Playing the saxophone Legere reed

Erm...I did say...2.75 sounds better but at the cost of easier articulation..i think

Yeah but on a mouthpiece that isn't your main mouthpiece.... so you should ditch the mouthpiece and play just one.

I get this is not what you want to hear. 😉 But if you've already decided you want to play two mouthpieces, and you want to play a 2.75 on the PT mouthpiece which you don't play all that often, then be my guest; but not much point asking questions if you don't want to hear the responses.
 
If you did play just the caravan mouthpiece, then you could roll up to your gigs, open the door and play from inside the caravan. No worries about parking, and it’s easier to pack up and leave at the end. It’s a win-win.
 
I'm also confused by what you're asking. Your question appears to be:-

You have two mouthpieces. You play a Theo Wanne and a Phil Tone. On the TW you play a 2.5 legere signature. On the PT you play a 2.75. And you're asking whether to stick with the 2.75 or to go softer.

My answer: stop playing the PT. Or stop playing the TW. Focus on one mouthpiece. And from what you say, you appear to focus on the TW already, so the entire question about strength of reed for the PT seems moot?
lol...there is no question regarding the PT..I only mentioned it as the 2.75 legere plays easier on it than it does on the TW..which is the piece i use...I have only tried the 2.75 on the PT not really played it for long..however i tried it on the TW and it sounded nice, but articulation was harder down low..hence the original questions..
 
So as I said; using the same reed on multiple mouthpieces generally isn't a great idea.

For reed selection, feel is, for me, the most important factor. How does the reed feel as you're playing, if it's uncomfortable or hard to do anything with it, then it's not the right choice, either through cut or strength. With cane reeds there might be a bedding in period; but that shouldn't be required with synthetics (personally not a fan of them, though trying some legere american cuts this week to see if they work for me any better).
 
If it were me I’d choose one mouthpiece, and then find the strength Rico reed that worked the best on it. Probably a 3, given the steength Legeres you are using. These minute details (2.5 vs 2.75) really make very little difference, and your time is way better spent working on your sound regardless of the reed you are using.

Why do you say that you can only play synthetics? Your other posts suggest you like the sound better with cane, so I really don’t see why you would want to use Legere. If you have trouble with splitting and curling, then get a good reed case, soak your reeds before you play them and wipe them off before putting them back in the reed case. Don’t tongue them too hard (which is bad technique in any case). Avoid those fancy cases with humidity packs, just use a simple, cheap D’Addario reed case.

Finally, Theo Wanne mouthpieces requiring harder reeds is a myth. Or disinformation. Or a lie…. Use the reed that a) sounds best and b) feels most comfortable. Theo Wanne maouthoieces are very well made, and very reed friendly; what strength works best is dependent on you, and nothing else.
 
Why do you say that you can only play synthetics?
He said cane wrinkled in the caravan. Cane always wrinkles on me no matter where I am in relation to caravans. 15 seconds in my mouth and a couple of flicks on the table, and the wrinkles are gone. I'd much rather contend with wrinkles than the sound and feel of synthetic.
 
If it were me I’d choose one mouthpiece, and then find the strength Rico reed that worked the best on it. Probably a 3, given the steength Legeres you are using. These minute details (2.5 vs 2.75) really make very little difference, and your time is way better spent working on your sound regardless of the reed you are using.

Why do you say that you can only play synthetics? Your other posts suggest you like the sound better with cane, so I really don’t see why you would want to use Legere. If you have trouble with splitting and curling, then get a good reed case, soak your reeds before you play them and wipe them off before putting them back in the reed case. Don’t tongue them too hard (which is bad technique in any case). Avoid those fancy cases with humidity packs, just use a simple, cheap D’Addario reed case.

Finally, Theo Wanne mouthpieces requiring harder reeds is a myth. Or disinformation. Or a lie…. Use the reed that a) sounds best and b) feels most comfortable. Theo Wanne maouthoieces are very well made, and very reed friendly; what strength works best is dependent on you, and nothing else.
I used cane all last summer a waste of time an money tbf...Lgeres work no splitting it's not storing them but playing..to humid..
 
I c
He said cane wrinkled in the caravan. Cane always wrinkles on me no matter where I am in relation to caravans. 15 seconds in my mouth and a couple of flicks on the table, and the wrinkles are gone. I'd much rather contend with wrinkles than the sound and feel of synthetic.
I could cope with wrinkles its the splitting more than a reed a week..frustrating..
 
Just curious about the splitting. Does it happen while you are playing? Or do they split when you store them? I have had maybe 5 reeds split in my life, and I’ve been playing for over 6 decades.

Since I live in the USA, I am not quite sure I know what you mean by “caravan”. Is this a vehicle, what we in the US call a SUV or mini-van? Can you only practice in that area?

I don’t want to go down a rabbit hole with you @eb424 …. really I don’t . I have practiced in my SUV at lunch when I was working, and did not find any particular issue other than being a little cramped. But I am thinking that you might be doing something that contributes to this problem that could easily be corrected. Oh my ears and whiskers…
 
I c

I could cope with wrinkles its the splitting more than a reed a week..frustrating..
Like Skeller, I can count on one hand the number of reeds that have split on me in nearly 5 decades of playing (a few hundred reeds?). I’ve had more Legeres split in a couple of years than a lifetime of cane.

I also think you might be doing something wrong. Your luck can’t possibly be that bad. Can you describe how you typically articulate? Which part of your tongue? How do you put the reed on the mouthpiece, do you slip the ligature on from the tip or leave the ligature on and slip the reed into it? How do you store your reeds?

I’m not trying to make you go back to cane. Just trying to put cane back on the table as an option, if you’re interested in going down this rabbit hole. If not, no problem.

@skeller047 , I’ve learned from watching lots of Top Gear that a caravan is what we would call a camper in the US, larger than an SUV. Not sure if a 5th wheel or full size RV would still be considered a caravan.
 
Thanks @lydian, that makes sense. But only hundreds of reeds? I’m into several thousand I’m sure…
Mostly a guess, but 6 weeks per reed over 50 years is only about 450, not counting all the duds and the years I added more instruments. These days I have reeds for soprano, alto, tenor, bari, bass saxes plus clarinet. Taking that into account, I can see thousands. I surely have a couple hundred on hand right now.
 
16897477499404764275685351080945.webp
 
Morning ( though it probably isn't) @lydian and @skeller047..the above are pictures of the caravan..its like a trailler i guess but mobile..theres no air con so in the summer probably over 100 degrees..excuse the mess just got out of bed for work..theres more room when the beds up lol..the bud can was from last night not for brekkie..ivdo have a beer whilst practising tho tbf..
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,564
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom