S.D. This is exactly the type of thing I meant, when I said, "learning to run, before you can walk".
As Pete and Griff say, holding down the "octave" key, isn't/shouldn't be a problem.
John.
That very well could be a large part of the problem right there John. There's no question about it that I'm just jumping right into just playing this thing like as if I already know how, when in fact, I don't.
🙂))
I'm absolutely guilty as charged on that count. No question about that at all.
Another thought occurs to me. Is your octave key at the right hight, and not bent up or down?
John.
That's a real possibility too. I never really thought of that. It does feel like this key goes too far down.
In fact, now that you mention this let me offer some observations about my horn. First off this is a really cheap horn. I mean it's not total junk I hope, but it is a very inexpensive model. So it could just be in very poor adjustment.
Now looking at the register key closely I see two things that don't look right to me.
First, there is a little "foot" or post that is on the bottom of the key, it has a felt pad on it and it evidently serves to keep the key from being depressed too far. This post, or "foot" rests against the horn when the key is pressed. Just looking at this post it appears to be bent and isn't meeting the horn body squarely. So that might be a problem right there.
Secondly, when pressed down, the register goes down lower than the thumb rest. Quite a bit actually, about 3 mm or 1/8 inch.
In fact, when I'm playing I do feel that. It's like I need to rock my thumb off the thumb rest a bit in order to get a solid register shift.
I think if the key stopped flush with the thumb rest it wouldn't be nearly the problem that it is.
So maybe that's it?
Maybe I just need to adjust this register key somehow.
One possible solution would be to put a thicker pad (about 3mm thick) under the "foot" post of the key so the key doesn't depress below the thumb rest, and then adjust the linkage for the new key height. That might just do it!
Thanks for the insight John.