Playing the saxophone Learning to Read v Playing by ear

The next step in this direction is to learn to pick up timing, particularly when the melody includes longish notes, without resort to sheet music. For this I need to start by hearing the melody and learning the timing by ear, which tells me that I need backing tracks with heads to start with.

I would suggest that you start by listening to good recordings rather than backing tracks, and internalise the timing that way. Do that until you could sing the melody, then go on with backing tracks without the melody.

I think playing along with a melody line on the backing track is likely to leave you still "leaning on" the other player, and you might fall over when their support is removed. Just my opinion though.
 
@richardr Learning by ear from a jazz master playing the head is the best way, as Bernie and I already said. Once you have that down, sing along with the head, then play along with the head. At this point if you use the Hal Leonard playalongs, you get the head played once or twice, then only the rhythm section, then the head to end. This is more or less the typical format for a jazz number, with improvisation after the head.

I would suggest that once you can play the head that you then listen to the playalong head till you hear how they are playing it. Every player has different timing and articulation. See if you can match this when you play along with the head, then continue to play the head over the rhythm section. Once you are confident that you are keeping your place in the form, then trade fours with the rhythm section. I.e. play for four bars, lay out for four. This is a great way to improve your time feel. At this point, stick to the melody of the head in each four bars. For a blues, you get to play each section by alternating with the rhythm section, for a typical 32 bar standard you need to switch to playing the second four bars after laying out for the first four, so that you will play all of the head.

If you really feel up to it, then trade twos with the rhythm section. This is much more challenging, since the melody typically is in four bar phrases in many melodies.

Good luck.

Bill
 
But I've heard it said that a band without gigs won't survive. So, I've had the idea that we might do a guerrilla tour: just turn up and play in bandstands in our local parks.


Of course we wouldn't charge, and there might not even be an audience. But so far I have been hesitant to suggest this to the band, I suppose I am worried they will think it is a daft idea.
Sounds like a good idea to me....

Which reminds me.... I must post footage of the Chinese at play in a park in Chengdu. Lots of bandstand type structures in a relatively small area, filled to the brim with players vying to have the best time bashing out all manner of tunes
 
Once you are confident that you are keeping your place in the form, then trade fours with the rhythm section. I.e. play for four bars, lay out for four. This is a great way to improve your time feel. At this point, stick to the melody of the head in each four bars. For a blues, you get to play each section by alternating with the rhythm section, for a typical 32 bar standard you need to switch to playing the second four bars after laying out for the first four, so that you will play all of the head.

If you really feel up to it, then trade twos with the rhythm section. This is much more challenging, since the melody typically is in four bar phrases in many melodies.

Hi Bill,

I've only ever done fours half a dozen times, and I was doing it by guesswork, so this is interesting to read. I don't quite get what you mean about laying out for the first four in a 32 bar standard, can you explain a bit more?
 
@Bernie OK, in a standard 12 bar blues, such as Tenor Madness or Now's the Time, if you play for four bars then lay out for four, by the time you have played two choruses you will have played each part of the piece. In the first chorus, you will have played bars 1 to 4 and then bars 9 to 12; in the second chorus, you will play bars 5 to 8 and then in the next chorus you will be back to 1 to 4 and 9 to 8.

In a 32 bar standard, whether the form is AABA or ABCD or whatever, since there are 8 sets of 4 bars, the first time you play the whole number you will be playing bars 1 to 4, 9 to 12, 17 to 20 etc. In other words you never get to play bars 5 to 8, 13 to 16, etc. So if the second time through the whole number you lay out, i.e. don't play, for the first four bars, then play four bars, then lay out, then play, you will be playing all the bars you didn't play the first time round.

This is true whether you are just keeping your place in the form and playing the head in the bars that you play, or whether you are trading fours with another soloist such as another horn, piano, bass or guitar. The hardest to trade with is the drummer, since when a good jazz drummer solos he/she will typically play with the timing so you need to be really strong in your internal clock to keep the form and know when to come in when it is your turn. This is an essential skill in playing jazz, and is one of the things that keeps jazz fresh and fun.

Hope this is clear.

Bill
 
As it happens, I've booted up my computer just now in order to find a suitable recording of "Georgia on My Mind" so that I can learn what to play along with the rest of the band. Last night Colin the Bear advised me to start playing (or attempting to play) my accompaniment to the melody instead of playing the melody to backing track which is broadly the same advice as I'm receiving here.
 
Georgia is a great tune, but it is a complex harmonic structure, with minor and major two-five-ones liberally sprinkled through it. It is not the easiest place to start. Perhaps one of the simplest ways to build an accompaniment for it is to build a guide tone line from the 3rds and 7ths, plus any altered tones which define the harmony, for each of the chords in the piece. To make a smooth line, always move the minimum distance from each guide tone, for example in the first two bars of Georgia, the concert key progression is F for four beats, E half-diminished for two beats then A dominant 7 (altered) for two beats. If you start the guide tone line on the third of F (A) hold it for four beats, then move to the flat 5 of E half-dim (Bb) for two beats, then to the sharp nine of A7 altered, (C) you have an ascending guide tone line which brings out the key notes of the harmony.

Of course this is without referencing the melody. An alternative approach is to take the melody line, and play a note or notes from the chord of the moment. You can harmonise the melody and play in the same time and direction as the melody, or you can harmonise and move in the opposite direction to the melody. Remember that as an accompanist, your job is to make the soloist sound good, not to show how well you can play. For that reason I tend to use guide tone lines when I am playing behind a soloist, particularly another horn player. It is also important to make sure that your line is beneath the soloist, not only in volume, but also if possible in register. This can be a challenge for me since I play soprano, so I tend to play comping in the lower register of the instrument.

If you find that it is hard to build a comping line on the fly, then write out some guide tone lines and play them out of time till you are comfortable with them, then play them along with the track. In time you will be able to create lines as you play and respond to other musicians in their solo.

Bill
 
And this is the first track I've found in the key I'll use (F). I've had a go and I think it's doable. Reminds me of Wednesday night jam sessions at Antwerp Mansion - but that's another tale.
 
Thanks, Bill, but this is way beyond me at present. I'm going to resort to the crude method of playing something that sounds right. Incidentally, I shall not attempt to accompany the soloist. I'll blow only when the whole band's playing. The aim of the game is note to play the melody - that's for the trumpeter - but to blow something that fits with what everyone else is doing. I think I can do that. At least I can have fun trying!
 
That's seriously smooth saxophone playing. Is it a C-Melody?
Do they normally sound like that, or is it only Frankie Trumbauer?

(The saxophone I started on was a C-Melody, so my limited experience of them is out of tune with uneven tone. But after hearing one played properly, I might have to re-think my opinion!)
 
That's seriously smooth saxophone playing. Is it a C-Melody?
Do they normally sound like that, or is it only Frankie Trumbauer?

(The saxophone I started on was a C-Melody, so my limited experience of them is out of tune with uneven tone. But after hearing one played properly, I might have to re-think my opinion!)
Need a good mouthpiece on a C melody............it isn't easy finding one!
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,566
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom