Playing the saxophone Learning to Read v Playing by ear

@richardr - I think that many of the posters here have been having an early New Year! I didn't even realise that there was music with the video that I posted, I just played along by ear. The number is very simple, and as Colin the Bear said, if you can handle the I, IV and V of the key you are off to the races!

The Tenor Saxophone is a transposing instrument, which means that when you play a C on the Tenor, it sounds a concert Bb. In this case it is a Bb an octave and a whole tone below what would be written on the sheet music. The Soprano saxophone and trumpet are also Bb instruments. Forget about tenor clef, bass clef and all the others. If a score is provided for you, then check if it is in Concert pitch (in which case you will need to transpose each note up a whole tone e.g. if C is written, you play D - do not worry about the octave you are in - the range of the instrument will largely determine where you play any part). If it is a Bb part then you do not need to transpose, just play what is written. If it says Eb part then it is for Alto or Baritone or Sopranino, if it says F then it is French or Tenor horn and you are probably in the wrong room!

Having said all that, in order to improvise collectively over Careless Love, all you need to know is the I, IV and V triads, here G major, C major and D major for Bb instruments - the key here is G major, viz. concert F major. Play patterns over the triads as the harmony changes. For example, over G triad, G, B, D you could play a descending triplet pattern like G,B,G; D,G,D; B,D,B; G,D,G etc. Since the melody starts on the third B, I wouldn't start an accompaniment on the B since you are doubling the trumpet, but this is a detail for later. Also voice leading is something that you can add in later.

I would recommend playing this as much by ear as possible. Get the triads under your fingers and then just play and listen to what you play. Of course recording yourself will tell you what you did well and what you need to work on. Keep it simple to start with.

All the best, Bill
 
If a score is provided for you, then check if it is in Concert pitch (in which case you will need to transpose each note up a whole tone e.g. if C is written, you play D - do not worry about the octave you are in - the range of the instrument will largely determine where you play any part). If it is a Bb part then you do not need to transpose, just play what is written. If it says Eb part then it is for Alto or Baritone or Sopranino, if it says F then it is French or Tenor horn and you are probably in the wrong room!
Yes, fully agree. But make sure you do this from the commentary about which instrument it's for, not from the key signature.
 
Thanks to all for these explanations. I've got it clearly (I think....) Really all I wanted to know was, what the heading meant - the score was so small that it was illegible. However, now I know what tenor clef is, an added bonus, not that I'm likely ever to come across it for real.
 
I was chatting to one of the guests in our orchestra a couple of days ago. Excellent tenor horn and trombonist. Also an excellent ear player and improviser. His take was that every performance of a work is an interpretation. So he prefers to approach a piece from the dots, get to know it and then listen to other recordings. His point was that the first time you hear a piece, it sets the base with the recording, not the notes, so it colours and inhibits your own interpretation.
 
As a change from trying to get something ready to play with the band yesterday evening, this morning I had a go at playing "Lullaby of the Leaves", a tune which I'd never heard, from sheet music. It took about ten minutes to get to the point where I could play it through. I've checked how it should sound on YouTube and I got it fairly near right. Simple stuff, but it shows it can be done, even for a non-reader like me.
 
I was chatting to one of the guests in our orchestra a couple of days ago. Excellent tenor horn and trombonist. Also an excellent ear player and improviser. His take was that every performance of a work is an interpretation. So he prefers to approach a piece from the dots, get to know it and then listen to other recordings. His point was that the first time you hear a piece, it sets the base with the recording, not the notes, so it colours and inhibits your own interpretation.
I've heard that too... My source likened it to making a pizza.
 
I've heard that too... My source likened it to making a pizza.


For me its like eating a pizza. Messy, I dribble a lot and afterwards often wish I had not finished it. But I still eat quite a few pizzas even though I dont seem to get any better at it as an art form.

Really, nowadays I go where the information is. If I can get the solo, the horn chart, the dots, I like that. If not I find a recording, put it on Transcribe and work it out. If there is no previous stuff, ie there is no sax part, I will settle down and study one up. What I invent is never ever as good as I would like, except in one number where I went off the wall totally and it worked. Always gets a bit of hand when I wheel it out.

I am afraid I am discoverting that though musical, that is had an aptitude from young, I have very little in the way of ear. Pitch eliudes me if it is a bare comparison, as in tuning, though I know when what I play fits and when it doesnt. I have pretty well given up on my so called ear. I think that may be a development for an even later part of my life if I am to have such a period.

Cha cha
Mike
 
As a change from trying to get something ready to play with the band yesterday evening, this morning I had a go at playing "Lullaby of the Leaves", a tune which I'd never heard, from sheet music. It took about ten minutes to get to the point where I could play it through. I've checked how it should sound on YouTube and I got it fairly near right. Simple stuff, but it shows it can be done, even for a non-reader like me.

So it sounds as if you aren't a non-reader now? It crept up on you when you were looking in the other direction! Congrats!!!
 
I believe it is important to remember that music is what you hear, not what you see. The symbols on a printed page are simply a road map or blueprint of the sound the composer hears in his/her mind. To those symbols one learns to add all of the nuances that are not written down that turn the collection of notes into music. This is called "musicianship" and is a never ending lifetime study. You learn "musicianship" by listening to and trying to emulate great musicians.
 
As a change from trying to get something ready to play with the band yesterday evening, this morning I had a go at playing "Lullaby of the Leaves", a tune which I'd never heard, from sheet music. It took about ten minutes to get to the point where I could play it through. I've checked how it should sound on YouTube and I got it fairly near right. Simple stuff, but it shows it can be done, even for a non-reader like me.

One of my favourite versions here. I murder this on alto.

 
That might be right. I'm not a sight-reader, rather a musical cryptanalyst, but I'll use any route I can to make music including ear and dots.

You have to start like that. Same as a kid learning to read words a letter at a time. Keep doing it and it will get easier. In fact, if you did a new tune that you don't know every day I'd be surprised if you weren't a reasonably fluent sight reader within a couple of months.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,565
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom