Saxophones Laquer n sound

to me, and many many others it is not clear at all that the incredibly small vibration of the wall have any influence an sound

the only serious experiment on flutes conclubed that there was no difference for materials ot thickness of walls.

About the Stadivarius , there was a famous test conducted in the '70 where modern violins were put in a blind test against several strads , many people identified as a strad a modern French violin.

Empiric tests based on sound identification by players and audience prove, tuime and time again that nobody really can identify an instrument by its sound.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
sure, soporific is the word, but these are like the endless medieval debates on the gender of angels , interest few are inconclusive and will never change the minds of a true believer, besides it is a debate which sense and purpose is debatable
 
the magic formula of the French sorcerers was lost and the first and second WW spent shell are gone.......... the secret is now in taiwan they use spent French and American shells found in Vietnam but the spells they casrt are not as good as the French spells
3903363079_be11c0b7a7.jpg
 
the magic formula of the French sorcerers was lost and the first and second WW spent shell are gone.......... the secret is now in taiwan they use spent French and American shells found in Vietnam but the spells they casrt are not as good as the French spells
3903363079_be11c0b7a7.jpg

lol, I was waitign for someone to say that they're not allowed to put lead in the brass any more.... And that would have been my chance >:)
 
they do..........>:)
img_A_category_2854_96855f1c9ccd15faecde8a5b83694954.jpg

lol - I meant in the alloy, but you make a good point. They used to add lead to the brass used for shell casings, maybe they still do - it acts as a lubricant and makes them easier to extract from the guns. Who cares about a little lead in the brass when people are chucking lumps of it around at high speed?
 
As said above "So subjective assessments based on personal experience are not necessarily valid "

We probably think that we sound best while playing instruments which we 'like' playing best .....and, because we play them with more confidence, that may well be so.
And that, in the end is, surely (as Davey so forcefully tells us) is what really matters in the long run?
Just keep playing the sax which you think suits YOU, and you will probably play it better than that Inderbinen which was forced upon you, against your better judgement 🙂))

IMO; the human mind has a much more powerful effect upon our perceptions of the minute sound differences involved, than any 'scientific measuring device' would show.

My bet would be that, if you put an expert player, who had no pre-conceptions/prejudices on the subject, behind a curtain and asked him/her to play, blindfold, lacquered and UL saxes of the same make & model, an audience of musicians and other audiophiles could not reliably pick the difference, and if they did(because of the unavoidable slight 'mechanical' differences' ), that they would not consistently say that the UL one sounded 'better'.

My teacher thinks his MkVI (which has lost about 20% of its lacquer) plays so well because of the brass from which it was made, and its relatively light weight ...... I say nothing 🙂
 
We probably think that we sound best while playing instruments which we 'like' playing best .....and, because we play them with more confidence, that may well be so.
And that, in the end is, surely (as Davey so forcefully tells us) is what really matters in the long run?

I agree. And arguments like the ones Milandro and others have put forward can change how we think and feel about these things. I play on cheap but usable saxes because, at this stage in my life, I have no choice. But I'm not in the least bit worried that the quality of the metal or laquer is holding back my progress. If I had doubts about those things, I expect they would make me less confident which would affect my playing.

If I ever move up to a "pro"-level horn, it will be for the qualtiy and reliability of the action, not for the mystique associated with a famous name. I accept that changes to the overall bore design will change the tone of a horn, but not minute details like laquer. Otherwise the slightest ding would ruin the sound. And we all know that's not true.
 
I think that there are differences between saxes that are made in the same "serie". From the first (with new tools) to the last (just before re-tooling) can be differences when it comes to the tone. How many saxes can be made with same tools and sold as a pro sax? 500, 1000 .... ? I think this can explain the difference between two identically horns.

Thomas
 
ARGHHHHHHHHHHHHH ITS ME AGAIN, ok folks i am in a mellow mood,must be the sunshine,this debate will never end so i stand down and i will go and blow my vibrating hunk of metel.
 
I've followed this thread, not quite sure which way to go, but with a sneaking suspicion that body material might affect tone through vibration. I did start to wonder if there was an analogy with a phenomenon well known to radio engineers, that of "skin effect". What happens in a radio frequency cable, very briefly, is that the energy penetrates the wire that is carrying it to a very small degree, an average value of which is known as the skin. The excitation creates eddy currents which can speed up or slow down the main energy in the cable slightly depending on where the eddy impinges on the wave front.

I wondered if something similar happened at audio frequencies with a wave of air in a tube. After all, the same laws of physics apply. If it did, this might account for slight differences in ostensibly simlar instruments, caused by minute variations in material thickness/ texture, but also perhaps the presence of laquer or lack of it on the outside which added/subtracted from the overall thickness (and therefore the skin depth inside). That the skin effect equivalent only happened very close to the surface of the inside of the body tube, also explains why holding a woodwind instrument has no effect on the sound (but doesn't really explain why players - me included -feel some vibration).

A bit of internet rsearch throws up some interesting links, all of them referring to Dr John Backus's work.
http://www.musictrader.com/effectsofwwbodymaterials.html
Does material affect tone quality in woodwind instruments?: Why scientists and musicians just can't seem to agree | Bret Pimentel, woodwinds

They all do conclude that material does in fact have no, or a negligible effect, on tone. There's the suggestion that the vibration players feel is in fact due to the reed itself, rather the air column vibrating through the body. There is also the conclusion that if a player thinks that a particular body material makes them sound better then it probably will, just out of the confidence it gives them. Backus' experiment is interesting as he concludes that body materal vibration (in a clarinet) has an effect 48dB down on the natural sound. That's a very small number - about 1/70,000th. And about 37dB more generally in woodwind instruments. So maybe the equivalent of a skin effect does exist, but if so, it is very small indeed.

So I think I am going to conclude, like others, that if you think it makes a difference, that's fine, and it probably will, because you think it will (that's why I love my matt laquer Mauriat!).

Going for a rest now.....
YC
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Am gannin doon stairs like ta blaw me vibrating bendy metal thing bonny lad like,ya nah wat i mean man,ya's tark odd doon sooth ,ya al mental like,we i ,gis a fishy on me dishy
 
Just to give YC a severe migraine.

Is that why waveguides are used at higher frequencies and would that help altissimo?

Doesn't that involve some magnetic influences?

Would the saxophone benefit if we fitted neodymium units down the body but where?

It is known that gravity bends light as the many instances of gravitational lensing in globular clusters proves, could that be the reason for the difference in sound between straight and curved instruments?

My brain hurts, Brian.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,576
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom