- Messages
- 4,216
- Location
- london
Sorry the missus says the same thing..I thought youd get the ref about dipping it in boiling water..
Last edited:
With apologies..The thread seems to have gone of track..it was never about my reed placement or struggling with legere 2.5..i don't, no squeeks..I only mention the caravan as it is to hot to play cane..I have no issues over the hall with it..no reed splitting, sticking to the table i can leave the reed on and take 5..not in the van..I found thebperfect match with cane but don't want to keep chopping and changing..i like the consistancy the legere gives me.No, I wasn't doing that just trying to help
Thanks I do that but with the legege a slivet over is best for me. Im lucky the tw has a short table..if i put the lig at thr furthest point back i can go the back of the lig is bang on the line on the Legere so i always know the tip is in the same place..Regarding the picture. With the angle of the mpc and the opening, it's really impossible to tell where the tip of the reed is. But the way to do it is to hold the mpc with the reed side facing toward you and press the reed closed with your thumb. That's when you can judge where the tip falls, ideally just a sliver of mpc visible, or perfectly even in Pete's case. That's also how you line it up when you put the reed on, by pressing the tip of the reed closed.
Sorry if this sounds too basic, but it's possible you may have missed learning this technique and have just been trying to eyeball it in it's normal state.
My calculator says (52/6)*50=433. So your math is even newer than mine, and I minored in math in college. But your expression works great for 6 reeds per week, not so great for 6 weeks per reed. You either need to work on your dimensional analysis skills or you’re much harder on reeds than I am.
And they say the US education system has gone downhill. This is proof that it’s always been terrible.
EDIT: I see your revised estimate. I still don’t follow. You honestly use 3 reeds per week? That sounds insane to me. How can a reed only last you a week? Do you play 1.5 strength? Do you play every waking hour of the day? Leaving time to sleep and eat, that’s still a max of about 3 hours per instrument per day for a total of 21 hours per week. If I only got 21 hours out of a $3 reed, I’d switch to trumpet.
I’ll try to explain with units this time.
50 years x 52 weeks/year x 1 reed / 6 weeks. Years cancel out, and weeks cancel out leaving you with total reeds. Units matter a great deal.
No worries. You definitely win in reed usage. I keep maybe two in rotation, maybe 3 months of use between them. As an amateur with a day job and tons of travel, I’m lucky to get 30 gigs a year, with 6-8 hours of rehearsals weekly. So I play far, far less than you do. I probably push my reeds way past their limit too. Unfortunately I’m the hardest on my bass reeds, the most expensive ones. Most of my gigs these days are on bass sax.So the new math cancels the les-dyxia…. I sit corrected, I’m too old and feeble (minded) to stand any more.
Sorry for misreading your post @lydian. Though there was a long period of my life where three reeds a week is about right. They weren’t $3 each then, but rent wasn’t $2750 a month either. It was an expense and I wrote it off, so the net cost was even lower.
I try to keep 8 reeds in rotation for each horn. so one needing replacement each week ain’t so bad. I was playing and practicing about 8 hours a day, sometimes more, and a six day work week was normal. I expect 20 or so hours per reed, so 2-3 reeds a week is not out of line. I don’t play that much any more, so my rate is down.
OK, so by doing this, you are in effect making the reed harder. So instead of doing that, try with the 2.75 but put the reed on normally.Thanks I do that but with the legege a slivet over is best for me. Im lucky the tw has a short table..if i put the lig at thr furthest point back i can go the back of the lig is bang on the line on the Legere so i always know the tip is in the same place..
I have tried that but tonguing 3 bottom Bs and the bars in choo choo going from mid Bb to bottom C# is difficult..The 2.5 sounds fine..most of the sing-a-long songs are quite long and fast Im not sure id have the stamina with the 2.75 which sounds better on the slow stuff..may just try the American cut. Ive started putting the 2.75 on at the end of the session and blowing to see if it will soften up in time..guess it's the same with Vandoren reds vs green i.e American vs French I find I can usually use a larger tip green..OK, so by doing this, you are in effect making the reed harder. So instead of doing that, try with the 2.75 but put the reed on normally.
I think the condensed version of this thread is that OP prefers the sound of the 2.75, but the feel/ease of playing and articulation on the 2.5. Is that a fair summary @eb424 ?Sigh. If the 2.5 sounds fine, why are we even having this discussion?
Like I said earlier, it seems like you've already decided the outcome from this whole thread before asking....
This is sooooo frustrating..lol..the 2.75 sounds better on the slow songs..it has more depth..No outcome has been decided..Sigh. If the 2.5 sounds fine, why are we even having this discussion?
Like I said earlier, it seems like you've already decided the outcome from this whole thread before asking....
Bang on...I think the condensed version of this thread is that OP prefers the sound of the 2.75, but the feel/ease of playing and articulation on the 2.5. Is that a fair summary @eb424 ?
If that's the case then I'd stick with the 2.5. You already know it works well for you. Another thing to consider is that you have your gig coming up, and changing your setup, especially to something which you've admitted you find more difficult/uncomfortable just before a long gig is a really bad idea.
You're not wrong.This is sooooo frustrating....
Hey at least you can opt out...im invested..You're not wrong.
How recently did you buy the 2.75? Can you exchange it?Bang on...
I can't change set up as you rightly say..I will carry on practicing with the 2.5..but I still don't know how long it will take the 2.75 to soften.. or if it ever will, or if dipping it in boiling water will help..or if the American cut is easier..guess ill just keep blowing it at the end of the session and see how it goes..
Use the 2.5 (or softer) then! If the 2.75 makes articulation difficult it is too hard. I would not use one.The 2.5 sounds fine..
I would not do that, with any Legere I don’t expect it to soften significantly.Ive started putting the 2.75 on at the end of the session and blowing to see if it will soften up
What is a larger tip green?!!!American vs French I find I can usually use a larger tip green..
Exactly what I was wonderingSigh. If the 2.5 sounds fine, why are we even having this discussion?
That makes no sense, you already said articulation is difficult low down, just practice tone and sound exercises with the 2.52.75 sounds better on the slow songs.
I would not bother. If a Legere does soften it means it is worn out.I still don't know how long it will take the 2.75 to soften..
I'd say that you are sweating the small stuff...The 2.5 sounds fine..most of the sing-a-long songs are quite long and fast Im not sure id have the stamina with the 2.75 which sounds better on the slow stuff...
Perhaps consider paying attention to what other folk are suggesting, then?Hey at least you can opt out...im invested..
I would say if thats where the reed plays best..keep it there tbf..I do listen to what people say and take notice accordingly..however sometimes queston how it's said..TBF the threads gone way of track..It's not about cane the caravan or my placement of the reed, which is fine according to my teacher or whether a 2.5 is ok: it was about whether working harder for a better tone is worth it..btw if you can stand in a pool of sweat dripping wet in over 100 degrees heat with no aircon because thats all youve got to practice in, and not damage a couple of no 2 cane reeds i take my hat of to youPerhaps consider paying attention to what other folk are suggesting, then?
So far we've established that you place your reeds on in a manner most would consider incorrect; somehow are destroying your cane reeds in your caravan (for context, I've had my saxes in pretty much any climate, and neverhad the issues you're describing); probably have general issues at the bottom end of the horn.
So the first thing for me would be to place the reed correctly, then start to work on your bottom end. The 2.5 legere seems to work for you, so stick with it whilst placing it correctly on your mouthpiece. If after a while it's still playing too soft, try moving up. Alternatively do the same with the 2.75, but given you've said you're having a harder time with it, that seems the incorrect approach. Perhaps also consult with your teacher and see what they suggest....
Or just carry on doing whatever it is you've already decided you want to do.....
Without meaning to be rude, you've said enough on this thread that makes me think that perhaps you aren't qualified enough to day where a reed plays best. 😉I would say if thats where the reed plays best..keep it there tbf..I do listen to what people say and take notice accordingly..however sometimes queston how it's said..TBF the threads gone way of track..It's not about cane the caravan or my placement of the reed, which is fine according to my teacher or whether a 2.5 is ok: it was about whether working harder for a better tone is worth it..btw if you can stand in a pool of sweat dripping wet in over 100 degrees heat with no aircon because thats all youve got to practice in, and not damage a couple of no 2 cane reeds i take my hat of to you
