Playing the saxophone Learning to Read v Playing by ear

Oh Ivan.....we should meet and have a few beers! Right eye lens replaced with plastic one because of cataracts. In photos my eye comes out white and the other one red! Will get the other one done in a couple of months.

Three bottom front teeth knocked out in the same tackle that did my wrist. Right knee awaiting a "scrape" out hopefully later this year. Chiropractor booked for my back!

Actually in comparison with some of my pals i am not doing so bad!!!! It is all relative and I'm not complaining when I see other peoples' situations.
 
Oh Ivan.....we should meet and have a few beers! Right eye lens replaced with plastic one because of cataracts. In photos my eye comes out white and the other one red! Will get the other one done in a couple of months.

Three bottom front teeth knocked out in the same tackle that did my wrist. Right knee awaiting a "scrape" out hopefully later this year. Chiropractor booked for my back!

Actually in comparison with some of my pals i am not doing so bad!!!! It is all relative and I'm not complaining when I see other peoples' situations.
Cataract operations are great things. If I hadn't had mine done a few years ago I wouldn't be driving now (or reading music, to get back on topic). Since having them done I've even taken up motorcycling. I've got to have something to do in retirement.
 
There's another argument for written music - it's preserved for posterity. I wonder how many tunes have been lost because only the words were written down.

another good reason for writing it down is that people who've taken the time to develop the skill can read the score and hear the music. This is a great boon for orchestra and choir leaders lokoing for pieces to add to their ensembles repertiores.

There's a place for written music, just as there's a place for playing by ear. Both have pros, both have cons. And to only accept one method is rather limiting.
 
I reckon there's something in it, it's also very interesting to hear from somebody who knows he was was too tied to written music but broke free.

I learned to read music early when I was playing in a marching/concert band. But I never use charts when I'm playing with oters. When I learn a song/part I use to read. And when I know the song I put away the the charts. It's easy for me because I just play Rocksax.

We are all differnt. In the 3-horn section I use to play one guy get so nervous when he see a chart so he is not able to play at all. Another guy needs the charts all the time. First thing to set up on the stage/place is the notstand!!! Not the sax, mpc or reed. I've tried to explain that it's not cool to read and pick up a notstand on a blues gig. 😉

So I use charts but I never read solos!! Some guys do!

Here is an sample. Some bars of the 24 bars solo in Springsteens song amrod. I think you should play solos like this "ad lib".

ramrod.webp
 
If it's my solo, no chart. If I'm playing someone else's well-known solo (in a tune like The Letter or Let's Stick Together) I'll almost always read it as there's more of a chance it will come out something like the original!
 
I think it is good if you can do both..read and play by ear,if you lack one of the skills it doesn't make you a bad player,i regularly go to a pub in bilston just down the road from Wolverhampton called The Trumpet they have live music seven nights a week and players use written music,and some don't,my tutor does the same and they are excellent musicians...and when do you stop being a beginner?.Bumnote.
 
If it's my solo, no chart. If I'm playing someone else's well-known solo (in a tune like The Letter or Let's Stick Together) I'll almost always read it as there's more of a chance it will come out something like the original!

Is there a good, well-known sax solo on The Letter ? On the live recording I have by Joe Cocker the sax solo is OK but not a classic (for me).

Rhys
 
I have three stages. If I play a song enough I start memorizing it without really trying to. If I hardly ever play it I need to read the music note for note. If I play it more often the music is there more to jog my memory while I play. Like a speaker refers to notes while giving a speech.
 
I like that moment when you find an old song in an old book. You've never heard it. You try it. You like it. You learn it. You perform it. They like it. Then some old boy comes up and directs you to a clip on youtube, taken from an early 20C 80rpm shellac disc, played on a lovingly restored wind up machine with hand made wooden needles by a band long gone. And....


you nailed it.
 
@Bernie It all depends on the individual player, also the type of jazz you want to play. If someone is happy playing ballads eg Autumn Leaves then fine do it by ear, If you want to play be-bop heads then learn to read it's easier, a couple of examples "Bouncing with Bud" or "Scrapple From The Apple" learn to read or by ear??
Not sure how you could learn the changes to a tune without knowing something of music theory, yes you might be able to make something fit over a tune, but that doesn't always make the changes, as they are/can improvised as well as the melody line, by using subs etc. Your point re the soloist that could play more naturally while improvising than reading is very true, also players that can play the written head in tune, but can't seem to improvise in tune. As for learning scales Hmmm! I'd best not go there for there be dragons

So is reading music the be all and and all to jazz? No far from it but it really does help, most of the the top jazz soloists players can/do read well. Just my humble opinion..
 
@Bernie It all depends on the individual player, also the type of jazz you want to play. If someone is happy playing ballads eg Autumn Leaves then fine do it by ear, If you want to play be-bop heads then learn to read it's easier, a couple of examples "Bouncing with Bud" or "Scrapple From The Apple" learn to read or by ear??

You need to read what I say more carefully Chris. I'm not saying people shouldn't read music or that there are no advantages to reading music, I'm saying that reading music isn't essential, but the ability to play by ear is.

Not sure how you could learn the changes to a tune without knowing something of music theory

Then you have something interesting and new to learn about music.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,567
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom