Accessories Key Leaves or Key Clamps?

See my previous post, then tell Ken Beason he doesn’t know what he’s talking about.

I imagine that Ken would be up to the task of rebuilding the tone hole chimney if you agreed that it was worth it.

Sad to see when that happens - filing a tone hole in an effort to flatten it, only to fail with not enough tone hole left to fix it.
 
I imagine that Ken would be up to the task of rebuilding the tone hole chimney if you agreed that it was worth it.

Sad to see when that happens - filing a tone hole in an effort to flatten it, only to fail with not enough tone hole left to fix it.
Yep, using the clamps I already had (free) was much cheaper than a major rebuild of the tone hole chimney. In any case, that horn is long gone. Haven't use any clamps since.
 
See my previous post, then tell Ken Beason he doesn’t know what he’s talking about.

OK, so, not enough 'meat' left on the toneholes?
Three options, just off the top of my head:

File the tonehole off, fit a soldered-on one in place.
Manipulate the body beneath the tonehole.
Fit an extension. Tricky, but doable - and if you weren't concerned about 'originality' you could always pop a 'pseudo roll' on it (a la Keilwerth).

I've done all of the above.
 
OK, so, not enough 'meat' left on the toneholes?
Three options, just off the top of my head:
I agree totally, using key clamps in that situation should not be an option.

All toneholes can be leveled and properly installed pads do not require clamps.

One of the best techs in the US told me one of mine couldn’t, not enough material left. Sure enough, part of the hole rose barely a mm above the body.
I took jbt's post to include provison of level tonehole whether it be by filing, manipulating the base, rebuilding, or some method hitherto unknown to mankind. I doubt any tech (however good or bad) would recommend to fix a grossly worn and unlevel (down to 1mm of chimney!) by using keyclamps except asa very emergency short term bodge.
 
I agree totally, using key clamps in that situation should not be an option.




I took jbt's post to include provison of level tonehole whether it be by filing, manipulating the base, rebuilding, or some method hitherto unknown to mankind. I doubt any tech (however good or bad) would recommend to fix a grossly worn and unlevel (down to 1mm of chimney!) by using keyclamps except asa very emergency short term bodge.
Well the horn continued to play fine for another 15 years for me. Next time I’ll get in my time machine and avoid the clamps so you lot are happy.
 
Well the horn continued to play fine for another 15 years for me.

I'm not disputing that. But I bet it was the tech's skill rather than the key clamps. I would think a further otion to fix that issue could have been very judicious bending of the key cup and/or pad floating/shims. I'm sure that could last very well when done by the right tech.
Next time I’ll get in my time machine and avoid the clamps so you lot are happy.
No need to, avoiding the key clamps is not what makes me happy🙂
 
I'm not disputing that. But I bet it was the tech's skill rather than the key clamps. I would think a further otion to fix that issue could have been very judicious bending of the key cup and/or pad floating/shims. I'm sure that could last very well when done by the right tech.

No need to, avoiding the key clamps is not what makes me happy🙂
Doesn’t sound like it. I just keep reading every other solution under the sun to avoid clamps. I only did what my tech told me, and it worked. We can second guess him indefinitely, but what’s done is done, and the results speak for themselves.

Besides, it’s ancient history now. If you don’t want to use clamps, don’t use them. But I would do it again in a heartbeat.

I’ve also ordered some knock off key leaves for my sticky Eb, so there.
 
All I can do is give my own opinion of the clamps. I used to have a set and used them. Like many things we all have different opinions and I see no harm in expressing them. (In spite of my signature) We might not have a forum otherwise.
 
At the shop I worked in for 7 years I did "play conditions" on countless student model saxophones with soft pads. Invariably the pads had deep indentations from the toneholes---even the normally open stack keys. On these saxophones it was very difficult to adjust the pads to correct for leaks or to do accurate regulation because there was no direct line of sight of the leak light. Due to time and cost restraints I had to work to the "that's good enough" standard and move on to the next "rental return". This experience helped to reinforce my belief that high quality pad work requires firmer pads and perfectly level toneholes. Pads with just a very light impression do not require key clamps to stay leak free. In my own shop I now have more control over the work I accept and the quality of work I turn out which is more satisfying and needless to say less frustrating.
 
A bit late to this discussion. I really like Key Leaves, they really stop mu G sharp sticking. One problem though is that the strap between the 2 wedges snapped at one of the holes, so I had to use some gorilla tap to reattached (Itried to make a new hole with a hot neddle but it just snapped again)
 
A bit late to this discussion. I really like Key Leaves, they really stop mu G sharp sticking. One problem though is that the strap between the 2 wedges snapped at one of the holes, so I had to use some gorilla tap to reattached (Itried to make a new hole with a hot neddle but it just snapped again)
If you have a chronically stick G#, clean the pad and the edges of the tonehole.

A sticky Eb is a similar issue - compounded by the fact that the tonehole is often the low point of the horn when it is stored in its case. Condensate collects there and often leads to a pad getting saturated or a tone hole corroding.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,062
Messages
578,402
Members
8,129
Latest member
Bartman
Back
Top Bottom