Playing the saxophone Legere reed

16897485631733452982830602591748.webp
 
Sorry broke the reply up a bit..ok so over 100 degrees in the summer but hey it must be hot in the states..right..theres no air con..@lydian i articulate and tongue with the tip..I keep my reeds flat in the case, soak for a min then put on the mouthpiecevslidding into the already placed lig....i feel the only thing i could do different is take the reed of every time i stop and replace it after..im not an angel I stop forva ciggie or sip of bud as the sweat pours of..but its the only place i have to practice..It's the constant drying out and wetting ( i feel) that weakens the reed..I could probably use cane most weeks of the year but have enough to work on to worry about a put on and play reed..The legeres work sound ok but obviously don't give me as much choice. I may try an American cut..is that fillrd vs unfilled?
 
Hi whats the difference in your eyes
I couldn't remember as I have played the AC since they came out, but just done a quick A-B test and the AC is a clearer slightly brighter reed, signature smoother a little more subdued but I only slightly and I only tested 1 signature against 1 AC so it might be different if I did a test with say 3 of each.
 
I actually have just been trying an American Cut 2.75 out just now on my tenor (I usually play 3 Gonzalez Jazz Local 627s). It's a brighter reed than the Gonzalez, but doesn't have the deadness that I get from Legere Signatures or something like a Vandoren Java Red. Bit of buzzy ness whilst playing it, but not completely horrible. Will try and record it later alongside a Gonzalez just to do a side by side.

Still find it immediately more fatiguing to play than a cane reed though, and the mouthfeel is less pleasant.
 
I actually have just been trying an American Cut 2.75 out just now on my tenor (I usually play 3 Gonzalez Jazz Local 627s). It's a brighter reed than the Gonzalez, but doesn't have the deadness that I get from Legere Signatures or something like a Vandoren Java Red. Bit of buzzy ness whilst playing it, but not completely horrible. Will try and record it later alongside a Gonzalez just to do a side by side.

Still find it immediately more fatiguing to play than a cane reed though, and the mouthfeel is less pleasant.
I think you can get used the synthetics given enough time, of course you might not want to and stick with cane but once you find the correct strength and brand and work with it then you can get great results.
Also with Legeres experiment with tip alinement because it can make a big difference to how they play.
 
I think you can get used the synthetics given enough time, of course you might not want to and stick with cane but once you find the correct strength and brand and work with it then you can get great results.
Also with Legeres experiment with tip alinement because it can make a big difference to how they play.
Good call I find 1mm ( if that) over the end really changes the dynamics..
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I think you can get used the synthetics given enough time, of course you might not want to and stick with cane but once you find the correct strength and brand and work with it then you can get great results.
Also with Legeres experiment with tip alinement because it can make a big difference to how they play.

I've played plenty of synthetics over my time, and yet to like any of them. This is certainly the least.... [insert expletive here]. Response is good, but I still don't like the feel of it. The Gonzalez sounds better.
 
Mostly a guess, but 6 weeks per reed over 50 years is only about 450, not counting all the duds and the years I added more instruments. These days I have reeds for soprano, alto, tenor, bari, bass saxes plus clarinet. Taking that into account, I can see thousands. I surely have a couple hundred on hand right now.
Are you one of those “new math” teachers? My calculator says 6 x 52 x 50 = 15,600

Soprano, alto, tenor and clarinet for me, probably 3 new reeds per week, 60 years of playing, let’s discount the first 5 or 6 as I was just a kid, so ..

3 x 53 x 52 = 8,268. That’s probably high, I’d estimate 5K for my usage over my life. Sigh … the story of my life reduced to small chips of a plant that most people treat as a weed.
 
Last edited:
My calculator says (52/6)*50=433. So your math is even newer than mine, and I minored in math in college. But your expression works great for 6 reeds per week, not so great for 6 weeks per reed. You either need to work on your dimensional analysis skills or you’re much harder on reeds than I am.

And they say the US education system has gone downhill. This is proof that it’s always been terrible.

EDIT: I see your revised estimate. I still don’t follow. You honestly use 3 reeds per week? That sounds insane to me. How can a reed only last you a week? Do you play 1.5 strength? Do you play every waking hour of the day? Leaving time to sleep and eat, that’s still a max of about 3 hours per instrument per day for a total of 21 hours per week. If I only got 21 hours out of a $3 reed, I’d switch to trumpet.

I’ll try to explain with units this time.
50 years x 52 weeks/year x 1 reed / 6 weeks. Years cancel out, and weeks cancel out leaving you with total reeds. Units matter a great deal.
 
Last edited:
I've played plenty of synthetics over my time, and yet to like any of them. This is certainly the least.... [insert expletive here]. Response is good, but I still don't like the feel of it. The Gonzalez sounds better.
I do agree more choice i quite like gonzalez..but picking up a legere and just being able to play..tbf they sound good and respond well
 
Are you one of those “new math” teachers? My calculator says 6 x 52 x 50 = 15,600

Soprano, alto, tenor and clarinet for me, probably 3 new reeds per week, 60 years of playing, let’s discount the first 5 or 6 as I was just a kid, so ..

3 x 53 x 52 = 8,268. That’s probably high, I’d estimate 5K for my usage over my life. Sigh … the story of my life reduced to small chips of a plant that most people treat as a weed.
But you can boil and eat them when youre finished..
 
I do agree more choice i quite like gonzalez..but picking up a legere and just being able to play..tbf they sound good and respond well
I find Gonzalez just play straight out the box. Except for one box in my life, which was 5 duds. Friday afternoon reeds....

But normally I get 5 out of 5 from a box, and they all just work.

As a side note, tried the alto legere, and actually really liked it. Still get that fatiguing feeling that all synthetics seem to have, and perhaps it's because I have a brighter setup on alto, but yeah it was a nice session.
 
As a side note, tried the alto legere, and actually really liked it. Still get that fatiguing feeling that all synthetics seem to have, and perhaps it's because I have a brighter setup on alto, but yeah it was a nice session.
Interesting I find the alto Legere's to be the best of their reeds and I too have a bright setup.
Still have not found a synthetic I'm happy with on soprano but I am still hopeful one day I will.
 
Good call I find 1mm ( if that) over the end really changes the dynamics..
Just checking on this, are you saying that the tip of your reed protrudes past the end of the mouthpiece? I'm new and no expert and I may have read you wrong but for me if the reed is overhanging the mouthpiece tip it will be almost impossible to play. My reed placement is maybe 0.5mm below the end of the mouthpiece but I'm obviously more than willing to listen to anybody else's opinion. i've read somewhere that if you turn the mouthpiece round so the reed is facing away from you and you can see any of the reed then it is too high. This will also increase the risk of chipping and splitting.
 
Just checking on this, are you saying that the tip of your reed protrudes past the end of the mouthpiece? I'm new and no expert and I may have read you wrong but for me if the reed is overhanging the mouthpiece tip it will be almost impossible to play. My reed placement is maybe 0.5mm below the end of the mouthpiece but I'm obviously more than willing to listen to anybody else's opinion. i've read somewhere that if you turn the mouthpiece round so the reed is facing away from you and you can see any of the reed then it is too high. This will also increase the risk of chipping and splitting.
You are correct. But this technique can be used as a temporary measure in lieu of clipping a reed which has become too soft. I would only do such a thing in an emergency. I guess Eddie has discovered this experimentally. But this should not be used to "change dynamics" as he says.

The ideal reed placement is such that you see only a tiny sliver of mouthpiece tip, no more, no less. Overhanging has the effect of a harder reed at the expense of clean articulation. Too much under and the reed will no longer seal. Both are prone to squeaks, instability and damage as you said.
 
You are correct. But this technique can be used as a temporary measure in lieu of clipping a reed which has become too soft. I would only do such a thing in an emergency. I guess Eddie has discovered this experimentally. But this should not be used to "change dynamics" as he says.

The ideal reed placement is such that you see only a tiny sliver of mouthpiece tip, no more, no less. Overhanging has the effect of a harder reed at the expense of clean articulation. Too much under and the reed will no longer seal. Both are prone to squeaks, instability and damage as you said.
With cane i wholeheartedly agree but with the Legeres I find it different..Maybe not a mm but when i turn the mouthpiece round and look i can just see the reed..Never squeeks. Articulation is easy..

Just checking on this, are you saying that the tip of your reed protrudes past the end of the mouthpiece? I'm new and no expert and I may have read you wrong but for me if the reed is overhanging the mouthpiece tip it will be almost impossible to play. My reed placement is maybe 0.5mm below the end of the mouthpiece but I'm obviously more than willing to listen to anybody else's opinion. i've read somewhere that if you turn the mouthpiece round so the reed is facing away from you and you can see any of the reed then it is too high. This will also increase the risk of chipping and splitting.
It's not just me tbf


It seems different with synthetic
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,564
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom