Saxophones Lockable Register Key?

Hey, this is great, if we all put our heads together, we might be able to redesign the sax so that we only have a few keys and our mouth to worry about.
Oh I just realised, it's already been done, it's called a trumpet!

John.

Speaking of trumpets, I have a really nice little pocket trumpet. I love the little bugger. The only thing with the trumpet is that I don't like to have to do all that 'burrrrrrrrring'. It makes my lips numb. But yeah, only three buttons, I can't complain about that.
 
Yes, I'm SURE I'll get it with practice. But the bottom line is that it's more difficult for me than if I didn't need to keep holding down the register key. The proof of that is simple - It's simply easier to play in the lower register when I don't need to hold down the register key. So there can be no question that it's simpler to play when I don't need to hold down the register key.

S.D. This is exactly the type of thing I meant, when I said, "learning to run, before you can walk".

As Pete and Griff say, holding down the "octave" key, isn't/shouldn't be a problem.

John.
 
... I still can't play it smoothly yet. It's especially hitting that C, D, B note run, which goes by pretty quick. Having to hold down the reg key makes it more difficult. I play it real clean in the low register without a problem. That's all I know to say.

But I WILL get it, I'm sure. ;}

Hi Sweet Dreamer,

I was pondering your problem and I wonder if it's a hand position or possibly strap height issue. To play C or B you are only holding one key down plus the octave key, this reduced contact between you and the horn can make it feel slightly unstable. The D, if we are talking about the palm D, will then compound this instability as you are then pushing the horn sideways. The tendency might then be to tense up your embouchure and body which will make the playing hard.

The other thought I had was, where are you placing your thumb on the thumb rest? For me my thumb joint sits on the thumb rest so I literally only have to bend the thumb down and the octave key is pressed. If you have the thumb pad on the thumb rest then you will need to move your whole thumb and alter the angle of your wrist to press the octave key.

Hope you find your solution soon,

Chris
 
Last edited by a moderator:
S.D. This is exactly the type of thing I meant, when I said, "learning to run, before you can walk".

As Pete and Griff say, holding down the "octave" key, isn't/shouldn't be a problem.

John.

That very well could be a large part of the problem right there John. There's no question about it that I'm just jumping right into just playing this thing like as if I already know how, when in fact, I don't. 🙂))

I'm absolutely guilty as charged on that count. No question about that at all.

Another thought occurs to me. Is your octave key at the right hight, and not bent up or down?

John.

That's a real possibility too. I never really thought of that. It does feel like this key goes too far down.

In fact, now that you mention this let me offer some observations about my horn. First off this is a really cheap horn. I mean it's not total junk I hope, but it is a very inexpensive model. So it could just be in very poor adjustment.

Now looking at the register key closely I see two things that don't look right to me.

First, there is a little "foot" or post that is on the bottom of the key, it has a felt pad on it and it evidently serves to keep the key from being depressed too far. This post, or "foot" rests against the horn when the key is pressed. Just looking at this post it appears to be bent and isn't meeting the horn body squarely. So that might be a problem right there.

Secondly, when pressed down, the register goes down lower than the thumb rest. Quite a bit actually, about 3 mm or 1/8 inch.

In fact, when I'm playing I do feel that. It's like I need to rock my thumb off the thumb rest a bit in order to get a solid register shift.

I think if the key stopped flush with the thumb rest it wouldn't be nearly the problem that it is.

So maybe that's it?

Maybe I just need to adjust this register key somehow.

One possible solution would be to put a thicker pad (about 3mm thick) under the "foot" post of the key so the key doesn't depress below the thumb rest, and then adjust the linkage for the new key height. That might just do it!

Thanks for the insight John.
 
Hi Sweet Dreamer,

I was pondering your problem and I wonder if it's a hand position or possibly strap height issue. To play C or B you are only holding one key down plus the octave key, this reduced contact between you and the horn can make it feel slightly unstable. The D, if we are talking about the palm D, will then compound this instability as you are then pushing the horn sideways. The tendency might then be to tense up your embouchure and body which will make the playing hard.

The other thought I had was, where are you placing your thumb on the thumb rest? For me my thumb joint sits on the thumb rest so I literally only have to bend the thumb down and the octave key is pressed. If you have the thumb pad on the thumb rest then you will need to move your whole thumb and alter the angle of your wrist to press the octave key.

Hope you find your solution soon,

Chris

Thumb position may be an issue too. I definitely have not been resting the joint of thumb on the rest. Maybe the heal of the thumb just before the joint? So I'm kind of "rocking" my thumb to depress the register key, rather than actually "swinging" it using the entire thumb joint. I think I have tried moving my thumb over a bit more to do something close to what you are saying here and found that to be awkward for me.

But now that Johnboy mentioned the possibility of the register key simply needing adjusted I think I'm going to look into that first. If I didn't' need to press the key "below" the surface of the thumb rest I think the problem would be solved. So I'm going to look into that now.
 
Yep, it sounds like the problem is probably the octave key, on my saxes the octave key goes level with the thumb rest when pressed down. The octave mechanism is a little fiddly and I wouldn't fancy trying to do that one myself.

Best of luck,

Chris
 
Register Key Height Poll?

I wonder if I can ask everyone to exam the register key motion on your sax. When you press the register key down until it hits the stop what do see?

A. The key is below the surface of the thumb rest pad
B. The key is even with the surface of the thumb rest pad
C. The key is slightly higher that the surface of the thumb rest pad.

Thanks to anyone who takes the time to check this out and report back. 🙂
 
Yep, it sounds like the problem is probably the octave key, on my saxes the octave key goes level with the thumb rest when pressed down. The octave mechanism is a little fiddly and I wouldn't fancy trying to do that one myself.

Best of luck,

Chris

Thanks Chris. You're giving me encouragement already because my key definitely is lower than the thumb rest when depressed.
 
I wonder if I can ask everyone to exam the register key motion on your sax. When you press the register key down until it hits the stop what do see?

A. The key is below the surface of the thumb rest pad
B. The key is even with the surface of the thumb rest pad
C. The key is slightly higher that the surface of the thumb rest pad.

Thanks to anyone who takes the time to check this out and report back. 🙂

Does this help?

Octave%20Key%201.jpg


Octave%20Key%202.jpg


Chris
 
Yep! Thanks for taking the time to take photos that's awesome!

My register key is definitely not right and needs adjusted. I don't think it's just bent, I think it was just poorly manufactured.

I can handle this job now that I know what the problem is. I'm a retired design engineer and I've designed and built machines far more complex than a saxophone, so I think I can adjust this key.

Thank you very much for your help!

I'm sure that his is what was causing me problems. Once I get this adjusted properly I should be able to play in the high register with no more problems.
 
I wonder if I can ask everyone to exam the register key motion on your sax. When you press the register key down until it hits the stop what do see?

A. The key is below the surface of the thumb rest pad
B. The key is even with the surface of the thumb rest pad
C. The key is slightly higher that the surface of the thumb rest pad.

Thanks to anyone who takes the time to check this out and report back. 🙂

below, on all

I find if it's too high, I catch it when I don't want to.

Chris' setup would be too high for me, but that doesn't mean that it's wrong.

Another question to ask is how much gap is there between the neck octave pin and the ring? Should be very little, but not touching.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I've made some adjustments just by bending stuff myself. 🙂))

I managed to get the key quite a bit higher. About 2mm. But it's still about 1mm below the surface of the thumb rest when pressed till the foot hits the horn. It's already easier to play than before just from what I've already done, but I really would like it to be even higher still.

Level with the thumb rest, seems inviting to me. If I could get it as high as the photo of Chris' sax I think I would like that.

But already, where it's at now is an improvement. I was thinking that I could try just taping a piece of 1mm thick cardboard onto the surface of the key just to get a feel for what that would be like. If I like that feel a lot I might look into trying to work on it some more to get the key to actually operate at that height. I think to do that I would need to put a 1mm thick pad underneath the "stop foot", and then adjust the rest of the linkage appropriately for the valves to operate correctly.

