Playing the saxophone Learning to Read v Playing by ear

What I called "actual music" is sounds which are purposefully put into patterns, written music is instructions on how to make actual music.
So someone who can do that naturally is extremely talented and doesn't necessarily need to read music. I have never heard of "actual music" before either. Patterns are there to be interpreted and assist to make up different genres so I cannot follow with the "actual music" philosophy.
 
Last edited:
One of my conservatorium lecturers (the one who taught us musical analysis, orchestration and the like) always drummed into us that music is stuff that you hear. The little dots we write down as memory aids represent the sounds that make up music, but they are not the music itself.

In a perfect world I would have no need for written music. If I heard it once I could then play it, if I imagined it I could immediately realise it with instrument or voice. Sadly I'm not that good (not even close), and I rely on the crutch of written music for most of my performance. I can analyse music far better on paper than I can by ear (to my shame), which suggests to me that my musical education was a too biased towards the "on paper" aspect.

Written music is also a necessity rather than a convenience for musicians who need to play an ever changing repertoire, often with little rehearsal time. Professional symphony orchestras rarely play without written music, the main reason probably being economic - the extra rehearsal time needed to prepare a concert would be prohibitively expensive. It is also a far more efficient way of getting a group of musicians to play a complex arrangement than laboriously piecing it together by ear.

But I enjoy performing without music in an idiom that allows me to change things about a bit to suit myself, to go with my mood at the time, to take a risk without a safety net of little dots on a sheet of paper in front of me. I'm getting better at it as I get older.

Horses for courses.
 
So someone who can do that naturally is extremely talented and doesn't necessarily need to read music. I have never heard of "actual music" before either. Patterns are there to be interpreted and assist to make up different genres so I cannot follow with the "actual music" philosophy.

You're overcomplicating things.

Did you ever try playing the national anthem without written music? You said you were going to, then we heard nothing more.
 
Written music is also a necessity rather than a convenience for musicians who need to play an ever changing repertoire, often with little rehearsal time. Professional symphony orchestras rarely play without written music, the main reason probably being economic - the extra rehearsal time needed to prepare a concert would be prohibitively expensive. It is also a far more efficient way of getting a group of musicians to play a complex arrangement than laboriously piecing it together by ear.

All true. But the original question that this arose from was from a beginner. That's where the mistake is being made. Beginners are given the impression that the way you play music is by reading dots, or as you put it, their education is too biased towards the "on paper" aspect.
 
You're overcomplicating things.

Did you ever try playing the national anthem without written music? You said you were going to, then we heard nothing more.
Have only just got back to practising after a year of non playing due to hand injury so I shall give it a go tomorrow and report back Bernie. In addition, I like to challenge the members because I learn so much from you all so please don't take my posts as "rude", they are not intended to be and I value your responses and time, so thank you!!
 
Have only just got back to practising after a year of non playing due to hand injury so I shall give it a go tomorrow and report back Bernie.

Ooh, not nice. How did you injure your hand (if it's too embarrassing, make something up).

In addition, I like to challenge the members because I learn so much from you all so please don't take my posts as "rude", they are not intended to be and I value your responses and time, so thank you!!

Oh, I've never thought you were rude. Deranged yes, rude no.
 
Ooh, not nice. How did you injure your hand (if it's too embarrassing, make something up).



Oh, I've never thought you were rude. Deranged yes, rude no.
Made me laugh out loud, nice one! Bust my wrist backwards at 45 degrees playing rugby years ago. Had the wrist fused so it doesn't bend which led to tendon and carpal tunnel problems. So from rugby to sax!
 
I have a theory (totally unsubstantiated by any research that I am aware of) that playing by ear/reading the notes is somewhat analagous to native language/learned language. I believe there is research that shows that native language and learned languages are stored in different parts of the brain, and if similar is true of reading/non-reading music processing it may explain why many experienced readers find playing by ear and improvisation so daunting and difficult (that was certainly the case with me, but with perseverance I improved), and why so many very competent "ear" players resist playing from notation so adamantly. Switching from one method to the other seems almost like starting again.

Then again, this may be a total load of rubbish.

Q: How do you get a guitarist to play quietly?

A: Put a chart in front of him.
 
That's your story and so far you're sticking to it

But we're watching you Prof
Ha ha ha ha! Truth is stranger than fiction! It actually happened when I was playing in Aus. I went to the hospital rather quickly - driven by a pal - and they asked for a credit card as I had no insurance! When they asked me to sign the receipt I explained that as my writing hand was not "useable" at present will they accept a scrawl by my left hand! Two more operations back in Blighty as well. Wanna hear about the plastic lens in my right eye?!
 
Ha ha ha ha! Truth is stranger than fiction! It actually happened when I was playing in Aus. I went to the hospital rather quickly - driven by a pal - and they asked for a credit card as I had no insurance! When they asked me to sign the receipt I explained that as my writing hand was not "useable" at present will they accept a scrawl by my left hand! Two more operations back in Blighty as well. Wanna hear about the plastic lens in my right eye?!
Go ahead

A full and frank list of your implants might give us a laugh
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,567
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom