellac. This is my first go making shellac from flakes. I made these two months ago. The material has been through rigorous testing. At one point I had it in front of a space heater for eight hours. Didn’t budge. After a few hot and cold cycles I actually took a micrometer to it. It does not expand or contract with ambient temperature change. I’m showing my reasoning for change. Two pictures of synthetic sticks from a premium company. These were in my storage cabinet four months. Originally they were all perfectly straight.
1621313243775.webp

1621313282306.webp

flakes.
1621313402456.webp

into sticks
1621313485829.webp
 
. I’m showing my reasoning for change. Two pictures of synthetic sticks from a premium company. These were in my storage cabinet four months. Originally they were all perfectly straight.
I favour shellac - but there are times when I'll use HMG. I find it particularly effective for small sax pads (palms, octaves etc.) and clarinets. And for use when refitting/resetting pads that were fitted with HMG in the first place.
However, there are many types of HMG - so you have to be careful to looks through the specs when choosing one.
3M's 3792Q seems to be pretty much an industry standard - and none of my sticks have gone droopy on me yet.

Trouble is, it's an industrial glue - so you have to buy it by the box (160 or so sticks). I've got enough to last me a lifetime...and more.

3m 3792Qsmall.webp
 
HMG has its place. I’m just not crazy about cleaning up after this product. The working time is good. Strings are minimal and it’s clear. A little to much and oozing out the pad edge becomes a mess. Cleaning out a cup and returning to shellac…good luck.

Anyone interested in learning more about hot melt glues go here.
 
Key cups sized and pads selected from inventory to fit. Just snug enough to not fall out. To loose and the shellac may leak out the sides. Too tight and the pad may deform in a unwanted way. I’ve numbered the cups and the pads so they go back in same cups after a light buffing.
1621466532232.jpeg

Everything has now been lightly polished. I used a very soft cotton wheel and extra fine jewelers rouge. I don’t suggest this to anyone unfamiliar with machine buffing. It’s very easy to lose a part in hand and damage it beyond repair ! Also being gentle to the plating. This needs to last another 95 years 😉
1BC7956B-C4C1-4390-A1DA-CB9907D3027A.jpeg

After this step I gave all the cups a final check. All cups are face flat and round to pads. No need to re-check cup to tone hole settings.
 
Last edited:
A note about the quantity of shellac to apply.
Before setting a static clearance between the tone hole and the key cup without pad. I measured the thickness of the original pads.
+/- 4.4mm average. The key cups average 3.4mm at rim. I set tone hole to cups @ 1.mm+. leaving room for cork regulation / setup. The new pads thickness is reasonably consistent @ 4,07mm(.160) This leaves the pad about 0,5 mm over the cup height. So for the most part I will be filling the middle/cardboard area of the pad back. At 0,5mm clearance not much shellac will be needed.
Here’s a picture of the pad in the cup with no shellac.
1621470065407.webp
 
Seing the quality of your work, I feel like I did a really miserable job a few years ago. Being the same model makes it easy to compare. Now, it was my first overhaul and repad. There is a learning curve. Starting with a C-Mel closing on 100 years is not the best of choices...
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,069
Messages
578,512
Members
8,131
Latest member
Jef B
Back
Top Bottom