The "foot" on my key is different from the foot on Chris' key. Chris' key appears to just have a flat bottom with a piece of cork glued to it. My key actually has a brass post that appears to be welded or soldered onto the bottom of the key, and then that post has a very thin felt pad on the bottom of it.

In any case, this was a problem for sure. And potentially still isn't right. But it's more playable now than before. That 2mm made a difference that I can definitely feel.

None the less I can still feel that 1mm "Drop off". I would prefer the key to stop level with the thumb rest. I'm just thinking that would feel right.

Like I say, I'll try just taping a 1mm thick piece of cardboard on the key and see how that feels. That should make it level with the thumb rest.
 
That of course is up to you, but if you were to have it set up by a Tech. it would be level before being pressed.
And that's the way they are made! A millimeter one way or the other, shouldn't be causing you any problems.

John.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Well, as you have mentioned before John, I am indeed trying to run before I can walk. The piece I'm working on is far above my playing skills. It's extremely demanding in terms of embouchure, breathing, and even in terms of fingering for me as a raw beginner. Even though the fingerings are fairly simple, there are places where it's difficult for me to execute them smoothly and concisely. Like I say, I can execute them just fine when I'm not holding down the reg key, but that addition requirement does seem to be causing me some difficulty. Although, I also confess that I have more difficulty obtaining good sound in the higher register too. So this little quirky thing with the reg key may just be the straw that's breaking the camel's back and tripping me up as I try to run when I should be walking.

But like I say, it's the precise same phrasing that I execute just fine when playing in the low register. For some reason having to hold down that register key is bothering the heck out of me.

This is especially true when I play the D note (perhaps because of the sideways pressure for that lever?). I play a run of C, D, B. and it's really that particular run that is giving the problems. But only when I'm holding down the reg key. I have no problems playing this note run smoothly when I'm just resting my thumb on the thumb rest. So it's got to be related to having to hold down the reg key. Having to hold down the reg key seems to be hampering my fingering.

But like you have said before, this could indeed just be a symptom of the fact that I'm trying to play something that is at a level I'm simply not prepared to play.

I'll tell you want I'm going to do. I'm going to cut the tempo way back. Like maybe in half. And see how that goes. If I can play it smoothly at the lower tempo maybe I can just start working my way back up to where I want to be in increments. That's probably what I should have done in the first place.

This is the perils of not having a teacher and just running off and trying to play like a pro in my first self-lesson. 🙂))

Ok. Just ignore my posts for a couple of years. Owl get it eventually. ;}
 
Hi S.D.
If it were easy, we would all be experts, and probably wouldn't be doing it!!
Keep going, and good luck.

John.

You're right John. Good things take time to master, and if it were easy anyone could just pick up the horn and play it without putting any work or dedication into it.

I confess that I'm a lazy bum who dreams of getting something for nothing. 🙂))

They don't call me Sweet Dreamer for nothing. ;}

I just can't help but think that if I had a lockable register key I'd be that much closer to my lazy bum dream. :mrcool

I wrote a little teeny piece of music. It's only 19 measures long. The first 7 measures are played exclusively in the low register, measures 8 - 17 are played exclusively in the high register and then the last two measures are back in the low register again.

I swear if I had a register lock key I could play this piece already. I'd just lock it in on measure 8 and unlock it for the last two measures.

But alas no such mechanical "cheat" exists. So owl have to learn to play it the traditional way I guess.

Owl just have to learn the art of patience, and suffer the reality of HARD WORK.

Like as if holding down a register key is HARD WORK. 🙂))

But seriously it does make the fingering more difficult for me, and "more difficult" does indeed translate into HARD WORK. ;}
 
Eureka!

Ok, maybe I just needed to change my fingering.

Thanks to this site below I found some alternative fingerings for the D note that are helping. :welldone

http://www.wfg.woodwind.org/sax/

fingerings.GIF


I was using the fingerings show in the upper charts. But I find the fingerings in the lower charts to be better for this particular piece. I didn't know you could play it like this until I saw these charts.

So there's a lot of newbie ignorance involved here too. 🙂))
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,070
Messages
578,522
Members
8,132
Latest member
LouisJR
Back
Top Bottom