Here’s the thing, @jools28. Beechler is a mouthpiece aimed at a specific use, namely saxophone playing in a loud pop/rock setting, where the player needs to compete with … er, blend with electric instruments and large amplifiers. And a 7 opening is quite large, which makes it harder to control.
A more standard mouthpiece, with a wider range of tonal colors, and in a smaller tip opening, is better for a beginning player. It’s difficult to make anything but a loud bright sound on a Beechler, even for a pro. On a Meyer, it’s possible to get a rich fulll brilliant sound, or a dark smoky wistful sound. This is why it’s the standard that it is. It cannot play as loud and strident as a Beechler, at least not easily, but it’s way more flexible.
The tip opening (the number of the mouthpiece) is another issue. The larger the tip onening, the more air you need to get a sound, AND the stronger your embouchure needs to be. Not because you need to press the reed harder, but you need good face strength to apply just the right amount of pressure to the reed and keep it constant.
It is for these reasons that people advise you not to play the Beechler until you have developed mastery over tone and dynamics. Which takes time and practice.
FWIW, I don’t suggest you get a Meyer, especially if you don’t have a teacher. A D’Addario Select Jazz 5M is a perfect next step from a Yamaha 4c - they are well made, very similar to a Meyer, but consistent - which Meyers are not. A Vandoren V5 size A25, or a V16 size A5, is another good option. Jody Jazz HR* in 5 is also good.
A more standard mouthpiece, with a wider range of tonal colors, and in a smaller tip opening, is better for a beginning player. It’s difficult to make anything but a loud bright sound on a Beechler, even for a pro. On a Meyer, it’s possible to get a rich fulll brilliant sound, or a dark smoky wistful sound. This is why it’s the standard that it is. It cannot play as loud and strident as a Beechler, at least not easily, but it’s way more flexible.
The tip opening (the number of the mouthpiece) is another issue. The larger the tip onening, the more air you need to get a sound, AND the stronger your embouchure needs to be. Not because you need to press the reed harder, but you need good face strength to apply just the right amount of pressure to the reed and keep it constant.
It is for these reasons that people advise you not to play the Beechler until you have developed mastery over tone and dynamics. Which takes time and practice.
FWIW, I don’t suggest you get a Meyer, especially if you don’t have a teacher. A D’Addario Select Jazz 5M is a perfect next step from a Yamaha 4c - they are well made, very similar to a Meyer, but consistent - which Meyers are not. A Vandoren V5 size A25, or a V16 size A5, is another good option. Jody Jazz HR* in 5 is also good.
