Playing the saxophone Jambalaya - versions and keys

Why should we consider the vocal when we don't have any vocal on backing track? The saxplayer decide the best key for he/she. I would like to do that song in (concert) Bb (C tenor , G alto). I just read that Darlene Love had to sing in lower keys in the end of a long tour. And if she was going to record a song the same day as a tour was over she would probably sing in Eb, D .... instead of E.
Hey @thomsax ... its a bit different for me....I am not at the stage yet where I can improvise, please refer to my cunning plan above.....I use the words as my tempo and rhythm I play on my own so it doesn't mater once I've nailed the song I will start improvising over the instrumentals..then get a backing track without the lyrics and so words or keys wont matter....all through this I am still trying to have some lessons to speed up my reading......don't think I'll ever be fast enough tho tbf....
 
Hey @thomsax ... its a bit different for me....I am not at the stage yet where I can improvise, please refer to my cunning plan above.....I use the words as my tempo and rhythm I play on my own so it doesn't mater once I've nailed the song I will start improvising over the instrumentals..then get a backing track without the lyrics and so words or keys wont matter....all through this I am still trying to have some lessons to speed up my reading......don't think I'll ever be fast enough tho tbf....
I understand but I still think you should try to learn by ear/heart. Sooner or later I think you must do this. You can cut up the song in smaller pieces and play the melody or give tones to the words/lyrics. Singing or huming is a good way to learn the music. Lots of good saxplayers that are playing songs like this. But do your own version. When I started to learn songs from recordings, I never tried to sound as the saxplayer on the recordings. We need more saxplayers that are doing thier own things. I was "impossible" already when I started to play back in the late 60's/early 70's. Bad saxophones (Conn Shooting Star alto and an Amati tenor), too big mouthpieces that my father gave me, lack of tallent ... but that didn't stop me. I'm still honking (I started again just before Christmas) and I enjoy it. There is space for all saxplayers.
 
Hey @thomsax ... its a bit different for me....I am not at the stage yet where I can improvise, please refer to my cunning plan above.....I use the words as my tempo and rhythm I play on my own so it doesn't mater once I've nailed the song I will start improvising over the instrumentals..then get a backing track without the lyrics and so words or keys wont matter....all through this I am still trying to have some lessons to speed up my reading......don't think I'll ever be fast enough tho tbf....
You don't have to be able to improvise to play a simple melody without dots.

Can you sing "Happy Birthday" or "God Save the Queen"? Now do the same thing - WITHOUT DOTS - on your sax.

From either of those songs (or pick something else you know well, "Silent Night", "Mary had a little lamb", etc.) to "Jambalaya" isn't much of a stretch. We're not talking about "Joy Spring" or a Bach three part invention, here.
 
Hey @thomsax ... its a bit different for me....I am not at the stage yet where I can improvise, please refer to my cunning plan above.....I use the words as my tempo and rhythm I play on my own so it doesn't mater once I've nailed the song I will start improvising over the instrumentals..then get a backing track without the lyrics and so words or keys wont matter....all through this I am still trying to have some lessons to speed up my reading......don't think I'll ever be fast enough tho tbf....
@thomsax really nailed it, you need to use your ears. When I started playing, I got my first gig after ~ 3 or 4 months. I didn't know most of the songs, I didn't know how to play but, as the guy who hired me put it, the 3 or 4 notes I played were right on and more importantly, that I didn't play when I didn't know what to play. Then the main guy from Shakedown Street heard me and asked me to sit in and jam to their Grateful Dead covers. I've never been much of a Dead Head so I only vaguely knew the songs and for the life of it, I would not have been able to play the melody so I just had to figure out something that worked. Guess what, the recurring question was "How in the world did you come up with that solo?"

If I had to listen to any of this stuff today, I would probably sell all my gear and never show up again anywhere but the point is that you don't want to tie yourself too much to the melody. A very good exercise is to let Youtube, Spotify or whatever select the play list and just try to play along regardless of whether you know the song or not. There will be phases where you think you are stale and not learning anything but it's kind of a "step function" that all of a sudden you realize you made some progress and you can play things that you never thought you'd master.

And forget about long tones, at least in this context. Concentrate on playing "in time", which is THE most important part of improvisation. Any note will sound good when you are on the beat. And increase your skill level by playing the Youtube videos at 1.25x, 1.5x speed just to try to keep up. And then you go back to normal speed and magically it is easy.
 
@eb424 Forget the dots and sheet music for a while. Try sing/play the words with a drum beat. The drums below is 2/4 beat rhumba that is more in style of Fats. This is basic. The tempo is ok, not to slow or not to fast. Just you and the "drummer". Start to play it in C on tenor or alto.
View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4FDAicntoVI


A train beat country groove is also fine.
View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4mqZPb9UUgs


Also surf beat is ok .....
View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4mqZPb9UUgs


Reggae beat ...
View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cs0TOWpUzFw&list=RDS__WiRWN0Ic&index=3


Blues shuffle
View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qCjTkhdxhgk&list=RDS__WiRWN0Ic&index=9


Songs like Jambalaya is pretty open to differnt styles/grooves.

Don't look too deep into the sheet music. Pratctice rhythm and differnt groves as well.
 
@eb424 Forget the dots and sheet music for a while. Try sing/play the words with a drum beat. The drums below is 2/4 beat rhumba that is more in style of Fats. This is basic. The tempo is ok, not to slow or not to fast. Just you and the "drummer". Start to play it in C on tenor or alto.
View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4FDAicntoVI


A train beat country groove is also fine.
View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4mqZPb9UUgs


Also surf beat is ok .....
View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4mqZPb9UUgs


Reggae beat ...
View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cs0TOWpUzFw&list=RDS__WiRWN0Ic&index=3


Blues shuffle
View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qCjTkhdxhgk&list=RDS__WiRWN0Ic&index=9


Songs like Jambalaya is pretty open to differnt styles/grooves.

Don't look too deep into the sheet music. Pratctice rhythm and differnt groves as well.
Hey thanks @thomsax defo getting to a rocksax workshop....
 
I just listened to the Carpenter's version for the first time.

The flute intro is just the melody with some rhythmic variation. You can easily duplicate that on sax.

The flute fills are short just diatonic phrases. The first one is scale degrees 5435---, then 53215---, then 1543---, and finally 5b551531. I didn't go any further than that since it sounds like the same ones are just repeated.

You apparently want someone to add a flute track to your backing track. But we've been trying to convince you that's not necessary. Play the flute intro on sax if you wish, or play Pete's example bass line if you like. The rest will sound fine without any fills.

You could use this backing track with synth flute and synth horns fills:
View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M6bZwIVZgkE
 
Last edited:
I’d always thought it was a wind synth on the intro. At one time I did learn the flute solo.

Quite tricky with a nice quote on High Society.

Tom Scott?
 
I’d always thought it was a wind synth on the intro. At one time I did learn the flute solo.

Quite tricky with a nice quote on High Society.

Tom Scott?
Tom played on a few Carpenters tunes. But credit for this particular one goes to Bob Messenger who also played sax on other Carpenters tunes.
 
I just listened to the Carpenter's version for the first time.

The flute intro is just the melody with some rhythmic variation. You can easily duplicate that on sax.

The flute fills are short just diatonic phrases. The first one is scale degrees 5435---, then 53215---, then 1543---, and finally 5b551531. I didn't go any further than that since it sounds like the same ones are just repeated.

You apparently want someone to add a flute track to your backing track. But we've been trying to convince you that's not necessary. Play the flute intro on sax if you wish, or play Pete's example bass line if you like. The rest will sound fine without any fills.

You could use this backing track with synth flute and synth horns fills:
View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M6bZwIVZgkE
Hey thanks for that i was going to take your advice and leave the flute section its just something to noodle over the instrumental and the outro..mines the karaoke version..im sure ive put a link..in another thread it has to be done on audaciy..
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,074
Messages
578,636
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom