Great Players Joe Farrell

Reply from the recording studio engineer Richard Vernon;

"hi john......mike is certainly correct, raphael ravenscroft and no other played the sax solo on Baker Street.....i was present at the session at Chipping Norton Recording Studios so hopefully you can take my word for it.....the Bob Holness connection started as a joke and became an urban myth......al newman i’ve never heard of.

i hope this sets the record straight? (no pun intended)."

regards richard
Fri, Dec 7, 2018 11:25 am
 
Reply from the recording studio engineer Richard Vernon;

"hi john......mike is certainly correct, raphael ravenscroft and no other played the sax solo on Baker Street.....i was present at the session at Chipping Norton Recording Studios so hopefully you can take my word for it.....the Bob Holness connection started as a joke and became an urban myth......al newman i’ve never heard of.

i hope this sets the record straight? (no pun intended)."

regards richard
Fri, Dec 7, 2018 11:25 am

Maybe of interest - interview with the man himself...

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jwO0Mgzlg3I


Greg S.
 
When >I saw the name Joe Farrell, I immediately thought of this one: (I recall the flute in Spain, but there's a soprano solo on 500 MIles High, the 3rd song). Stanley Clarke looks like he's about 15! These guys were smokin' and they made instrumental jazz pop up again for a minute.
 
Reply from the recording studio engineer Richard Vernon;

"hi john......mike is certainly correct, raphael ravenscroft and no other played the sax solo on Baker Street.....i was present at the session at Chipping Norton Recording Studios so hopefully you can take my word for it.....the Bob Holness connection started as a joke and became an urban myth......al newman i’ve never heard of.

i hope this sets the record straight? (no pun intended)."

regards richard
Fri, Dec 7, 2018 11:25 am

In light of this statement - and I do believe that Raff played that solo - am still troubled in some existential way that Al Newman would claim to have played on Baker Street. As I said earlier in this thread, I knew him in his later years and he was not the sort of person to make a false claim - he had absolutely no reason to do so, he had been a very successful session player at the height of the scene in the 60s and 70s and was very comfortably off in old age.
I guess I will never get to the bottom of that particular conundrum! One for the Great Gig in the Sky.
 
Thanks David. Keep in mind that his son, Jonathan Newman is making the claim.

In our research we have found several musicians who have indicated that they played on a particular hit recording which was not the case. A few of those include; "Return To Sender" by Elvis, "The Heat Is On" by Glenn Fry, "Stagger Lee" by Lloyd Price, "Calendar Girl" by Neil Sedaka, "Spooky" by the Classic IV, "Rockin' Around The Christmas Tree" by Mel Smith and Kim Wilde.

We just want credit given to the correct musician.
 
Thanks David. Keep in mind that his son, Jonathan Newman is making the claim.
.......
Al Newman himself made that claim to me and seemed genuinely angry about it. It's a puzzler for sure.


......In our research we have found several musicians who have indicated that they played on a particular hit recording which was not the case. A few of those include; "Return To Sender" by Elvis, "The Heat Is On" by Glenn Fry, "Stagger Lee" by Lloyd Price, "Calendar Girl" by Neil Sedaka, "Spooky" by the Classic IV, "Rockin' Around The Christmas Tree" by Mel Smith and Kim Wilde.

We just want credit given to the correct musician.

Yes indeed.
 
Oh, I did not realize that. I could understand it if the studio person stated that they recorded several players and settled on the late Rafael but that does not appear to be the case. Oh well.
 
I received a note on Facebook from a Leo Green indicating that a Ray Gelato played the solo. And Ray agreed. However it was Pete Thomas who played the solo on the "released hit" recording. It was confirmed by a Mr. Colman who asked/hired Pete to play the solo.
 
I saw Ray Gelato last year - still going strong. Here he is a while back playing another song that Pete does.


And I saw Leo Green (Benny Green's son) playing about ten years ago. He also played with Jerry lee Lewis, Van Morrison, Jools Holland and others.


Rhys
 
Interesting detour, folks. Just a note about Wikipedia. It's a good place to grab info on something you know nothing about. It's also chock full of misinformation. I had some experience with editors some years ago. We were writing about a château in France. The fact in question was documented in official records and the editor chose to think he knew better, and kept re-editing the article. This is clearly against their rule about documentation. Some editors have no other power in their lives and so abuse their position. Never take anything in Wikipedia for strict fact. I've also seen birth dates of people I know personally that are patently wrong. Some of the editors are like the guy in the parking lot with a flashlight. As someone said, musicians credits anywhere are often either wrong of contain omissions.
 
I saw Ray Gelato last year - still going strong. Here he is a while back playing another song that Pete does.


And I saw Leo Green (Benny Green's son) playing about ten years ago. He also played with Jerry lee Lewis, Van Morrison, Jools Holland and others.


Rhys

I have a CD by Leo Green called "Sax Moods" - he does a sax instrumental version of "Albatross" by Fleetwood Mac...

Greg S.
 
"I agree David and I do not know either. We just report what our research has found over the years which is a part of the document."

Reply from the recording studio engineer Richard Vernon;

“hi john......mike is certainly correct, raphael ravenscroft and no other played the sax solo on Baker Street.....i was present at the session at Chipping Norton Recording Studios so hopefully you can take my word for it.....the Bob Holness connection started as a joke and became an urban myth......al newman i’ve never heard of.

i hope this sets the record straight? (no pun intended).”

regards richard
Fri, Dec 7, 2018 11:25 am
 
That's interesting John, but Al Newman said he did the session at Rodmarton Street in London's West End (I recorded there in the 80s too, but the studio is no longer there AFAIK), so this leads me to believe that Al is not making things up, but may have participated in an entirely different set of sessions.
I wonder if he played on a cover version? It was common for the Musician's Union to stipulate a re-recording for use on BBC's Top of the Pops (long running chart show in UK). These MU stipulated re-recordings were not actually used: after all, who wants a track recorded and mixed in 3 hours by bunch of sessioneers when you spent days and thousands of ££ producing a hit record? They were done to satisfy the MU.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,058
Messages
578,289
Members
8,127
Latest member
PJ2116
Back
Top Bottom