What I meant was that, if you really want to improve, you need to learn to play middle D with the standard fingering.
Viruskiller, Filton, and Saxnik,
I am in total agreement with everything you guys are saying here.
However, I think there is some misunderstanding here.
I'm not suggesting that this should be my main technique for learning how to play the saxophone in general. I'm not even remotely suggesting this. That was never my intent.
I totally understand the usefulness of learning basics and especially for slowing things down and getting a solid handle on them. I do that sort of thing all the time with all the instruments I play.
My goal right now is to learn to play a particular piece of music quickly. I don't care how many "cheats" are required to achieve that goal. This is in no way going to affect my "standard practice routines".
For example, I'm working my way through John O'neil's Jazz Method for the Saxophone. I play all his lessons using the fingerings and techniques that he suggests. That is basically my "program" for learning to play the saxophone in general. And I do that methodically, slowly, and purposefully.
You can say that this is my "method" for learning the saxophone.
Ok, now, as an
ASIDE to that,...
I'm going off on a tangent for some fun and trying to learn to play a particular piece of music that is admittedly currently over my head. My only goal with this particular piece is to find a way to play it. Any 'cheats' that I can find that will help me achieve this goal are totally welcome. I don't see where this is going to have an adverse affect on my standard lesson plans via John O'neil's method book.
So I'm not disagreeing with any of you, on the contrary, I'm in total agreement with what you are saying in general.
I'm just trying to have a little fun on the
SIDE, and play a little piece of music that is basically over my head, but appears to be almost within reach if I accept a few "cheats".
I'm perfectly cool with doing this.
It's not going to destroy my standard method of practice. That is still in-tact and I continue to practice those standard lessons too. I'm also fully aware that if I succeed in playing this more advanced piece of music, that's not going to instantly make me a great saxophone player. It's going to be a "cheat" and I'm well aware that it is a "cheat".
So I hope this helps to clear up my goals. I'm not proposing that anything I'm doing here should be used as a 'standard method for learning to play a saxophone'.
It was never my intent to even remotely imply that. ;}