Playing the saxophone Learning to Read v Playing by ear

Because it isn't so hard to do, plus it is a great way for you to improve your playing. Beginners that don't record tbh don't know what they really sound like, or how far out of time they are, or how out of tune they are, or not as the case may be..
Hi. Chris. I think you are missing my point, I am not suggesting it is not a good idea! Nor that people like myself would not benefit perhaps we would! I am simply saying that if I choose not to that I cannot see how you can disagree with my decision!

Of course if I were to argue that recording ones playing has no value then that it is something that is arguable and a position that could be disagreed with!

As I said I may go back to recording myself at the moment to much else to concentrate on!

Cheers
 
Stuart, if I think it's the wrong decision then I'll say so, based on how good a tool it is to help guys improve.
It helps with timing, tone and tuning, plus it forces you to listen to what other musicians are playing if you are using backing tracks. NOT ALL recording has to be done with the pc/backing tracks, a zoom recorder( or any recording device) and a metronome would be a starting point. Also not everything recorded is for public listening, it's a tool for the player.
 
Because it isn't so hard to do, plus it is a great way for you to improve your playing. Beginners that don't record tbh don't know what they really sound like, or how far out of time they are, or how out of tune they are, or not as the case may be..

My experience exactly. My first recordings taught me a lot about things I didn't realise I was getting wrong until I heard myself playing.
 
Improvisation, a really interesting topic. If you are part of the "jazz mafia" then you will know all about chord/scale relationships a la Berklee College in Boston. Of course Bird didn't know this, nor did many of the greats, they just played. It seems to me that there are several different schools of thought when it comes to improvising.

Greats like Louis Armstrong used the melody as a jumping off point, and this is always a good place to start. Utilising passing notes (chromaticism, enclosures, multiple approach notes) can all quickly lead to a very interesting improvisation yet still remind the listener of the melody. The blues is a good place to start with this (and of course could also be a good place to finish with it!)

Many of the bebop players then used the harmony of the piece to develop their improvisation - essentially using arpeggios from the harmony with scale fragments to join arps, and chromaticism, particularly over the V chord, giving a complex improvisation which still reminded the listener of the piece through harmonic similarity to the original.

Many blues players also learned a series of licks and riffs, which by judicious combination, provided them with a seemingly limitless well to draw on to provide improvisation in the blues idiom with differences in articulation, tone, dynamics, rhythm and so on providing the interest rather than the choice of notes themselves. Often old-school blues players will draw mainly from the major and minor blues scales for their entire improvisation, and yet still sound fresh and interesting.

Moving to modal playing, we then have a more scalar approach, exemplified by the seminal Miles Davis Kind of Blue album, still a benchmark for many of us. Here the harmony is pared right back, oftentimes to only one or two chords, and so only one or two basic scales (or modes of scales). Now the challenge is how to make this interesting. Listen to Miles solo on So What to see how you don't need to play lots of notes to make a musical statement that stands the test of time.

One of the myths that exists is that jazz greats played without any preconception of what they were going to play. While it is certainly true that most great solos were/are played in the moment, and develop organically, it is not true to say that they do not use pre-learned concepts and skills. If you doubt this, then listen to the several takes by John Coltrane on Giant Steps, or on Naima to see that he clearly had many ideas which he would reuse, albeit in interesting ways.

So, if you want to develop improvising skills, perhaps you might want to pick something that requires little technical thought (so don't start on Giant Steps!), that you are comfortable with, for example a blues or a standard ii V I, then start playing over the form. Give yourself some limitations, for example, only playing two out of every three bars, or always starting a phrase on the and of one, or only using chord tones and varying the rhythm - in the extreme, you could pick one note per bar and see how musical you can make this by timing and other means. Record yourself and listen back. Pick what you like and discard what you don't like.

Hope this helps,

Bill
 
A technical reason for likes and dislikes? I've always regarded it as essentially unfathomable.

It's the progressive move further away from the original tune - chromaticity (some I can like), then into modality, and it's these two steps that explain where jazz/blues and I part company. Throw in another factor - the players' personal sound and it's all clear to me. My likes are very much based on melody/harmony, tension from less harmonic structures like dominant 7th chords is OK if not overdone. But atonality/aggressive tone drive me away.
 
I've been invited to sit in with a local jazz band (they know I'm learning sax but have never heard me play) and my immediate aim is to reach a standard such that I dare do so, bearing in mind that there's an audience. I hope to do this soon and if I get a second chance I'll be able to try-out bits of "embroidery".
 
One of the things that never occurred to me when I took up saxophone is that it's not an instrument for a solo musician. Sure, people like Colin the Bear busk alone, but they take their bands with them in the form of backing tracks. Anyway, ever since I grasped this fact I've been looking for an opportunity to play with a band. I've tried sitting in with a couple of re-the-dots bands but that got me nowhere, partly because I find reading so difficult but mainly because it's not the way I want to play.

Now I consider myself extremely fortunate to be able to sit in with a local jazz band. Most of it members are much older than me and I think their purpose in having me sit in is for me to "learn the trade". The want newcomers to carry on their style of music.

There are plenty of opportunities for competent play-by-ear saxophonists but few for learners. How do you become competent without playing in a band? How do you get to play in a band without being competent? Catch 22!

To my mind the ideal would be beginners' bands, a few individuals who want to make music and who are willing to learn together. This shouldn't be a sax-only ensemble; there must be a rhythm section as well as a front line. Is there an internet forum for bringing such people together? If not, I wonder whether there would be any sense in the Cafe having a section open to allcomers listing learner saxophonists looking for opportunities?
 
@richardr Well done for getting to play regularly with a band. Just a couple of suggestions to develop your ability to play with a rhythm section.

First of all, listen to as much small group jazz as you can. With the likes of Spotify this is now so easy - I wish that we had had that opportunity when I was playing in the 60s!

Second, get a hold of some of Jamey Aebersold's play alongs, I am aware that some people look down their noses at them, but I know for a fact that many top US sax players use these playalongs for regular practice. Good Aebersold volumes to start with are Maiden Voyage and Killer Joe. There are no heads on these tracks, only rhythm sections. If you want to have some with the tunes, then you need to buy the likes of the Hal Leonard series, such the Blues or Bluesy Jazz. IMO the rhythm sections are nothing like as good, but Aldevis likes them because their tuning is better ;-)

Pick a couple of numbers, I would suggest one blues and one standard, and learn the heads. The best way is to listen over and over to a master recording then play by ear till you can play the head. If you want, you can use the dots on the playalong scores, but be aware that they are not always what was played. For example, Sugar by Stanley Turrentine has been simplified on the Killer Joe score. Once you can play along with a recorded head, then put on the playalong and practise playing the head over and over, making sure that you can keep your place in the form the whole way through.Record yourself playing along to check what you sound like and whether you are keeping good time or not.

For the next step, check out some of the ideas on these and other threads re improvising.

BTW, the saxophone is very definitely also a solo instrument. It is just not so commonly used as such!

Hope this helps,

Bill
 
To my mind the ideal would be beginners' bands, a few individuals who want to make music and who are willing to learn together. This shouldn't be a sax-only ensemble; there must be a rhythm section as well as a front line. Is there an internet forum for bringing such people together? If not, I wonder whether there would be any sense in the Cafe having a section open to allcomers listing learner saxophonists looking for opportunities?

Hi Richard,

I had been thinking along the same lines as you for quite some time, and feeling rather frustrated, but I found a solution: I went to a jazz workshop, picked out a few people who seemed to be playing at around the same standard as me, and asked them if they would like to get together. Happily they all said yes, which made me very happy, it reminded me of asking a girl out and her saying yes!

There's a bassist, a drummer, a guitarist and a piano player, and me on alto. We've got together 3 times now, and it's been everything I had hoped for.

There is one issue I am struggling with a little though: as you'll hear from this recording we are not yet ready to face a paying public (and maybe we never will be?):

View: https://soundcloud.com/saxynet/almost-like-almost-like-being-in-love


But I've heard it said that a band without gigs won't survive. So, I've had the idea that we might do a guerrilla tour: just turn up and play in bandstands in our local parks.

upload_2015-12-23_10-22-42.webp



Of course we wouldn't charge, and there might not even be an audience. But so far I have been hesitant to suggest this to the band, I suppose I am worried they will think it is a daft idea.
 
Bernie, I enjoyed listening to you and your band and so would many others, but the market for live jazz isn't huge so getting paid might be a problem. If you're willing to perform without payment a guerilla tour might be the way forward (is that any different from busking where you do get paid if you're any good?) but why not see if you can find a pub that will let you set up and blow on midweek (quiet) evenings? The two local bands that I follow both do that.
 
... we are not yet ready to face a paying public (and maybe we never will be?):
.
My Big Band isn't good enough to play for a paying audience either. So we play in a couple of local pubs that have weekly/monthly live music sessions. People are there mainly for a few drinks in the pub and we're live (and loud!) background music to the pub talk. We get a couple of free drinks and (sometimes) a small donation. We've played a couple of times at shopping centres and we also do one or two concerts at care homes. Care home residents are pleased to come and see/hear something different from their daily/weekly routine and are often our most enthusiastic audience! Maybe this will give you some ideas.

I liked the recording BTW!
 
Bernie, I enjoyed listening to you and your band and so would many others, but the market for live jazz isn't huge so getting paid might be a problem.

Thanks Richard! Personally I couldn't care less about getting paid, in fact it would almost go against my principles. But the others might feel differently about it

If you're willing to perform without payment a guerrilla tour might be the way forward (is that any different from busking where you do get paid if you're any good?)

Not really I suppose, except that if I was thinking of it as busking I would look for a location where we might attract an audience, or at least passers-by.

but why not see if you can find a pub that will let you set up and blow on midweek (quiet) evenings? The two local bands that I follow both do that.

Yeah, that is a good idea.
 
@billbluesnjazz, thanks for these recommendations. I practiced hard for the number to which I played along last night, mainly by playing to a headless backing track. The result was truly cringeworthy, but at least I could keep time and get back in when I panicked and lost the plot. But I couldn't have done that without having got the timing from sheet music in the first place. The next step in this direction is to learn to pick up timing, particularly when the melody includes longish notes, without resort to sheet music. For this I need to start by hearing the melody and learning the timing by ear, which tells me that I need backing tracks with heads to start with. I've an awful lot to learn before I'm halfway competent but I'm making progress.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,566
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom