Mouthpieces Just invested in a pro mouthpiece (Beechler)

But seriously, reed instruments don’t need to warm up.
I always warm-up my saxes. I don't know where in USA you live but in Sweden it can be chilly and cold out in the woodshed (no heating). I play Martin saxes , thick wall with thick tone holes joints as well, and they can be tricky if I play in a room lets say 18 degrees Celsius. The cold metal cool of the air(stream) and the result can be a sharp and squeaking sax. The altos are easier to warm up compared to baritones.
 
If you cannot get through a tune, then I don’t see how you could be doing long tones properly.
The long tone exercises are tools to be able to get through a 2 hour concert/gig in an even way. I often hear sax players that are very good the first 45 min and after that ..... . I'm not talking about players on a high international or national standard, I'm talking about saxplayers in amateur bands. Fine readers and good technique but they haven't done their homework when it comes to how to reach out for 2 hours.
 
What most of my students do when making a big jump in tip opening is bite to close the reed gap back to what it was on their old mouthpiece. A sore jaw indicates to me that you're probably doing this too. So just relax the embouchure and give it time. If your reed is bent (won't lay flat), that confirms biting. Your jaw should never get sore.

Also pay close attention to intonation on the new mouthpiece. My guess is you're probably going sharp on the high end. It's counterintuitive, but push in the mouthpiece and open your jaw.
I was just going to say the same thing, take in more of the MPC, loosen your embouchure and blow straight into the MPC instead of up or down. A more open MPC isn't always more difficult, it mostly has a smaller range "of how you play it" at which it will sound good.
 
What is the difference in length of your long tones between the 4C and the Beechler? Test at quiet, medium-loud and loud.
It depends, I didn't really warm-up at all since I played the Beechler which I thought was a problem, but now I'm a bit confused on whether I should be doing scales and long-tones etc. at all or not.
Sir, yes sir! (salutes)

But seriously, reed instruments don’t need to warm up. My warmup on sax and clarinet usually consists of 3 short notes to make sure everything is still mechanically sound. Brass and flute need warmups for the lips and muscle memory. I’ll spend at least 5 minutes on those vs. 5 seconds on reeds.

Once you’re past the beginner phase, I think it’s a waste of time to play what you already know how to play. Practice what you CAN’T already play.

I do agree that long tones are essential for beginners. But you have to be focused on a nice, steady, controlled tone. Do just blow and get it over with. You want to sound beautiful.
Really I thought warm-ups were important because the sax changes tune as it gets warmer (for one) but that's interesting. I'd love to not have to waste time doing warm-ups!

An .085 is a big tip for most alto players. Its huge for a newish player. Not even a question. Put it away and play a .076 at most.
I would agree but personally I'm not really a new player, I'm fine calling myself a beginner in the sense that I haven't had any formal teaching on the sax, and I probably have some bad habits (I don't know how many different ways you can play the sax wrong, probably a lot! But that's a discussion for another thread perhaps) but I haven't just picked one up. I suppose it depends on your definition of new/beginner player. As I said earlier, I don't really know what level I'm at, but I've been playing sax on and off for years. But yeh I know it's a big tip-I could go for a Jody Jazz HR* 6 instead then? I was thinking of getting one of those anyway.

If you cannot get through a tune, then I don’t see how you could be doing long tones properly.

Long tones could be good at your stage and, if done right, will reveal whether your setup works for you.

What is your concept of “long tones”?
Just playing notes for as long as I can going up and down the sax
 
I always warm-up my saxes. I don't know where in USA you live but in Sweden it can be chilly and cold out in the woodshed (no heating). I play Martin saxes , thick wall with thick tone holes joints as well, and they can be tricky if I play in a room lets say 18 degrees Celsius. The cold metal cool of the air(stream) and the result can be a sharp and squeaking sax. The altos are easier to warm up compared to baritones.
Ah, yes, in the cold I blow through the horn to literally warm it up for sure. But that’s not often here in the southern US. I stop booking outdoor gigs for the season when it drops below 20 C. And my woodshed is in my house. I certainly don’t miss those chilly Christmas parades I had to march as a kid. Those were nothing compared to a Swedish winter, I’m sure.

I’ve got 8 hours of outdoor gigs this weekend, but the weather is just about perfect right now.
 
Really I thought warm-ups were important because the sax changes tune as it gets warmer (for one) but that's interesting. I'd love to not have to waste time doing warm-ups!
Well I was talking about the player warming up as an athlete would. But, yes, in cold weather it is important to literally raise the temperature of the horn to stay in tune.
 
It depends, I didn't really warm-up at all since I played the Beechler which I thought was a problem, but now I'm a bit confused on whether I should be doing scales and long-tones etc. at all or not.

Really I thought warm-ups were important because the sax changes tune as it gets warmer (for one) but that's interesting. I'd love to not have to waste time doing warm-ups!


I would agree but personally I'm not really a new player, I'm fine calling myself a beginner in the sense that I haven't had any formal teaching on the sax, and I probably have some bad habits (I don't know how many different ways you can play the sax wrong, probably a lot! But that's a discussion for another thread perhaps) but I haven't just picked one up. I suppose it depends on your definition of new/beginner player. As I said earlier, I don't really know what level I'm at, but I've been playing sax on and off for years. But yeh I know it's a big tip-I could go for a Jody Jazz HR* 6 instead then? I was thinking of getting one of those anyway.


Just playing notes for as long as I can going up and down the sax
So if you’re a bit more scientific about it - playing the same note in the same way on the 4C compared to the Beechler: are we talking a note length of 20s plus vs less than 10? Or more or less parity?
That would be one thing. Other than that it will be whether you can hold the note straight without wavering.
Then whether you can play all notes just as easily - Pete’s soft low Bb challenge.
Then fatigue: after 5 mins of long notes can you play anything else?
 
but push in the mouthpiece and open your jaw.
I was just going to say the same thing, take in more of the MPC,
My understanding is that Lydian was saying to push the mouthpiece further on to the cork and relax, not more in your mouth.

My thoughts are that it's impossible to say without seeing or hearing what may or may not be wrong with the embouchure re: the amount of mouthpiece in the mouth. Usually they need to take in less IME.
 
My understanding is that Lydian was saying to push the mouthpiece further on to the cork and relax, not more in your mouth.

My thoughts are that it's impossible to say without seeing or hearing what may or may not be wrong with the embouchure re: the amount of mouthpiece in the mouth. Usually they need to take in less IME.
That’s exactly what I was trying to say, to mitigate biting. Would be nice to see and hear what’s going on, at least a scale from top to bottom and some long notes.
 
That’s exactly what I was trying to say, to mitigate biting. Would be nice to see and hear what’s going on, at least a scale from top to bottom and some long notes.
Yes I agree with this as an antidote to biting - push mouthpiece on quite far so that the only way to bring the pitch down is by loosening embouchure and opening the throat
 
My understanding is that Lydian was saying to push the mouthpiece further on to the cork and relax, not more in your mouth.

My thoughts are that it's impossible to say without seeing or hearing what may or may not be wrong with the embouchure re: the amount of mouthpiece in the mouth. Usually they need to take in less IME.
Either way, you get your throat closer to the neck 🙂
 
Well I was talking about the player warming up as an athlete would. But, yes, in cold weather it is important to literally raise the temperature of the horn to stay in tune.
Ah ok well I live in the UK in a drafty old house so enough said! I just bought a tuner/metronome combo, do you recommend I check my tuning with that?

So if you’re a bit more scientific about it - playing the same note in the same way on the 4C compared to the Beechler: are we talking a note length of 20s plus vs less than 10? Or more or less parity?
That would be one thing. Other than that it will be whether you can hold the note straight without wavering.
Then whether you can play all notes just as easily - Pete’s soft low Bb challenge.
Then fatigue: after 5 mins of long notes can you play anything else?
I'll test myself on all these next time I play and let you know, I can't really say until I try again on it properly and time myself etc. should get a good session in over the weekend assuming I have time. I'll also see if I can get a semi decent recording as well (if I'm brave enough) as I agree that is the only way anyone is gonna know if I have any bad habits and/or need to change mouthpieces.

If your coming off a 4c Id stay with a meyer 5 size. .071 ish. 76 might be ok but there is really no reason to push sizes. Mouthpieces are like shoes. You need to have what fits. Otherwise walking is a pain.
Ok I'll look into something around the size 5s thank you.

My understanding is that Lydian was saying to push the mouthpiece further on to the cork and relax, not more in your mouth.

My thoughts are that it's impossible to say without seeing or hearing what may or may not be wrong with the embouchure re: the amount of mouthpiece in the mouth. Usually they need to take in less IME.
That was my understanding as well-push the mouthpiece in and then relax like I would when playing the lower notes?
 
Ah ok well I live in the UK in a drafty old house so enough said! I just bought a tuner/metronome combo, do you recommend I check my tuning with that?
No! You can use the tuner to get some baseline idea but you need to play against backing tracks AND record yourself to develop an ear. In the beginning, while you are playing, everything sounds good if you are able to hit the note you were trying to. But if you record yourself and listen to it, then typically the first listening will still be ok, the second one will raise some questions and if you wait for a day and then listen again, you'll cringe.

Don't worry, that's normal, and you will get better if you listen carefully and check where you are off and then take corrective action, even if it is just playing the same bar over and over until you develop the ear and the confidence to hit the notes how they were meant to be played.
 
@LostCircuits ah ok yeh that's basically what I've been doing so far anyway. Thank you for the advice, I definitely need to just concentrate on one song til I get it sounding ok. Yeh you can't fully concentrate on tuning issues whilst your playing or notice them until you record yourself and listen back. I tend to play bits of songs because I have SO many I wanna get through, but it's not much good if they all have mistakes because I don't ever practice one for long enough. Will try and do that from now on. It's better to play one song well than 20 badly!
 
If you find a good practice regime of 15-20 mins though, it will give you the grounding to enable you to play hundreds of songs, rather than feeling like you’re starting from scratch with every new tune you have a go at.
 
Go back and read the original post
I did.

OP has gone, as a beginner, from a 4C or 5C, can't remember exactly which, to a Beechler 7 which looks from a handy chart to be about equivalent to a Meyer 8, and now she can't manage to get through a whole phrase. Yep, way way too much mouthpiece for her. I already covered that issue when I re-told Andrew White's story.

Just for reference, if OP's still reading, I've been playing alto sax since 1978, my primary horn is baritone, and still I only use a Meyer 7 on alto. The vast majority of run-of-the-mill jazz alto players play a Meyer 6 or 5 as fully developed professionals. It's no surprise to anyone that a beginner on a whacking great piece a seasoned professional would have trouble controlling can't play the thing.

But then we diverged to a discussion of tone building strategies, and the latest discussion was me pointing out that once you get past the "mezzo-nothing" level with some degree of stability, you need to push your envelope a bit. This last bit of the discussion isn't really all that germane to the original discussion in the thread but is more of a general-case conversation. Last time I looked this was still allowed on the internet. If the rules have changed, someone needs to let us all know.
 
@turf3 I'm still here! I was on a 4C yeh. My cheeks get tired, I made the mistake of neglecting my practice for a while before I bought the Beechler because I just didn't like the 4C and didn't wanna play it (that was stupid). So my chops probably are weak. I made a recording-it's not bad, an improvement on the 4C (though it's also the first time I used a mic so that probably helps) I think it sounds in tune. I will get something more inbetween the 4C and Beecher (I really don't wanna go back to the 4C) and put the Beechler away for a bit. I know it's there for when I'm ready.

If I can I'll put a recording up anyway hopefully by the end of the week on the Beechler just for critique on my playing before I get another MPC 🙂

Edit-just out of interest, in what way would a pro struggle to control it? I thought it being hard to play meant it'd tire your chops out easier that's why I expected that but general consensus is that's not what the difficulty is?
 
Well, there's getting tired out prematurely. Then there's the added challenge of holding stable pitch with a bigger facing. Then if you use a softer reed, the pitch stability is less. You've got to blow harder to get the low notes out, but that makes it harder to play them softly or attack them delicately.

Experienced players find these things harder just like less-experienced players. Yeah, we'll power through it, but any time you find yourself working harder, you're going to give up something, whether it be endurance, dynamic range, tonal flexibility, or just spending more energy on playing the mouthpiece and less on playing interesting lines or what have you. For the seasoned pro who is willing to give up something to get what they get from a mouthpiece that's hard to play, that can be a perfectly reasonable choice.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,567
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom